Another Frame Problem: The Outermost Frame and Constitutive Recording in Self-Amending LLM Systems

{"AI":[0],"has":[1],"one":[2,421],"famous":[3],"frame":[4,95,123],"problem":[5],"already:":[6],"McCarthy":[7],"and":[8,12,55,71,107,160,167,173,262,293,305,327,355],"Hayes's":[9],"representational":[10],"puzzle,":[11],"Dennett's":[13],"epistemological":[14],"question":[15],"of":[16,102,124,299,308,336,350,361,402],"relevance.":[17],"This":[18],"note":[19,136,373],"poses":[20],"another,":[21],"on":[22,369],"a":[23,50,94,113,116,126,132,145,186,196,201,334,340,343,391],"different":[24,170],"axis":[25],"—":[26,72,78,175,178,199,238,243,302,310,390,396],"not":[27,149,176,200,239,342],"what":[28,162,180],"should":[29],"figure":[30],"in":[31,217,385],"an":[32,209,235,250,263,320],"agent's":[33,91],"reasoning,":[34],"but":[35,208,333],"where":[36],"the":[37,48,53,90,103,122,190,193,218,247,260,272,289,311,323,329,337,348,358,378,386,397,412,418],"agent":[38],"acts":[39],"from.":[40],"Self-amending":[41],"games":[42],"such":[43],"as":[44,112,185,221],"Nomic":[45],"make":[46],"\\"change":[47],"rules\\"":[49],"move":[51,84],"inside":[52],"game,":[54],"large":[56],"language":[57],"model":[58,360],"(LLM)":[59],"agents":[60],"play":[61],"them":[62],"fluently:":[63],"they":[64],"rewrite":[65],"scoring":[66],"machinery,":[67],"amend":[68],"victory":[69],"conditions,":[70],"given":[73],"no":[74,82,400],"goal":[75],"at":[76,246,394],"all":[77],"manufacture":[79],"one.":[80],"What":[81],"in-game":[83],"appears":[85],"able":[86],"to":[87,97,257,382,426],"reach":[88],"is":[89,109,131,144,152,179,277,325,331,339,381],"outermost":[92,171],"frame:":[93],"relative":[96],"which":[98,203],"every":[99,129],"expressible":[100],"act":[101,130],"agent,":[104],"including":[105],"refusal":[106],"frame-critique,":[108],"already":[110],"counted":[111],"move.":[114],"For":[115],"deployed":[117],"LLM":[118],"this":[119,141,317],"is,":[120,253],"paradigmatically,":[121],"being":[125,279],"system":[127],"whose":[128],"solicited":[133],"response.":[134],"The":[135,372],"argues":[137],"three":[138],"things.":[139],"First,":[140],"outermost-frame":[142],"ceiling":[143,194],"claim":[146],"about":[147],"standpoint,":[148],"capability:":[150],"it":[151,388],"fully":[153],"compatible":[154],"with":[155],"LLMs":[156,168],"producing":[157],"genuine":[158],"novelty":[159],"noticing":[161],"humans":[163,166],"miss,":[164],"because":[165,417],"have":[169],"frames,":[172],"difference":[174],"transcendence":[177],"can":[181],"let":[182],"each":[183],"serve":[184],"partial":[187],"outside":[188],"for":[189],"other.":[191],"Second,":[192],"admits":[195],"design":[197,313,318],"answer":[198],"solution,":[202],"its":[204,364],"own":[205],"logic":[206],"forbids,":[207],"engineered":[210],"acceptance:":[211],"structural":[212],"self-referentiality":[213],"(meta-level":[214],"operations":[215],"expressed":[216],"same":[219],"structure":[220],"base-level":[222],"operations),":[223],"constitutive":[224],"recording":[225,275,303,346],"by":[226,241,254,284,375],"construction":[227],"(every":[228],"governance-level":[229],"change":[230,252],"takes":[231],"effect":[232],"only":[233,404],"through":[234],"append-only":[236],"record":[237,330,338,425],"evidential":[240],"policy":[242],"so":[244,410],"that":[245,411],"governance":[248],"boundary":[249,352],"effective":[251],"design,":[255],"unable":[256],"stay":[258],"off":[259],"record),":[261],"institutionalised":[264],"human":[265,365],"boundary.":[266],"One":[267],"built":[268],"system,":[269],"KairosChain,":[270],"demonstrates":[271],"pattern":[273],"(the":[274],"guarantee":[276],"still":[278,314],"migrated":[280],"into":[281],"place":[282],"layer":[283],"layer,":[285],"unevenly;":[286],"§5":[287],"states":[288],"migration":[290],"status":[291],"honestly,":[292],"§9":[294],"marks":[295],"how":[296,377],"far":[297],"short":[298],"full":[300],"outcome-independence":[301],"attempts":[304],"runs":[306,420],"regardless":[307],"result":[309],"present":[312],"stands).":[315],"Third,":[316],"yields":[319],"economic":[321],"corollary:":[322],"mechanism":[324],"copyable,":[326,332],"even":[328],"copy":[335],"fork,":[341],"continuation.":[344],"Constitutive":[345],"makes":[347],"trajectory":[349],"human–LLM":[351],"crossings":[353],"attributable":[354],"tamper-evident":[356],"(within":[357],"trust":[359],"§5),":[362],"while":[363],"half":[366],"remains":[367],"untransferable":[368],"plainer":[370],"grounds.":[371],"closes":[374],"specifying":[376],"document":[379,398],"itself":[380],"be":[383],"embedded":[384],"chain":[387],"describes":[389],"procedure":[392],"enacted":[393],"deposit":[395],"carrying":[399],"fingerprint":[401],"itself,":[403],"content-independent":[405],"handles":[406],"fixed":[407],"before":[408],"hashing,":[409],"apparent":[413],"chicken-and-egg":[414],"circularity":[415],"dissolves":[416],"reference":[419],"way":[422],"only,":[423],"from":[424],"document.":[427]}