Falsification of the Constructed Cipher Class for the Voynich Manuscript Across Thirteen Folios: A Substrate Grammar Distinguishability Argument at v3 Catalog Scope (1014 Trials) and v4 Substrate Grounded Hartlieb Tradition Scope (351 Trials)

{"The":[0,260,312,342,406,533],"Voynich":[1],"Manuscript":[2],"(Beinecke":[3],"MS":[4],"408)":[5],"has":[6,50],"carried,":[7],"for":[8,148,263,403],"more":[9],"than":[10,83,201,476],"a":[11,13,24,28,35,39,52,59,85,99,135,241,274,399,438,464,472,521],"century,":[12],"parallel":[14],"literature":[15,49],"claiming":[16],"the":[17,21,47,72,89,94,105,111,115,158,202,206,216,269,286,301,324,333,356,365,372,427,458,481,487,529,541,554],"surface":[18],"text":[19],"is":[20,74,252,267,272,298,349,433,442,463,469,486],"output":[22,197,297,330],"of":[23,31,117,215,224,327,346,371,454,504],"constructed":[25,343],"cipher,":[26],"either":[27],"genuine":[29],"cipher":[30,41,67,119,159,295,329,344,466],"pre-1500":[32],"vintage":[33],"or":[34,79],"later":[36],"forgery":[37,347],"applying":[38],"known":[40,118],"method.":[42],"Every":[43],"such":[44],"test":[45,214],"in":[46,368,565],"public":[48],"used":[51],"single":[53],"acceptance":[54,95],"criterion:":[55],"lexical":[56],"recovery":[57],"against":[58,232,277,285],"natural":[60,557],"language":[61,366,376],"dictionary.":[62],"Under":[63],"that":[64,198,246,527],"criterion,":[65],"every":[66],"trial":[68],"returns":[69,222],"NULL,":[70],"and":[71,134,151,293,323,397,410,468,547,559],"result":[73,408,462,534],"read":[75],"as":[76,84,161,471,477],"\\"not":[77,80],"Latin\\"":[78],"German\\"":[81],"rather":[82,475],"structural":[86,145,170,242,261],"constraint":[87],"on":[88,451,502],"surface.":[90],"This":[91],"paper":[92],"changes":[93],"criterion.":[96],"We":[97],"define":[98],"substrate":[100,189,207,270,369,413,478,484],"operator":[101],"grammar":[102,208,417],"scorer":[103,271,401,465],"over":[104,300],"chip":[106,302],"class":[107,291,335,345],"lexicon":[108],"attested":[109],"across":[110,164,236,355,419],"manuscript,":[112],"then":[113],"run":[114],"catalog":[116,160],"methods":[120],"from":[121,157,168],"antiquity":[122],"through":[123],"2026,":[124],"including":[125],"representative":[126,136],"modern":[127,264,328],"computationally":[128],"secure":[129],"primitives":[130],"(DES,":[131],"AES,":[132],"ChaCha20)":[133],"post-quantum":[137],"sample":[138],"(Kyber,":[139],"NTRU,":[140],"McEliece,":[141],"BIKE,":[142],"HQC,":[143],"plus":[144,186],"simulation":[146],"rows":[147],"SPHINCS+;":[149],"Dilithium":[150],"other":[152],"signature":[153],"schemes":[154],"are":[155],"excluded":[156],"categorically":[162],"non-encryption),":[163],"thirteen":[165],"folios":[166,499,506],"drawn":[167],"six":[169,225,237],"sections":[171],"(cosmographic,":[172],"herbal,":[173],"balneological,":[174],"pharmaceutical,":[175],"cosmological,":[176],"zodiac,":[177],"rosettes":[178],"foldout).":[179],"Across":[180],"1014":[181],"v3":[182],"(cipher,":[183],"key)":[184],"trials":[185,191],"351":[187,420],"v4":[188,360,421],"grounded":[190,414],"(1365":[192],"total),":[193],"zero":[194,223],"combinations":[195],"produce":[196],"scores":[199,321],"higher":[200],"unciphered":[203,319,490],"manuscript":[204,320,555],"under":[205,435],"scorer.":[209],"A":[210,359,423],"separate":[211,424],"generator":[212],"side":[213],"Cardano":[217],"grille":[218,227,248],"hypothesis":[219],"(Rugg":[220],"2003)":[221],"tested":[226,357],"configurations":[228],"achieving":[229],"distribution":[230,238,283,339],"match":[231,284],"any":[233,247,294,452],"real":[234],"folio":[235],"statistics,":[239],"with":[240,507],"argument":[243,262],"(Section":[244,362],"7.3)":[245],"reading":[249],"multi-chip":[250],"syllables":[251],"forced":[253,444],"to":[254,305,445],"over-produce":[255],"token":[256],"length":[257],"by":[258,310,336,540],"construction.":[259,311],"strong":[265,508],"ciphers":[266],"reframed:":[268],"not":[273,536,552,561],"cryptographic":[275],"distinguisher":[276],"uniform":[278,299],"random;":[279],"it":[280],"measures":[281],"alphabet":[282,303,338],"manuscript's":[287,488],"empirically":[288],"non-uniform":[289],"opener":[290,308],"distribution,":[292],"whose":[296],"falls":[304],"~10/22":[306],"mean":[307],"fit":[309],"empirical":[313],"25-45":[314],"percentage":[315,523],"point":[316,524],"gap":[317],"between":[318],"(0.74-0.98)":[322],"null":[325],"floor":[326],"(0.32-0.58)":[331],"closes":[332],"entire":[334],"this":[337,352],"mismatch":[340],"(Observed).":[341],"hypotheses":[348],"falsified":[350],"at":[351,412,494],"evidence":[353,370],"level":[354],"folios.":[358],"extension":[361],"10)":[363],"re-grounds":[364],"scope":[367,415,497],"1450s":[373],"Hartlieb":[374],"tradition":[375,389],"stack":[377],"(Hebrew,":[378],"Arabic,":[379],"Greek":[380],"register":[381],"switching,":[382],"Mittelhochdeutsch,":[383],"Latin":[384],"medical":[385],"/":[386],"Cappelli,":[387],"Mandeville":[388],"exotic":[390],"alphabets,":[391],"namenmantik,":[392],"sign":[393],"legend,":[394],"alchemical":[395],"sigla)":[396],"adds":[398],"second":[400],"dimension":[402],"shorthand":[404],"fit.":[405],"falsification":[407],"holds":[409,501],"strengthens":[411],"(0":[416],"hits":[418],"trials).":[422],"observation":[425],"about":[426],"al-Manazil":[428],"mod-28":[429,491],"block":[430],"(Block":[431],"B)":[432],"reported":[434,470],"explicit":[436],"scope:":[437],"position":[439],"cyclic":[440],"substitution":[441],"mathematically":[443],"score":[446],"volvelle":[447],"traversal":[448],"strength":[449],"1.0":[450],"input":[453],"sufficient":[455],"length,":[456],"so":[457],"Block":[459],"B":[460],"strength=1.0":[461],"tautology":[467],"methodology":[473],"landmark":[474],"positive":[479],"evidence;":[480],"corresponding":[482],"substantive":[483],"signal":[485],"native":[489],"preference,":[492],"which":[493],"corpus":[495],"complete":[496],"(224":[498],"tested)":[500],"38.4%":[503],"eligible":[505],"section":[509,525],"heterogeneity":[510],"(astronomical":[511],"62.5%,":[512],"pharmaceutical":[513],"56.2%,":[514],"zodiac":[515],"50.0%,":[516],"cosmological":[517],"20.0%,":[518],"herbal":[519],"35.2%),":[520],"42.5":[522],"spread":[526],"meets":[528],"dramatic":[530],"divergence":[531],"threshold.":[532],"does":[535,551,560],"address":[537],"authenticity":[538],"(handled":[539],"2009":[542],"Arizona":[543],"AMS":[544],"C14":[545],"dating":[546],"McCrone":[548],"ink":[549],"analysis),":[550],"claim":[553],"encodes":[556],"language,":[558],"exclude":[562],"one-time-pad":[563],"use":[564],"principle.":[566],"---":[567],"Substrate":[568],"origination":[569,580],"documented":[570],"August":[571],"2025":[572],"(Paduan":[573],"Medical":[574],"Reference":[575],"dataset;":[576],"DOI":[577],"10.5281/zenodo.18687530,":[578],"copyright":[579],"2025-08-27).":[581]}