A proposal for a long-term renewal programme for Finland's icebreaker fleet
This report presents a proposal for a national renewal programme for Finland’s icebreaker fleet covering the period 2026–2045. The proposed approach is to replace the existing fleet with newbuildings in order of age, with the renewal programme proceeding in stages. In the next few years, decisions should be made on replacing the oldest icebreakers approaching the end of their service lives, URHO and SISU, both built in the 1970s. The programme would then continue in the 2030s with the replacement of KONTIO and OTSO, which will reach 50 years of age in the mid-2030s. In the final stage, during the 2040s, the multipurpose icebreakers FENNICA and NORDICA would be replaced. The renewal programme is based on an extensive background analysis of changes in the operating environment of icebreaking. In addition to global drivers of change in maritime transport, the report examines the anticipated development of the transport needs of Finnish industry and business, changes in the merchant fleet calling at Finnish ports over the past 25 years, changes in ice and weather conditions, and the changing significance of winter navigation for national security. Finnish industry and business expect transport volumes, and consequently the need for icebreaker assistance, to increase rather than decrease. Continuity of industrial and business operations and a secure investment environment require reliable, predictable and equitable icebreaking services. Finnish industry, particularly in the Bay of Bothnia, has no viable alternative transport routes. Any deterioration in the service level of winter navigation would have a direct impact on the operating conditions and competitiveness of Finnish industry and businesses. The analysis indicates that icebreaking and the fleet required to provide it will continue to be needed at least at the present level for decades to come. Although the climate is warming and winters are becoming milder on average, ice seasons more severe than the long-term average will continue to occur. Climate change is likely to reduce the overall extent of ice cover, while at the same time making ice conditions more challenging and less predictable. Planned offshore wind farms will alter sea-ice dynamics and reduce the sea area available for navigation. Results from the sea-ice dynamics modelling commissioned by the Finnish Transport Infrastructure Agency will become available in early 2027. Changing ice conditions will also change the capabilities required of icebreakers. The fleet will need to operate in considerably more variable conditions than in the past. At least the current number of icebreakers will be required in the coming decades, although the future fleet may consist of icebreakers of different sizes and types than today. Changes in the merchant fleet also affect icebreaking. Merchant vessels’ power-to-deadweight ratios and ice-going performance have deteriorated, and this trend is expected to continue. At the same time, vessels have become more difficult to assist. In addition to lower engine power relative to vessel size, modern vessels have bow forms and towing arrangements that are less suitable for icebreaker assistance, as well as larger windage areas. In the Bay of Bothnia, the proportion of vessels with a low power-to-deadweight ratio has increased substantially and consistently in overall traffic and among assisted and towed vessels. This will increase the need for assistance in the future. Compared with older tonnage, the operational ice-going capability of newer merchant vessels does not correspond as closely to what their nominal ice class would suggest. Even modern vessels with high ice classes require more icebreaker assistance because their ability to proceed independently in ice is poorer than that of older vessels. The importance of national security has increased and the operating environment in the Baltic Sea has changed. Year-round maritime transport and icebreaking are prerequisites not only for the functioning and competitiveness of industry and business but also for security of supply, including the safeguarding of maritime transports essential to society, and for military mobility. Icebreaking must remain operational during disruptions to maritime transport and under emergency conditions. In the changed security environment, the capabilities required of the future icebreaker fleet and its potential use for tasks other than its primary mission must be assessed. Such tasks would require icebreakers to be capable of operating in open-sea conditions, to possess surveillance capabilities and to be able to communicate with government information systems. The report has been prepared in close cooperation between the Finnish Transport Infrastructure Agency and the Swedish Maritime Administration. The final reports published in the two countries respond to the assignment given to the agencies in early 2025 by the Finnish Ministry of Transport and Communications and the Swedish Ministry of Rural Affairs and Infrastructure. In accordance with the assignment, the competent authorities of the two countries developed a shared view of changes in the operating environment of icebreaking and, on that basis, prepared national proposals for the renewal of their icebreaker fleets. The working group also examined the conditions for possible joint Finnish-Swedish procurement related to icebreaking. Potential areas identified include the design of a new icebreaker concept, the construction of new icebreakers and the procurement of supplementary icebreaking capacity. Finland and Sweden have a shared interest in examining a new icebreaker concept to replace the URHO/ATLE-class icebreakers built in the 1970s, of which Finland operates two and Sweden three. Joint procurement would be a natural approach to the concept design, particularly as the joint assignment has demonstrated that the Finnish and Swedish authorities have very similar views of the future operating environment and the capabilities required of newbuild icebreakers. The conditions for joint procurement should be examined in greater detail, particularly from a legal perspective. The Finnish Transport Infrastructure Agency and the Swedish Maritime Administration therefore propose an additional assignment to be completed by the end of 2026. The working group also assessed the bilateral agreement between Finland and Sweden on the joint provision of winter navigation services. Particular attention should be given to the method used to calculate compensation for temporary assistance assignments. A central element of Finnish-Swedish cooperation is the flexible deployment of the two countries’ icebreakers in support of one another, with compensation calculated at the end of each icebreaking season. The calculation method under the current agreement does not take actual operating, maintenance or capital costs into account and therefore does not reflect the true cost of the service. The need to revise the calculation method will become more pronounced as new icebreakers with significantly higher capital costs enter the fleets of both countries. The bilateral agreement, which originates from the 1960s, establishes a minimum level for the number and classes of icebreakers required to ensure adequate winter navigation services. During the assignment, the Finnish Transport Infrastructure Agency and the Swedish Maritime Administration concluded that the authorities should discuss revising the provision concerning the required size and composition of the icebreaker fleets. The authorities also considered that the targets set in the agreement for icebreaking waiting times and for the proportion of merchant vessels passing through without waiting should be reassessed. A safe and effective winter navigation system requires not only a capable icebreaker fleet but also adequate ice-going capability of merchant vessels. The indicators used to measure the service level of icebreaking should therefore be considered in parallel with the revision of the Finnish-Swedish Ice Class Rules. The Finnish and Swedish authorities have jointly observed a deterioration in merchant vessels’ ability to proceed independently in ice, as well as a growing discrepancy between vessels’ nominal ice class and their operational ice-going capability. The current Ice Class Rules should therefore be revised so that a vessel’s ice class more accurately reflects its actual ice-going capability. The revision would require cooperation between all four competent authorities: the Finnish Transport and Communications Agency, Traficom and the Finnish Transport Infrastructure Agency in Finland, and the Swedish Maritime Administration and the Swedish Transport Agency in Sweden.
Authors
- Lauri Kuuliala (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4809-1397)
- Olli Holm
- Helena Orädd
- Risto Murto
- Elisa Mikkolainen
- Tuomas Taivi
- Mika Nyrhilä
Publication Details
- Journal
- Doria (University of Helsinki)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- Primary Topic
- Arctic and Russian Policy Studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00