Structural Factor Framework for Gomoku Evaluation: Falsifiable Hypotheses, Engine Blind-Spot Characterisation, and a Pre-Registered Verification Protocol

This paper formalises a set of experience-based judgements about Gomoku, accumulated through long-term independent practice, into a structural factor evaluation framework.本文将通过长期独立实践积累的一组五子棋经验判断,形式化为一个结构因子评估框架。The framework publishes its factor list and aggregation structure while sealing its numerical weights.该框架公开发布其因子清单与聚合结构,同时将数值权重保密。Three falsifiable hypotheses are derived: (H1) the evaluation gap between the best move and the second-best move is often small in master-level play; (H2) mainstream engines exhibit systematic bias on long-jump and distant-defence structures, and the bias grows toward the endgame; (H3) the marginal value of a live two decays monotonically with game phase.由此引出三条可证伪假设:(H1)大师级对局中最优手与次优手的评估差距常呈“平坦”分布;(H2)主流引擎对远跳与远防结构存在系统性偏差,且该偏差随对局向残局推进而放大;(H3)活二的边际价值随对局阶段单调衰减。A pre-registration-style verification protocol is specified before any testing begins.本文在任何测试开始之前给出预注册风格的验证协议。This paper explicitly does not claim that a human using this framework can defeat top engines, that any world champion has played incorrectly, or that forbidden-move Gomoku admits a controllable outcome for either side.本文明确不声称:人类使用本框架可击败顶级引擎、任何世界冠军存在“下错”、或带禁手五子棋可任意操控任一方胜负。Instead, it argues that the only credible form of a "bombshell" in this field is a set of reproducible artifacts: an engine blind-spot challenge suite, a machine-verified endgame corpus, a counterexample list published before successes, and pre-registered tests.本文主张:在本领域能够可信构成的“炸弹”唯一形式,是一组可复现工件——引擎盲区挑战套件、机器验证残局库、先于成功结果发布的反例清单,以及预注册测试。

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24409320
Primary Topic
Artificial Intelligence in Games
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Structural Factor Framework for Gomoku Evaluation: Falsifiable Hypotheses, Engine Blind-Spot Characterisation, and a Pre-Registered Verification Protocol

湖南耒阳 曾乐
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Artificial Intelligence in Games
article

Structural Factor Framework for Gomoku Evaluation: Falsifiable Hypotheses, Engine Blind-Spot Characterisation, and a Pre-Registered Verification Protocol

湖南耒阳 曾乐
article en

Abstract

This paper formalises a set of experience-based judgements about Gomoku, accumulated through long-term independent practice, into a structural factor evaluation framework.本文将通过长期独立实践积累的一组五子棋经验判断,形式化为一个结构因子评估框架。The framework publishes its factor list and aggregation structure while sealing its numerical weights.该框架公开发布其因子清单与聚合结构,同时将数值权重保密。Three falsifiable hypotheses are derived: (H1) the evaluation gap between the best move and the second-best move is often small in master-level play; (H2) mainstream engines exhibit systematic bias on long-jump and distant-defence structures, and the bias grows toward the endgame; (H3) the marginal value of a live two decays monotonically with game phase.由此引出三条可证伪假设:(H1)大师级对局中最优手与次优手的评估差距常呈“平坦”分布;(H2)主流引擎对远跳与远防结构存在系统性偏差,且该偏差随对局向残局推进而放大;(H3)活二的边际价值随对局阶段单调衰减。A pre-registration-style verification protocol is specified before any testing begins.本文在任何测试开始之前给出预注册风格的验证协议。This paper explicitly does not claim that a human using this framework can defeat top engines, that any world champion has played incorrectly, or that forbidden-move Gomoku admits a controllable outcome for either side.本文明确不声称:人类使用本框架可击败顶级引擎、任何世界冠军存在“下错”、或带禁手五子棋可任意操控任一方胜负。Instead, it argues that the only credible form of a "bombshell" in this field is a set of reproducible artifacts: an engine blind-spot challenge suite, a machine-verified endgame corpus, a counterexample list published before successes, and pre-registered tests.本文主张:在本领域能够可信构成的“炸弹”唯一形式,是一组可复现工件——引擎盲区挑战套件、机器验证残局库、先于成功结果发布的反例清单,以及预注册测试。

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Artificial Intelligence in Games
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon
Structural Factor Framework for Gomoku Evaluation: Falsifiable Hypotheses, Engine Blind-Spot Characterisation, and a Pre-Registered Verification Protocol — 湖南耒阳 曾乐 · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) (2026) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS