The Influence of Environmental Context on Cognitive Performance in High School Students
Academic performance is usually a result of accuracy and the time taken to complete given cognitive tasks. However, these measures do not always represent how students respond when they encounter academically challenging and cognitively demanding tasks (pushing persistence, frustration, specific strategy use, and/or disengagement).This study examined the associations among students’ emotional states, perceived task difficulty, self-efficacy beliefs, and performance on cognitive tasks. The study was guided by theories based on stress-management, self-efficacy, and mindset theories. In this study, the associations between task perception and performance were measured. We compared the Pre-Task 1 (growth-mindset) and Pre-Task 2 (fixed-mindset) groups to examine differences in students’ experiences of the task. Completion time was not significantly related to any of the emotional or self-efficacy measures, meaning that the hypothesis that more positive cognitive appraisals would lead to faster completion was not supported. However, several strong relationships were found among students’ perceptions of difficulty, frustration, task demand, capability, improvement, and feeling stuck. Accuracy was lower among students who reported greater difficulty and frustration, and was higher among students who reported more positive feelings, improvement, ability to figure things out, and capability. The Pre-Task 1 group had higher accuracy and feelings of capability, all while having fewer negative sentiments. The Pre-Task 2 group reported higher perceived difficulty and task demand. These findings suggest that students’ experiences with and perceptions of academic challenges can be related to academic performance. The results draw attention to the potential value of learning environments that challenge students while simultaneously allowing them to feel capable of improving and working through difficulty.
Authors
- Tarun Tiwari
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.58445/rcrwha71
- Primary Topic
- Education, Achievement, and Giftedness
- Type
- preprint