Annealed Fisher bounds, normalized-minor Ward identity, and obstructions to one-contraction pairing ceilings in the Holstein model
Scope. This preprint is an intermediate, finite-volume methodological result. It is not a pairing ceiling: it proves no frequency-linear bound on the singlet pair-decay temperature of the Holstein model, and it does not close that open step. The frequency-linear upper bound kBTpair ≤ C(t,U)Ω (possibly up to logarithmic factors) of the spinful Holstein model, uniformly in volume and chemical potential as Ω → 0, remains open. Rather than close it, the note develops an annealed Fisher-information approach for the zero-Matsubara phonon mode and pinpoints the exact point at which the first-order theory succeeds and the second-order closure stops. (i) Integration by parts on the static-mode marginal and on the exact interacting finite-Ω conditional marginal, for any Hubbard coupling U0 ≤ 0, gives the full V × V matrix Fisher bound E[χeff] ≼ U-1 IV with no small-hopping cutoff, graph ball-growth hypothesis or pointwise convexity assumption; in the grand-canonical ensemble at U0 = 0 this controls the expected near-Fermi spectral weight by 2cosh2(a/2)τ/U, while in fixed-particle-number sectors the uniform-shift compressibility vanishes identically and local diagonal entries remain bounded by U-1. (ii) A Hilbert-Schmidt weighted Fisher inequality combined with a Daletskii–Krein spectral Ward identity for the normalized pair-minor matrix Qb = (I + e-βhb)-1 yields τ||∂vQb||HS2 ≤ ⅛ vTχbv uniformly in b, v, τ, t and μ, which removes the τ-1 derivative loss carried by unnormalized minors. (iii) An exact annealed one-contraction bound E0[|ΔS(1)(b0)|] ≤ C1phys(Ω/τ)2 holds with C1phys = 1/24 + ζ(3)/(8π3) = 0.0465127… (enclosed as 0.0465126 … 0.0465128) and no logarithmic factors. The paper then exhibits three sharp obstructions that block extending that one-contraction bound into a closed global inequality for the interacting structure factor SΩ: a Θ(τ-2) second-derivative blowup in clean two-dimensional metals, an extensive Θ(V(Ω/τ)2) coexistence covariance under static-to-dynamic measure reweighting, and the mismatch between conditional and bare static compressibilities together with the (t,U)-blindness of a single bare contraction. Metallic charge-density-wave domain walls near coexistence are assessed and shown to defeat unresummed annealed perturbation without providing a physical counterexample to a linear ceiling. Contents. This record holds the manuscript paper/main.pdf (paper/main.tex, paper/refs.bib) as reviewed and released. The companion verification program SUPPLEMENT/replay.py, SHA-256 digest 572106bc3bd377ab5453e506696557220b5fcf1668c21927d8eb70146b304072, is deposited separately as doi:10.5281/zenodo.24413072. The released PDF has SHA-256 digest 0845717f4f10349b7d592e1d79f5a78a589ea386a987433863c41cd1630c289c. Disclosures. The finite-lattice, sixteen-dimensional Fock-space and quadrature diagnostics in the supplement are numerical sanity checks only and do not substitute for the analytical proofs, which hold for every finite graph. No superconducting transition is claimed and no pairing ceiling is established. AI agents generated the proofs, code and drafts under D. Rens' direction, and separate AI agents carried out the independent reviews. This preprint has not been peer reviewed. Hosted source repository: https://github.com/SuperMatics-Inc/holstein-annealed-fisher-bounds.
Authors
- Davis Rens
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24413069
- Primary Topic
- Quantum many-body systems
- Type
- preprint