Manifesting inspired landscapes: Implementing a plural valuation framework for landscape restoration in South Africa

Context Plural valuation frameworks integrate different values of sustainability and could help navigate the often messy and contentious nature of multistakeholder collaborations to restore multifunctional landscapes. However, several literature reviews have concluded that this potential has not yet been realised in practice. Objectives To understand this theory–practice gap, a realist case study was implemented to explore the experience of a non-profit company, Living Lands, in adapting Commonland’s 4Returns framework to the contested and complex context of two South African landscapes. The framework is intended to enable a long-term perspective on landscape restoration, and deepen understanding on how livelihoods are supported by ecological, economic, and social outcomes emergent from social-ecological relationships. Methods Interviews with and participant observations of Living Lands, landscape community members, and other stakeholders were used to assess the implementation and outcomes of projects based on the framework. Data analysis included thematic coding of transcripts, fieldnotes, and documents. Results The 4Returns framework enabled collective sensemaking, and broadened the value of restoration. However, participants highlighted pitfalls of oversimplified linear understandings of complex challenges, particularly in terms of securing financial returns, engaging marginalised people as fellow stewards, and the role of inspiration (i.e. visioning, learning, and innovations). Conclusions To manifest the potential of plural valuation frameworks, implementation requires an active and continuous reflexive process to support practitioners in engaging with social-ecological relationships. This includes recognising marginalised community members as stewards and not passive beneficiaries of projects, and managing expectations while maintaining inspiration to weather setbacks inherent to transformative processes for landscape sustainability.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Landscape Ecology
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1007/s10980-026-02489-7
Primary Topic
Land Use and Ecosystem Services
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Manifesting inspired landscapes: Implementing a plural valuation framework for landscape restoration in South Africa

Jessica J. Cockburn, Karen Joan Esler, Marja J. Spierenburg, Ancois Carien de Villiers
Landscape Ecology
Land Use and Ecosystem Services
article

Manifesting inspired landscapes: Implementing a plural valuation framework for landscape restoration in South Africa

Jessica J. Cockburn, Karen Joan Esler, Marja J. Spierenburg, Ancois Carien de Villiers
article en

Abstract

Context Plural valuation frameworks integrate different values of sustainability and could help navigate the often messy and contentious nature of multistakeholder collaborations to restore multifunctional landscapes. However, several literature reviews have concluded that this potential has not yet been realised in practice. Objectives To understand this theory–practice gap, a realist case study was implemented to explore the experience of a non-profit company, Living Lands, in adapting Commonland’s 4Returns framework to the contested and complex context of two South African landscapes. The framework is intended to enable a long-term perspective on landscape restoration, and deepen understanding on how livelihoods are supported by ecological, economic, and social outcomes emergent from social-ecological relationships. Methods Interviews with and participant observations of Living Lands, landscape community members, and other stakeholders were used to assess the implementation and outcomes of projects based on the framework. Data analysis included thematic coding of transcripts, fieldnotes, and documents. Results The 4Returns framework enabled collective sensemaking, and broadened the value of restoration. However, participants highlighted pitfalls of oversimplified linear understandings of complex challenges, particularly in terms of securing financial returns, engaging marginalised people as fellow stewards, and the role of inspiration (i.e. visioning, learning, and innovations). Conclusions To manifest the potential of plural valuation frameworks, implementation requires an active and continuous reflexive process to support practitioners in engaging with social-ecological relationships. This includes recognising marginalised community members as stewards and not passive beneficiaries of projects, and managing expectations while maintaining inspiration to weather setbacks inherent to transformative processes for landscape sustainability.

Landscape EcologyVol. 41(12)
Leiden University (NL), Rhodes University (ZA), University of Applied Sciences Leiden (NL), Stellenbosch University (ZA)
Land Use and Ecosystem Services
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon