Vogel's plane and the index condition from the highest-root grading

Let 𝔀 β‰  𝔰𝔩₂ be a complex simple Lie algebra, graded by its highest root ΞΈ as 𝔀 = 𝔀₋₂ βŠ• 𝔀₋₁ βŠ• 𝔀₀ βŠ• 𝔀₁ βŠ• 𝔀₂ with 𝔀₀ = β„‚ΞΈβˆ¨ βŠ• 𝔀₀′. Reading the invariants of the nilradical grade by grade, we give a uniform proof that Sym²𝔀 is the multiplicity-free sum of β„‚, L(2ΞΈ), the modules L(ΞΈ+ΞΈ_X) for the simple ideals X of 𝔀₀′, a copy of 𝔀 when 𝔀₀′ has a center, and L(ΞΈβˆ’Ξ±_a) exactly when 𝔀₀′ acts on 𝔀₁ as the full symplectic algebra. Together with the marks of ΞΈ and a secular equation on the odd part of Sym²𝔀, this yields Vogel's parametrization of the Casimir spectrum on Sym²𝔀 with no list of simple Lie algebras: the Casimir eigenvalues on Sym²𝔀 other than 0 and that of L(2ΞΈ) are 4h∨ βˆ’ 2Ξ½ for at most two values Ξ½, which sum to h∨ + 2 when there are two. Vogel's 𝔰𝔩, 𝔰𝔭, 𝔰𝔬 and exceptional lines and the point (4, 4) appear as five structural cases, and the hypotheses of Vogel's diagrammatic Theorem 6.3 hold. We also prove, by two reflections, that every irreducible component of ΞΈβŠ₯ of rank at least 2 contains a long root, so that the simple ideals of 𝔀₀′ of rank at least 2 have Dynkin index 1. Four brackets with x ∈ 𝔀₁ take eβ‚‹ΞΈ to Q(x)e_ΞΈ for a quartic form Q on 𝔀₁ that vanishes exactly in the symplectic case; an operator it defines on Sym²𝔀₁ acts on the image of each simple ideal and of the center of 𝔀₀′ by the corresponding Vogel parameter, and by zero on the complement of these images, and Q is shared among the simple ideals and the center of 𝔀₀′ in the proportions of the secular equation at the root of L(2ΞΈ). Consequences include a structural characterization of the point Ξ² = Ξ³, whose three orders are the vertices of the triangle formed by the exceptional line and its images under the permutations of the parameters, the value dim L(2ΞΈ) = 300 there from two moments of the Casimir, Vogel's dimension formulas from three, and the Vogel points of the simple ideals of 𝔀₀′. In the exceptional case (iv), passing to the simple ideal of 𝔀₀′ leaves exactly five points, at h∨ = 4, 9, 12, 18, 30, where dim 𝔀 = 14, 52, 78, 133, 248, and the point of 𝔀 determines which of the five cases holds.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24418947
Citations
2
Primary Topic
Advanced Algebra and Geometry
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Vogel's plane and the index condition from the highest-root grading

Eric Guideng
2 citations
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Advanced Algebra and Geometry
preprint

Vogel's plane and the index condition from the highest-root grading

Eric Guideng
preprint en
2 citations

Abstract

Let 𝔀 β‰  𝔰𝔩₂ be a complex simple Lie algebra, graded by its highest root ΞΈ as 𝔀 = 𝔀₋₂ βŠ• 𝔀₋₁ βŠ• 𝔀₀ βŠ• 𝔀₁ βŠ• 𝔀₂ with 𝔀₀ = β„‚ΞΈβˆ¨ βŠ• 𝔀₀′. Reading the invariants of the nilradical grade by grade, we give a uniform proof that Sym²𝔀 is the multiplicity-free sum of β„‚, L(2ΞΈ), the modules L(ΞΈ+ΞΈ_X) for the simple ideals X of 𝔀₀′, a copy of 𝔀 when 𝔀₀′ has a center, and L(ΞΈβˆ’Ξ±_a) exactly when 𝔀₀′ acts on 𝔀₁ as the full symplectic algebra. Together with the marks of ΞΈ and a secular equation on the odd part of Sym²𝔀, this yields Vogel's parametrization of the Casimir spectrum on Sym²𝔀 with no list of simple Lie algebras: the Casimir eigenvalues on Sym²𝔀 other than 0 and that of L(2ΞΈ) are 4h∨ βˆ’ 2Ξ½ for at most two values Ξ½, which sum to h∨ + 2 when there are two. Vogel's 𝔰𝔩, 𝔰𝔭, 𝔰𝔬 and exceptional lines and the point (4, 4) appear as five structural cases, and the hypotheses of Vogel's diagrammatic Theorem 6.3 hold. We also prove, by two reflections, that every irreducible component of ΞΈβŠ₯ of rank at least 2 contains a long root, so that the simple ideals of 𝔀₀′ of rank at least 2 have Dynkin index 1. Four brackets with x ∈ 𝔀₁ take eβ‚‹ΞΈ to Q(x)e_ΞΈ for a quartic form Q on 𝔀₁ that vanishes exactly in the symplectic case; an operator it defines on Sym²𝔀₁ acts on the image of each simple ideal and of the center of 𝔀₀′ by the corresponding Vogel parameter, and by zero on the complement of these images, and Q is shared among the simple ideals and the center of 𝔀₀′ in the proportions of the secular equation at the root of L(2ΞΈ). Consequences include a structural characterization of the point Ξ² = Ξ³, whose three orders are the vertices of the triangle formed by the exceptional line and its images under the permutations of the parameters, the value dim L(2ΞΈ) = 300 there from two moments of the Casimir, Vogel's dimension formulas from three, and the Vogel points of the simple ideals of 𝔀₀′. In the exceptional case (iv), passing to the simple ideal of 𝔀₀′ leaves exactly five points, at h∨ = 4, 9, 12, 18, 30, where dim 𝔀 = 14, 52, 78, 133, 248, and the point of 𝔀 determines which of the five cases holds.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Advanced Algebra and Geometry
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon