Obstructions to lifting cold-phonon pairing bounds to the full Gibbs state in the Holstein model

Scope. For the spinful Holstein model at large U/Ω, a released argument bounds the polaronic pair-decay temperature by 226(t2/U)e-7U/(8Ω), but only on a cold manifold that keeps the odd-site occupation zero and the phonon occupation below M=floor(U/(64Ω)) at every site. Removing that projection, so that the same ceiling holds for the Gibbs state of the unprojected Hamiltonian, is open, and this note does not close it. It records why five natural route families fail, quantifies what any surviving route must control, and isolates the remaining statement. Obstructed routes. Five route families are obstructed at the level of specified estimates: operator Schrieffer-Wolff and phonon-number Lyapunov bounds, Gaussian domination of the Lang-Firsov influence functional, reflection positivity, log-concavity of the phonon marginal, and cut Schrieffer-Wolff without a global projection. Cutoff-free kernel. The directed pair-transfer kernel satisfies an exact bound that carries the same e-(U/Ω)coth(βΩ/4) exponent, but the influence weight of an electron history does not factorize over disjoint time segments: an explicit legal history with four bond charges has conditional log weight exceeding the free directed maximum by at least 3/4 for all U/Ω≥20 at βΩ=1, and a closed four-hop pair-return loop costs action at most 3 independently of U/Ω. A facing-plateau lemma survives with the weaker constant 3/22 and does not add along a spatial skeleton. Distortion-valley route. Written in the distortion coordinate, this sixth route removes the cold projection at the level of the two-site problem: it gives a non-asymptotic splitting bound, an excursion bound at every temperature, and a volume-uniform many-body barrier bound, but it stops at the same locality step, because local valley projectors leak at order t2/U rather than exponentially. Hot sector. In the bare Lang-Firsov frame the population of the hot region Nz>M is at least c2(t/U)2 with c2=1/4096, on the dimer and, with volume-uniform constants, on every torus and every finite vertex-transitive regular graph, at every temperature in a fixed window and for all hopping below an explicit power of Ω3/U2. A separate second-order Duhamel calculation on the dimer gives the same conclusion with a different constant. The channel weight of a first-order virtual transfer tends to 1/4 both in the bare frame and after the first Schrieffer-Wolff rotation. Charge order. Under the same wall, positive-temperature charge order remains open at the decorated-contour lemma; what is proved is the exact second-order pseudospin anisotropy, volume-uniform first Lie-Schwinger bounds, and boundedness of the density-observable transport. Status. No pairing ceiling is claimed. Every finite and exact-arithmetic claim is replayed by six standalone supplement scripts, which reject deliberately broken variants of themselves, nine, twelve, six, ten and eight respectively and are archived with the source. This preprint has not been peer reviewed. AI disclosure. AI tools were used for drafting, calculation and checking under the author's direction and review. All theorems were checked by hand against the proofs, and all numerical claims are reproducible from the archived scripts.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24419885
Citations
2
Primary Topic
Quantum many-body systems
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Obstructions to lifting cold-phonon pairing bounds to the full Gibbs state in the Holstein model

Davis Rens
2 citations
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum many-body systems
preprint

Obstructions to lifting cold-phonon pairing bounds to the full Gibbs state in the Holstein model

Davis Rens
preprint en
2 citations

Abstract

Scope. For the spinful Holstein model at large U/Ω, a released argument bounds the polaronic pair-decay temperature by 226(t2/U)e-7U/(8Ω), but only on a cold manifold that keeps the odd-site occupation zero and the phonon occupation below M=floor(U/(64Ω)) at every site. Removing that projection, so that the same ceiling holds for the Gibbs state of the unprojected Hamiltonian, is open, and this note does not close it. It records why five natural route families fail, quantifies what any surviving route must control, and isolates the remaining statement. Obstructed routes. Five route families are obstructed at the level of specified estimates: operator Schrieffer-Wolff and phonon-number Lyapunov bounds, Gaussian domination of the Lang-Firsov influence functional, reflection positivity, log-concavity of the phonon marginal, and cut Schrieffer-Wolff without a global projection. Cutoff-free kernel. The directed pair-transfer kernel satisfies an exact bound that carries the same e-(U/Ω)coth(βΩ/4) exponent, but the influence weight of an electron history does not factorize over disjoint time segments: an explicit legal history with four bond charges has conditional log weight exceeding the free directed maximum by at least 3/4 for all U/Ω≥20 at βΩ=1, and a closed four-hop pair-return loop costs action at most 3 independently of U/Ω. A facing-plateau lemma survives with the weaker constant 3/22 and does not add along a spatial skeleton. Distortion-valley route. Written in the distortion coordinate, this sixth route removes the cold projection at the level of the two-site problem: it gives a non-asymptotic splitting bound, an excursion bound at every temperature, and a volume-uniform many-body barrier bound, but it stops at the same locality step, because local valley projectors leak at order t2/U rather than exponentially. Hot sector. In the bare Lang-Firsov frame the population of the hot region Nz>M is at least c2(t/U)2 with c2=1/4096, on the dimer and, with volume-uniform constants, on every torus and every finite vertex-transitive regular graph, at every temperature in a fixed window and for all hopping below an explicit power of Ω3/U2. A separate second-order Duhamel calculation on the dimer gives the same conclusion with a different constant. The channel weight of a first-order virtual transfer tends to 1/4 both in the bare frame and after the first Schrieffer-Wolff rotation. Charge order. Under the same wall, positive-temperature charge order remains open at the decorated-contour lemma; what is proved is the exact second-order pseudospin anisotropy, volume-uniform first Lie-Schwinger bounds, and boundedness of the density-observable transport. Status. No pairing ceiling is claimed. Every finite and exact-arithmetic claim is replayed by six standalone supplement scripts, which reject deliberately broken variants of themselves, nine, twelve, six, ten and eight respectively and are archived with the source. This preprint has not been peer reviewed. AI disclosure. AI tools were used for drafting, calculation and checking under the author's direction and review. All theorems were checked by hand against the proofs, and all numerical claims are reproducible from the archived scripts.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Quantum many-body systems
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon