Comparison of Trust in AI vs Peer Tools in Generation Alpha Education
Students aged 15-17’s usage of AI in educational settings has been dramatically increasing in today’s education, with both benefits and drawbacks reported in the literature. However, excessive dependency on AI raises concerns of technostress, fatigue, and anxiety among students that can negatively impact relationships with learning. Additionally, decreases in peer connection have led to a lack of social learning. However, upon conducting a digital study at Davis Senior High, the 101 sophomores surveyed routinely scored higher on trust for peers over their trust for AI on three of four metrics of trust: personalization, intent, and objectivity. Only AI consistency was scored higher than peer consistency. Research suggests that boosting peer trust and classroom connection over AI usage would directly contribute to improving the lack of peer consistency. Creating a stronger, more diverse student network can increase peer trust and connection effectively. Given the geographical cluster sample, more research is needed to expand on the differences in trust between AI and peers.
Authors
- Jason Lin
Publication Details
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.58445/8pn8d377
- Primary Topic
- Artificial Intelligence in Education
- Type
- preprint