ALP-ttbar Toy MC v2.7 — Post-Registration: Tag Formula Diagnostics Results in Displaced Light ALP → e⁺e⁻

Post-registration results for the v2.7 Tag Formula Diagnostics study in the ALP-ttbar Toy MC series. This study investigates why the Tag discriminator's upper-limit degradation ratio exhibits 45× higher seed-to-seed variability than the HV discriminator in a toy Monte Carlo simulation of displaced ALP → e⁺e⁻ searches in tt̄ events (E3 configuration: f = 0.25, 17-band endcap geometry, η = 2.0). Three diagnostic approaches were deployed across a 50-seed ensemble at two ALP masses (17 MeV and 200 MeV): Approach A — Frozen-Seed Variance Decomposition: Group F (both seeds vary), Group C (conversion seed fixed), and Group S (signal seed fixed) isolate the dominant variance source. Result: 99.84% of Tag variance comes from conversion-background randomness (σ_S/σ_F = 0.9992), not signal randomness (σ_C/σ_F = 0.0432) — the opposite of the preregistered prediction. Approach B — Per-Vertex Weight Analysis: 4-way overlap classification of near-band-edge and inter-band-gap vertices at multiple distance thresholds D ∈ {1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50} mm. The near-edge correlation with Tag was weak (|R| = 0.0934, below the predicted 0.3 threshold), refuting prediction N1. Approach C — Robust Estimator Comparison: Trimmed mean at k = 1% reduces CV from 5.80% to 0.13% (a 45-fold improvement). Winsorised mean unexpectedly worsens CV to 7.35%, a counter-intuitive asymmetry caused by threshold-scan instability. Excess kurtosis = 44.97 confirms extremely heavy-tailed λ distribution. Prediction verdicts: 8/12 confirmed, 4/12 refuted. Core score: 2/4 (weak diagnostic evidence by preregistered criteria). The core refutations (F1 and N1) are scientifically informative — conversion dominance was unexpected and reshapes the understanding of Tag instability. At 200 MeV, variance additivity does not hold (σ_C²/σ_F² + σ_S²/σ_F² = 1.5975 ≠ 1.0); however, the departure from additivity alone cannot determine whether the signal and conversion sources are statistically dependent. The v2.7 Group F ensemble was computed fresh for this study. Seed-0 verification confirms internal consistency among the v2.7 F/C/S groups (matching to floating-point precision at i = 0), but direct comparison with the original v2.6 per-seed arrays was not performed (they were not retained). Preregistration DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24388228Previous study (v2.6 post-registration): 10.5281/zenodo.24373115 This is an independent personal toy study, not affiliated with the authors of arXiv:2610.38932 (Alimena et al., 2026) or arXiv:2306.08686 (Rygaard et al., 2023), nor with the CMS, ATLAS, LHCb or ALICE Collaborations or the FCC study. Detector numbers are assumed; only qualitative trends and ratios are meaningful.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24408989
Primary Topic
Particle Detector Development and Performance
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

ALP-ttbar Toy MC v2.7 — Post-Registration: Tag Formula Diagnostics Results in Displaced Light ALP → e⁺e⁻

Won Shik Paik
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Particle Detector Development and Performance
preprint

ALP-ttbar Toy MC v2.7 — Post-Registration: Tag Formula Diagnostics Results in Displaced Light ALP → e⁺e⁻

Won Shik Paik
preprint en

Abstract

Post-registration results for the v2.7 Tag Formula Diagnostics study in the ALP-ttbar Toy MC series. This study investigates why the Tag discriminator's upper-limit degradation ratio exhibits 45× higher seed-to-seed variability than the HV discriminator in a toy Monte Carlo simulation of displaced ALP → e⁺e⁻ searches in tt̄ events (E3 configuration: f = 0.25, 17-band endcap geometry, η = 2.0). Three diagnostic approaches were deployed across a 50-seed ensemble at two ALP masses (17 MeV and 200 MeV): Approach A — Frozen-Seed Variance Decomposition: Group F (both seeds vary), Group C (conversion seed fixed), and Group S (signal seed fixed) isolate the dominant variance source. Result: 99.84% of Tag variance comes from conversion-background randomness (σ_S/σ_F = 0.9992), not signal randomness (σ_C/σ_F = 0.0432) — the opposite of the preregistered prediction. Approach B — Per-Vertex Weight Analysis: 4-way overlap classification of near-band-edge and inter-band-gap vertices at multiple distance thresholds D ∈ {1, 2, 5, 10, 20, 50} mm. The near-edge correlation with Tag was weak (|R| = 0.0934, below the predicted 0.3 threshold), refuting prediction N1. Approach C — Robust Estimator Comparison: Trimmed mean at k = 1% reduces CV from 5.80% to 0.13% (a 45-fold improvement). Winsorised mean unexpectedly worsens CV to 7.35%, a counter-intuitive asymmetry caused by threshold-scan instability. Excess kurtosis = 44.97 confirms extremely heavy-tailed λ distribution. Prediction verdicts: 8/12 confirmed, 4/12 refuted. Core score: 2/4 (weak diagnostic evidence by preregistered criteria). The core refutations (F1 and N1) are scientifically informative — conversion dominance was unexpected and reshapes the understanding of Tag instability. At 200 MeV, variance additivity does not hold (σ_C²/σ_F² + σ_S²/σ_F² = 1.5975 ≠ 1.0); however, the departure from additivity alone cannot determine whether the signal and conversion sources are statistically dependent. The v2.7 Group F ensemble was computed fresh for this study. Seed-0 verification confirms internal consistency among the v2.7 F/C/S groups (matching to floating-point precision at i = 0), but direct comparison with the original v2.6 per-seed arrays was not performed (they were not retained). Preregistration DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.24388228Previous study (v2.6 post-registration): 10.5281/zenodo.24373115 This is an independent personal toy study, not affiliated with the authors of arXiv:2610.38932 (Alimena et al., 2026) or arXiv:2306.08686 (Rygaard et al., 2023), nor with the CMS, ATLAS, LHCb or ALICE Collaborations or the FCC study. Detector numbers are assumed; only qualitative trends and ratios are meaningful.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Particle Detector Development and Performance
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon