Toward a Validated School Head Qualifying Examination: A PRISMA-Guided Review and Prototype For Philippine Public Schools
A defensible qualifying examination for school heads must do more than produce reliable scores. It must show that candidates can demonstrate leadership practice, support comparable interpretations across settings, and justify the consequences of classification. This exploratory evidence map, completed by one reviewer, examined fixed Scopus and Google Scholar exports and used the findings to frame a Philippine research prototype. The source files contained 6,250 rows. Exact normalized-title deduplication removed 78 records, leaving 6,172 unique titles for screening under a documented rule set. Ninety-five records were mapped. To strengthen the interpretation, 12 linked scholarly full texts and four authoritative documents were purposefully verified. The historical Google Scholar query, export date, filters, and 500-result retrieval limit were recoverable, but the original Scopus query and database-run date were not preserved. Of the mapped records, only 12 directly addressed principal qualification or readiness. Binary signals in indexed text, used only as reporting indicators rather than estimates of method prevalence, showed factor-analysis terms in 27 records, self-report or survey terms in 23, predictive or criterion terms in two, invariance or differential-item-functioning terms in two, and performance-oriented terms in one. No signal was found for standard setting, longitudinal validation, or test–retest evidence. The literature helps inform construct and method design, but it does not support an integrated Philippine qualification decision. In response, this paper proposes a five-domain, PPSSH-aligned multimethod architecture, a traceability matrix linking claims, tasks, scoring, and validation, and a staged validation program. All weights and item counts remain provisional. The prototype is neither the current National Assessment for School Heads nor a developed or validated examination. It should not support pass/fail, appointment, promotion, or exclusion decisions unless policy authorization is secured and evidence establishes score meaning, fairness, classification consistency, prediction, and consequences.
Authors
- Las Johansen B. Caluza (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-4353-6916)
- Roy M. Maldecino
Institutions
- Leyte Normal University (PH)
Publication Details
- Journal
- International Journal of Research and Innovation in Applied Science
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.51584/ijrias.2026.11110014
- Primary Topic
- Psychometric Methodologies and Testing
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00