The Mainstreaming of Caste Extremities: Diaspora and Networked Publics in Australia

Introduction Caste remains a significant structure of social identity, belonging, and inequality within the Indian diaspora in Australia. Migration extends caste relations across national boundaries, while kinship, marriage, religious practices, cultural memory, and community networks provide mechanisms through which caste identities and hierarchies are reproduced and renegotiated (Ambedkar). Digital media further shape these processes by enabling dispersed communities to maintain transnational connections and reconstruct identities within bidesh through networks linking them to desh (Appadurai; Gardner). Previous scholarship has demonstrated that digital media create spaces in which caste hierarchies are reproduced alongside counter-discourses (Ananth and Saha; Gajjala; Thakur). However, despite the persistence of caste and caste discrimination in Australia (Sarwal), limited attention has been paid to how caste-based ideologies acquire characteristics of extremity within diasporic digital publics and how they move between the fringes and wider public discourse. Addressing this gap, this article examines caste-related discussions on Reddit in Australia through qualitative content analysis. It brings Saha’s concept of New Casteism into dialogue with theories of networked publics (boyd; Castells; Bory; Markus and Ripatti-Torniainen). The article argues that caste extremity must be understood as a context-dependent and relational process, shaped by the interaction between caste ideologies, digital communication, and competing claims to legitimacy. By examining these processes within the Australian diaspora, the article advances an understanding of how digital publics mediate the reproduction and contestation of caste ideology across national boundaries. Caste Ideologies, Extremism, and New Casteism Caste is a historically embedded system of social stratification in South Asia, particularly India, whose ideological foundations are associated with religious and textual traditions, including the Purusha Sukta of the Rigveda, which presents a hierarchical division of society. These hierarchical frameworks have historically informed the legitimation of hereditary status, endogamy, occupational divisions, and notions of purity and pollution, shaping social, economic, and cultural relations (Thorat; Waughray). Although the Indian Constitution, adopted in 1950, prohibited caste-based discrimination and abolished untouchability, caste continues to structure social relations, positioning savarna communities within systems of privilege and those historically excluded from the varna hierarchy within relations of exclusion and oppression (Ambedkar). Drawing on Brown and Hohman and Zmigrod and Kruglanski, ideological extremity can be understood as inflexible adherence to political, religious, or social beliefs that intensifies divisions, resists adaptation, and dismisses alternative perspectives. In the context of caste, extremity thus could be referred to as the intensification and defence of caste ideology through the reinforcement of Brahmanical hierarchies and the legitimation of caste-based exclusion and oppression. Such ideologies may be articulated as cultural traditions or religious principles, rendering hierarchical relations legitimate or normal. Although legal reforms and resistance movements have challenged the public legitimation of caste discrimination, caste ideologies continue to be reproduced and contested through contemporary media environments. This shift is significant to the emergence of New Casteism, through which caste is reconstructed and negotiated under changing mediated conditions. From this perspective, caste extremity involves the reinforcement of hierarchical distinctions, the policing of social boundaries, and the positioning of an out-group as inferior or threatening. Networked communication provides a context in which these ideologies are articulated, circulated, defended, and challenged beyond local community settings (Raman and Saha). Dirks demonstrates that caste retains social significance across changing political and social contexts through its associations with cultural authenticity, religious authority, heritage, status, and community belonging. As caste relations evolve, the mediated and representational processes through which caste ideology is reproduced and contested also change. Saha’s concept of New Casteism helps explain these transformations by highlighting the role of contemporary media in reshaping caste ideology. These processes are particularly significant in diasporic contexts, where migration transforms the social and institutional conditions through which caste is expressed (Ayyathurai). Through community practices and transnational connections, caste is negotiated across desh (home country) and bidesh (host country). Caste ideologies are therefore not merely transferred between national contexts but reconstructed in response to changing social conditions, cultural expectations, and public norms. Despite scholarship on caste, diaspora, and digital media, further research is needed to explain how migration reconfigures caste extremities and how these ideologies are reproduced and negotiated across the desh-bidesh relationship. Given the significance of networked spaces to the mediated restructuring of caste associated with New Casteism, this study examines how caste extremities are reconstructed within diasporic contexts and acquire public legitimacy through networked communication. From Fringe to Mainstream: Networked Circulation and Public Legitimacy The fringe and the mainstream are contested positions within public communication, distinguished by the circulation and legitimacy of discourse (Fraser). Networked publics, constituted through interactions between people, technologies, and communicative practices (boyd), complicate this distinction by enabling narratives to circulate beyond their original communities. The affordances of persistence, replicability, scalability, and searchability shape the visibility and reach of these narratives. In caste discourse, such circulation becomes a struggle over ideological legitimacy, through which caste hierarchies may be normalised and savarna privilege reinforced, or challenged through counterpublic narratives. Castells (Rise) and Bory situate social power and ideology within networks and communicative flows. Building on these perspectives and Saha’s concept of New Casteism, this study conceptualises the movement of caste ideology between fringe and mainstream spaces as a contested process shaped by the conditions under which narratives gain public recognition. Existing scholarship demonstrates that caste ideology is reproduced and negotiated through networked interaction especially in India (Saha; Ananth and Saha), while Fuchs situates digital communication within broader struggles over public opinion and power. However, because extremity is context-dependent and shaped by prevailing social norms, values, and individual perceptions (Fowlie), caste extremity must be examined in relation to the communicative contexts in which it is constructed and contested. This is particularly important in diasporic settings, where caste ideologies are negotiated across the desh and bidesh. Focussing on Reddit discussions concerning caste in Australia, this study examines how networked interactions reproduce and contest caste ideologies, how these ideologies acquire characteristics of extremity, and how their circulation shapes the contested boundaries between fringe and mainstream discourse. Reddit: Data Collection and Analysis This study employed qualitative content analysis of Reddit discussions, selected for its pseudonymous participation and threaded format, which facilitate the expression and negotiation of caste-related beliefs and experiences, providing a space in which caste-based ideologies can be freely articulated. Given the dispersed nature of caste-related discussions across Reddit forums, Boolean searches combining the terms “Australia” AND “caste” were conducted to identify potentially relevant posts. Preliminary searches identified approximately 21 potentially relevant posts published over a six-year period. However, a greater concentration of relevant discussions appeared from 2022 onwards, coinciding with growing institutional recognition of caste in Australia (Scroll Staff). Accordingly, 11 threads published between January 2022 and January 2026 were purposively selected based on three criteria: a minimum of 10 comments, substantive engagement with caste, and relevance to caste-related experiences, identities, and relations in the Australian context. These criteria prioritised discussions offering sufficient depth to examine how caste was articulated, negotiated, and contested. The selected threads contained more than 2,700 comments. From this corpus, approximately 300 comments were selected for detailed analysis using stratified systematic sampling. The selected comments were iteratively coded to identify recurring patterns and develop broader analytical categories. Caste, Culture, and the Production of Normality Caste normality operates through the association of caste practices with cultural and religious traditions, presenting hierarchical relations as customary, legitimate, and integral to cultural identity (Thorat). The Reddit discussions demonstrate how caste ideology is reproduced through narratives of cultural continuity, heritage, religion, and community belonging. By framing caste as cultural preservation, these narratives legitimise caste distinctions while obscuring the inequalities they sustain. For example, in the Reddit discussion on r/IndiaSpeaks (with 14 comments), a user observed that “most ‘normal’ people see their caste as a community of people with similar cultural practices”. The comment subsequently discusses caste-based community celebrations and parental preferences for endogamous marriage

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
M/C Journal
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3341
Primary Topic
South Asian Studies and Diaspora
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

The Mainstreaming of Caste Extremities: Diaspora and Networked Publics in Australia

Ali Saha
M/C Journal
South Asian Studies and Diaspora
article

The Mainstreaming of Caste Extremities: Diaspora and Networked Publics in Australia

Ali Saha
article en

Abstract

Introduction Caste remains a significant structure of social identity, belonging, and inequality within the Indian diaspora in Australia. Migration extends caste relations across national boundaries, while kinship, marriage, religious practices, cultural memory, and community networks provide mechanisms through which caste identities and hierarchies are reproduced and renegotiated (Ambedkar). Digital media further shape these processes by enabling dispersed communities to maintain transnational connections and reconstruct identities within bidesh through networks linking them to desh (Appadurai; Gardner). Previous scholarship has demonstrated that digital media create spaces in which caste hierarchies are reproduced alongside counter-discourses (Ananth and Saha; Gajjala; Thakur). However, despite the persistence of caste and caste discrimination in Australia (Sarwal), limited attention has been paid to how caste-based ideologies acquire characteristics of extremity within diasporic digital publics and how they move between the fringes and wider public discourse. Addressing this gap, this article examines caste-related discussions on Reddit in Australia through qualitative content analysis. It brings Saha’s concept of New Casteism into dialogue with theories of networked publics (boyd; Castells; Bory; Markus and Ripatti-Torniainen). The article argues that caste extremity must be understood as a context-dependent and relational process, shaped by the interaction between caste ideologies, digital communication, and competing claims to legitimacy. By examining these processes within the Australian diaspora, the article advances an understanding of how digital publics mediate the reproduction and contestation of caste ideology across national boundaries. Caste Ideologies, Extremism, and New Casteism Caste is a historically embedded system of social stratification in South Asia, particularly India, whose ideological foundations are associated with religious and textual traditions, including the Purusha Sukta of the Rigveda, which presents a hierarchical division of society. These hierarchical frameworks have historically informed the legitimation of hereditary status, endogamy, occupational divisions, and notions of purity and pollution, shaping social, economic, and cultural relations (Thorat; Waughray). Although the Indian Constitution, adopted in 1950, prohibited caste-based discrimination and abolished untouchability, caste continues to structure social relations, positioning savarna communities within systems of privilege and those historically excluded from the varna hierarchy within relations of exclusion and oppression (Ambedkar). Drawing on Brown and Hohman and Zmigrod and Kruglanski, ideological extremity can be understood as inflexible adherence to political, religious, or social beliefs that intensifies divisions, resists adaptation, and dismisses alternative perspectives. In the context of caste, extremity thus could be referred to as the intensification and defence of caste ideology through the reinforcement of Brahmanical hierarchies and the legitimation of caste-based exclusion and oppression. Such ideologies may be articulated as cultural traditions or religious principles, rendering hierarchical relations legitimate or normal. Although legal reforms and resistance movements have challenged the public legitimation of caste discrimination, caste ideologies continue to be reproduced and contested through contemporary media environments. This shift is significant to the emergence of New Casteism, through which caste is reconstructed and negotiated under changing mediated conditions. From this perspective, caste extremity involves the reinforcement of hierarchical distinctions, the policing of social boundaries, and the positioning of an out-group as inferior or threatening. Networked communication provides a context in which these ideologies are articulated, circulated, defended, and challenged beyond local community settings (Raman and Saha). Dirks demonstrates that caste retains social significance across changing political and social contexts through its associations with cultural authenticity, religious authority, heritage, status, and community belonging. As caste relations evolve, the mediated and representational processes through which caste ideology is reproduced and contested also change. Saha’s concept of New Casteism helps explain these transformations by highlighting the role of contemporary media in reshaping caste ideology. These processes are particularly significant in diasporic contexts, where migration transforms the social and institutional conditions through which caste is expressed (Ayyathurai). Through community practices and transnational connections, caste is negotiated across desh (home country) and bidesh (host country). Caste ideologies are therefore not merely transferred between national contexts but reconstructed in response to changing social conditions, cultural expectations, and public norms. Despite scholarship on caste, diaspora, and digital media, further research is needed to explain how migration reconfigures caste extremities and how these ideologies are reproduced and negotiated across the desh-bidesh relationship. Given the significance of networked spaces to the mediated restructuring of caste associated with New Casteism, this study examines how caste extremities are reconstructed within diasporic contexts and acquire public legitimacy through networked communication. From Fringe to Mainstream: Networked Circulation and Public Legitimacy The fringe and the mainstream are contested positions within public communication, distinguished by the circulation and legitimacy of discourse (Fraser). Networked publics, constituted through interactions between people, technologies, and communicative practices (boyd), complicate this distinction by enabling narratives to circulate beyond their original communities. The affordances of persistence, replicability, scalability, and searchability shape the visibility and reach of these narratives. In caste discourse, such circulation becomes a struggle over ideological legitimacy, through which caste hierarchies may be normalised and savarna privilege reinforced, or challenged through counterpublic narratives. Castells (Rise) and Bory situate social power and ideology within networks and communicative flows. Building on these perspectives and Saha’s concept of New Casteism, this study conceptualises the movement of caste ideology between fringe and mainstream spaces as a contested process shaped by the conditions under which narratives gain public recognition. Existing scholarship demonstrates that caste ideology is reproduced and negotiated through networked interaction especially in India (Saha; Ananth and Saha), while Fuchs situates digital communication within broader struggles over public opinion and power. However, because extremity is context-dependent and shaped by prevailing social norms, values, and individual perceptions (Fowlie), caste extremity must be examined in relation to the communicative contexts in which it is constructed and contested. This is particularly important in diasporic settings, where caste ideologies are negotiated across the desh and bidesh. Focussing on Reddit discussions concerning caste in Australia, this study examines how networked interactions reproduce and contest caste ideologies, how these ideologies acquire characteristics of extremity, and how their circulation shapes the contested boundaries between fringe and mainstream discourse. Reddit: Data Collection and Analysis This study employed qualitative content analysis of Reddit discussions, selected for its pseudonymous participation and threaded format, which facilitate the expression and negotiation of caste-related beliefs and experiences, providing a space in which caste-based ideologies can be freely articulated. Given the dispersed nature of caste-related discussions across Reddit forums, Boolean searches combining the terms “Australia” AND “caste” were conducted to identify potentially relevant posts. Preliminary searches identified approximately 21 potentially relevant posts published over a six-year period. However, a greater concentration of relevant discussions appeared from 2022 onwards, coinciding with growing institutional recognition of caste in Australia (Scroll Staff). Accordingly, 11 threads published between January 2022 and January 2026 were purposively selected based on three criteria: a minimum of 10 comments, substantive engagement with caste, and relevance to caste-related experiences, identities, and relations in the Australian context. These criteria prioritised discussions offering sufficient depth to examine how caste was articulated, negotiated, and contested. The selected threads contained more than 2,700 comments. From this corpus, approximately 300 comments were selected for detailed analysis using stratified systematic sampling. The selected comments were iteratively coded to identify recurring patterns and develop broader analytical categories. Caste, Culture, and the Production of Normality Caste normality operates through the association of caste practices with cultural and religious traditions, presenting hierarchical relations as customary, legitimate, and integral to cultural identity (Thorat). The Reddit discussions demonstrate how caste ideology is reproduced through narratives of cultural continuity, heritage, religion, and community belonging. By framing caste as cultural preservation, these narratives legitimise caste distinctions while obscuring the inequalities they sustain. For example, in the Reddit discussion on r/IndiaSpeaks (with 14 comments), a user observed that “most ‘normal’ people see their caste as a community of people with similar cultural practices”. The comment subsequently discusses caste-based community celebrations and parental preferences for endogamous marriage

M/C JournalVol. 29(6)
The University of Melbourne (AU)
South Asian Studies and Diaspora
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon