When are flood-frequency estimates reportable? A selective-coverage audit of short hydrological records
This study is a selective-coverage audit, not a claim of a universally reliable reporting rule. It asks whether a three-state reporting policy (PASS, HOLD, WITHHOLD) for stationary generalized extreme-value (GEV) return levels remains reliable after selection, and whether pooled coverage conceals tail-specific failure. The policy combines profile-likelihood intervals, split-conformal expansion and observable stability diagnostics. In an independent paired synthetic test (1,000 in-domain cases), a tail-protected policy accepted 201 cases (20.1%); 191/201 intervals contained the true Q100 (95.02%; Wilson 91.1–97.3%) and none exceeded 50% error, against 313/338 (92.60%) and 17 large errors for the baseline policy. The apparent pooled gain stems mainly from withholding difficult cases rather than improved interval construction: on the 201 cases accepted by both policies the baseline intervals covered 194 and the protected intervals 191 (median widths 76% and 50%), while the 137 cases rejected only by the protected policy were covered 119 times (86.9%). A post hoc ablation shows that a fitted-shape cap, ξ̂ ≤ 0, alone reproduces the result (221/231, 95.7%). Acceptance was concentrated at true ξ = −0.1 (185 of 201); coverage was 10/16 at ξ = 0.2 and no case was accepted at ξ = 0.5 or 0.8. Without recalibration, the frozen policy covered 232/245 accepted cases (94.7%) under a finer GEV shape grid, Pearson type III and serially dependent maxima, but only 51/56 (91.1%) for GEV with ξ ≥ 0. In five Australian gauges (282 annual maxima of daily-mean flow, 83.7% graded C or E at the peak date) every training-fit ξ̂ exceeded 0.2, so no site could be accepted, and GEV did not outperform a lognormal benchmark at four sites. The evidence delineates a boundary of reportability for light-tailed regimes; it does not validate design-flood estimates, heavy-tail coverage, or superiority over established practice such as Bulletin 17C. Keywords: flood-frequency analysis; generalized extreme value; selective coverage; abstention; split-conformal calibration; heavy-tail identifiability; daily-flow maxima; Australian gauges.
Authors
- Ayad Kadhim Hussein (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-0304-5525)
Institutions
- University of Kufa (IQ)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24412517
- Primary Topic
- Flood Risk Assessment and Management
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00