Finite quandles separate the remaining knots up to 12 crossings from their reverses

Clark, Elhamdadi, Saito and Yeatman asked in 2014 whether the remaining 308 of the 1366 chiral or negative amphicheiral prime knots with at most 12 crossings can be distinguished from their mirror images, equivalently from their reverses, by numbers of colourings by finite quandles. The data file of Clark, Dunning and Saito (2016) gives such a separation for 294 of the 308. We show that the other 14 are separated as well: each of them has a conjugacy class C of a finite group (in PΓL(2,8), U_3(3).2, M_11 or PΓL(2,32), of size 252 to 10,912) whose conjugation quandle gives different colouring numbers for K and its reverse. Among them are the 12 chiral knots that Clark, Dunning and Saito list as the exceptions for their 60 quandles; for two of them (12a_779, 12a_1055) one of those 60, a conjugation quandle of M_11 with 720 elements, gives different colouring numbers by our computation; we cannot tell why their list does not reflect this. For the thirteenth knot of that list, the positive amphicheiral 12a_427, colouring numbers cannot separate K from its reverse; Eisermann's knot colouring polynomial for M_11, with the meridian in a class of elements of order 11, does. Every count was obtained by two independent programs. STATUS: not refereed. The note was prepared in collaboration with the AI system Claude Code (Anthropic), working with the author; the tool-use declaration is in the note. The author takes full responsibility for all contents. FILES: note.pdf, note.tex; package.zip with the per-knot results of both computational routes (GPU search over conjugation quandles from GAP's ATLAS; independent Wirtinger-presentation count in GAP on a different diagram), the programs and their run logs, the script that builds the two tables of the note from the result files, the outputs for 12a_427, our reading of the data file of Clark, Dunning and Saito, literature-search receipts, and a script that re-reads the note's numbers from these files; README.md; LICENSE-DOCS.txt; SHA256SUMS. Not included: the exported class arrays (111 MB, regenerated by the included script from GAP's ATLAS), the USF data files of Clark, Elhamdadi, Saito, Yeatman and of Clark, Dunning, Saito, and KnotInfo data. LICENCES: note CC BY 4.0 (the licence field of this record); scripts GPL-3.0-or-later; data CC BY 4.0 — per part as stated in README.md.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24416141
Primary Topic
Geometric and Algebraic Topology
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

Finite quandles separate the remaining knots up to 12 crossings from their reverses

Werner Alois Stanggassinger
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Geometric and Algebraic Topology
preprint

Finite quandles separate the remaining knots up to 12 crossings from their reverses

Werner Alois Stanggassinger
preprint en

Abstract

Clark, Elhamdadi, Saito and Yeatman asked in 2014 whether the remaining 308 of the 1366 chiral or negative amphicheiral prime knots with at most 12 crossings can be distinguished from their mirror images, equivalently from their reverses, by numbers of colourings by finite quandles. The data file of Clark, Dunning and Saito (2016) gives such a separation for 294 of the 308. We show that the other 14 are separated as well: each of them has a conjugacy class C of a finite group (in PΓL(2,8), U_3(3).2, M_11 or PΓL(2,32), of size 252 to 10,912) whose conjugation quandle gives different colouring numbers for K and its reverse. Among them are the 12 chiral knots that Clark, Dunning and Saito list as the exceptions for their 60 quandles; for two of them (12a_779, 12a_1055) one of those 60, a conjugation quandle of M_11 with 720 elements, gives different colouring numbers by our computation; we cannot tell why their list does not reflect this. For the thirteenth knot of that list, the positive amphicheiral 12a_427, colouring numbers cannot separate K from its reverse; Eisermann's knot colouring polynomial for M_11, with the meridian in a class of elements of order 11, does. Every count was obtained by two independent programs. STATUS: not refereed. The note was prepared in collaboration with the AI system Claude Code (Anthropic), working with the author; the tool-use declaration is in the note. The author takes full responsibility for all contents. FILES: note.pdf, note.tex; package.zip with the per-knot results of both computational routes (GPU search over conjugation quandles from GAP's ATLAS; independent Wirtinger-presentation count in GAP on a different diagram), the programs and their run logs, the script that builds the two tables of the note from the result files, the outputs for 12a_427, our reading of the data file of Clark, Dunning and Saito, literature-search receipts, and a script that re-reads the note's numbers from these files; README.md; LICENSE-DOCS.txt; SHA256SUMS. Not included: the exported class arrays (111 MB, regenerated by the included script from GAP's ATLAS), the USF data files of Clark, Elhamdadi, Saito, Yeatman and of Clark, Dunning, Saito, and KnotInfo data. LICENCES: note CC BY 4.0 (the licence field of this record); scripts GPL-3.0-or-later; data CC BY 4.0 — per part as stated in README.md.

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Geometric and Algebraic Topology
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon