THE INVARIANT-TARGET, CONTEXT-DEPENDENT EVALUATION PRINCIPLE
The Invariant-Target, Context-Dependent Evaluation Principle (ITCDEP) proposes ageneral framework for examining how the evaluation of an unchanged target can vary whenthe context used to evaluate it changes.The central observation is that the actual state or measurable output of an individual,object, process, or system may remain constant while its relative position, score, classification,rating, judgment, or decision changes under different evaluation contexts.Such contexts may involve different reference populations, benchmarks, criteria, thresholds,metrics, measurement scales, weighting arrangements, objectives, observers, or decision rules.The framework distinguishes three fundamental components: the underlying target, itsmeasurement, and the evaluation applied to the measured result. This separation is necessaryto distinguish actual change from measurement error and context-dependent evaluationchange.The theory introduces Context-Conditioned Evaluation Shift (CCES) as its proposeddefault mechanism. A general evaluation function is formulated to represent the relationshipbetween an unchanged target and different evaluation contexts. Appropriate differencemeasures are then specified for numerical scores, percentiles, classifications, decisions, andprobabilistic evaluation outputs.The permanent primary case is the 5'7" Cross-Reference Height Evaluation Case (CRHEC),in which the same measured height may occupy different relative positions in two referencepopulations. This case is retained across all fourteen theoretical layers while remainingdistinct from the theory's generalized definition.The proposed architecture integrates mathematics, statistics, measurement theory, generalsystems theory, decision theory, causal inference, sociology, economics, psychology, computerscience, and engineering applications.Fourteen theoretical layers, six research hypotheses, formal propositions, operationaldefinitions, empirical procedures, boundary conditions, and falsification criteria are developed.ITCDEP is presented as a conditional and testable theoretical proposal rather than anestablished universal law. Its scientific contribution must be determined through empiricalvalidation, literature comparison, and demonstrations of explanatory or predictive valuebeyond existing approaches.Keywords: ITCDEP; Context-Dependent Evaluation; Target Invariance; Evaluation Shift;Reference Distribution; Measurement; Benchmark; Threshold; Systems Theory; MathematicalModeling; Decision Theory; Evaluation Invariance.
Authors
- Shamiul Hoque Shan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24425392
- Primary Topic
- Psychometric Methodologies and Testing
- Type
- preprint