Disentangling reactive control, representation, map knowledge and prediction in robot navigation among pedestrians: A controlled simulation benchmark
Benchmarks of robot navigation among pedestrians usually compare complete planners, so the design choice behind a difference is rarely identified. We present a seeded, paired simulation benchmark that varies the planning representation (sparse Voronoi roadmap, dense lattice, dense grid), a local reactive potential field (on or off), the robot’s knowledge (full, or from a 120° occluded sensor without a map) and pedestrian forecasting (from constant velocity to a trained long short-term memory and an oracle). Each operating point uses 100 paired seeds, analysed with multiplicity-adjusted paired tests and with failure-inclusive and time-to-collision metrics. The reactive field is the dominant lever: it raises minimum pedestrian clearance by 0.31–1.18 m for every representation and cuts the share of runs entering a 0.9-m contact zone from up to 69% to at most 4%; with it, the roadmap and lattice differ by at most 0.06 m. Forecasting and map completeness matter little: forecasts add about 0.1 m at most, perfect forecasts from an oracle perform like constant velocity, a full static map changes nothing, and omniscient pedestrian tracking adds 0.09–0.18 m. Reliability differences between representations vanish once the roadmap is queried correctly; we document this and three further artefacts – planner-coupled random streams, an unstated robot-to-pedestrian speed ratio and non-inflated obstacles in external planner ports – that can manufacture effects of the size typically reported. The orderings survive sensor noise, social-force and ORCA crowds, an indoor scene family and multiple robots, but weaken when the robot moves no faster than pedestrians under unicycle limits.
Authors
- Yao‐Jen Chang (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1461-2270)
- Hung-Huan Liu (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0002-2100-3652)
Institutions
- Chung Yuan Christian University (TW)
Publication Details
- Journal
- SIMULATION
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1177/00375497261508045
- Primary Topic
- Robotic Path Planning Algorithms
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00