Injunctions of (Centrist) Extremes: Derrida, Habermas, and Digital Media in an Age of (Eco)collapse

Many liberal democratic societies are experiencing increasing polarisation. Scholars have increasingly sought to measure this phenomenon through quantitative models of ideological distance and collective behaviour. Yet such approaches risk reproducing the very categories they claim to describe from an objective lens. Polarising rhetoric and narratives ring through digital circuits that structure contemporary culture(s) and, at the same time, weaken the unstable divide between culture and politics. While most of the world’s populations are phenomenologically implicated in the material effects of this instability, the empiricists are busy concocting a “polarization metric” to measure denaturing relationalities stemming from the “physics of collective phenomena” (Thurner, Hofer, and Korbel 1). Metric-based assessments, the brainchildren of liberal austerity, retain a neoliberal affect that rhetorically distances the analyst from a damaged planet and the multiple lives and relations it sustains. This is not to discount the insights of empirical studies of extremism. On the contrary, I want to suggest that these “metrics” are meaningless without a close reading of the theoretical assumptions that their operationalisations and conceptualisations (re)produce. In short, these empirical studies fail to engage with a more fundamental categorical-theoretical conundrum. This puzzle can be stated succinctly: we are told extremism is rising, but what if we have already been living in the extreme? The very category of extremism is hermeneutically suspicious when considering its spatial-temporal construction. This essay argues the distinction between mainstream and extreme functions less as a descriptive category than as a rhetorical mechanism that obscures the structural extremity of contemporary life. In arguing for a postfoundational understanding of the extreme/mainstream binary, I am not positing a single definition of either term. The nature of this argument rests on inherently restless understandings of both terms. To ground this idea, I engage scholars of postphilosophical countertraditions and digital media to trace how algorithmic fantasies of overcoming extremism reproduce the contexts for new understandings of the extreme. This is especially clear when examining the Anthropocene. In an age defined by ecological collapse and systemic instability, the “centre” persists not as a site of moderation but as an ideological formation that masks the radical unsustainability of contemporary life. Framing a perpetually fleeting and deferred concept of “normal” ignores normativity’s rhetorical function. The problem is not simply that extreme ideas are becoming more visible or more acceptable. Rather, the conceptual distinction between “mainstream” and “extreme” may no longer adequately describe the present. Escalating climate catastrophe, intensifying economic precarity, and the erosion of democratic institutions suggest not a stable centre under threat, but a broader condition of systemic instability. To retain this binary may be less an act of analysis than an act of maintenance—one that preserves the fiction of a centre even as the material conditions that once appeared to sustain it continue to unravel. Understanding where we are requires an always incomplete understanding of where we have come from. To begin a deconstructive reading of centrist stability, we need a generalised understanding of the unstable “origins” of the concept of the centre. For this task, we turn to the godfather of conceptual-contextual instability: Jacques Derrida. Derrida and the Metaphysics of the Centre Philosophy has a strong historical lineage grounded in what Derrida identifies as a “metaphysics of presence” (Derrida, Of Grammatology 49). The structural assumption (especially in the Global North) is that the “centre”—like other forms of metonymical normativity—is intrinsically natural, stable, and self-evident. For Derrida, there is no form of presence beneath history, philosophy, rhetoric, or communication that is not mediated. Presence (re)produces the stability, immediacy, coherence, and self-evidence of the organising principle of intelligibility. In this sense, presence is assumed to precede the very structures it organises through its tentacular grasp. Derrida’s insights, arriving slightly before the digital revolution, gained new relevance in the context of digital media and the cultures they materialise. Indeed, the digital mainstream is often presented as the purest and most stable of presences. Digital media collapse the spatial and temporal boundaries that impede communication, ushering in a sense of globalisation. A Derridean perspective resists interpreting digital media as a pure form of presence uninhibited by spatio-temporal concerns (Koulouris 4). In the case of the mainstream, the normative implications associated with the utterance “mainstream” are assumed to exist prior to interpretation. The structural assumptions of the metaphysics of presence extend into digitally mediated political and cultural discourses. This observation is most salient in the digital ecologies of algorithm-based trending and the technocultures surrounding large language models (LLMs). Platforms like TikTok and Facebook promote “trending” topics as a reflection of collective attention. Figures like Elon Musk describe social media, LLMs, and the “Internet” as large cybernetic collectives (Rogers). Musk extends this analysis to describe the contemporary human subject as feeding a machine. In this technocentric worldview, humans feed information to algorithms and models to optimise their supposed use-value for consumers who pay fees to large tech corporations (Zuboff 47). However, this rhetorical obfuscation disguises the exclusions and opacities that determine what gets promoted to the coveted “trending” status. The most visible repetitions of an algorithmically determined presence emerge from a series of probabilistic decisions masquerading as self-evident. Derrida, writing before the advent of specular algorithmic trends, haunts life in the extremist corners of the integrated circuit. But what does it mean to be extreme? Could one ever comprehend extremity outside its relationship with other signifiers? Derrida is reluctant to say, in his typical deference to undecidability. Writing in Specters of Marx, Derrida asks, “can the extremity of the extreme ever be comprehended? After the end of history, the spirit comes by coming back; it figures both a dead man who comes back and a ghost whose expected return repeats itself, again and again” (10). Contemporary media and their supposedly intelligent technologies bear an uncanny resemblance to Derrida’s spirit at the end of history. The collapse between the come and the coming is especially relevant in conceptual discussions on extremism. If the centre (broadly defined as mainstream culture or ideals) comes by coming back, serious ethical and political problems arise within theoretical constructions of the mainstream. There is no transcendental centre or transcendental signifier that directs us toward a centre that is outside the realm of structure. Derrida is urging a recognition of the (other)wise (in)comprehensible nature of the coming required to come. This is not to suggest that our attentiveness to the ethics and political consequences of extremism in media and planetary ecologies is unimportant. Our contemporary lives are plagued by challenges of unforeseen scale and scope. Kathryn Yusoff reminds us of the longue durée of (non)human histories of ecological destruction. Yusoff asserts that the Anthropocene is one of many spatio-temporal abuses carried out in the name of Western domination and colonisation (Yusoff 28). Paradoxically, it is the very technologies and media coded as mainstream or centrist that perpetuate the ecological destruction that new generations are beginning to reckon with. Derrida is often misread as an apolitical figure intent on destroying a shared objective reality. Habermas writes, “despite his transformed gestures, in the end he, too, promotes only a mystification of palpable social pathologies; he, too, disconnects essential (namely, deconstructive) thinking from scientific analysis; and he, too, lands at an empty, formula-like avowal of some indeterminate authority” (Habermas, Philosophical Discourse 161). Amid climate extremes, Derrida’s own writing raises the question: whither Derrida? Derrida’s inquiry rests on a scholarly insistence on the question’s contingency and radical openness. However, we must remember how politics and ethics intertwine with contingency and openness. Derrida’s analysis of language (différance) gave rise to a recognition of the necessity of relationality in (re)constructing meaning. One need look no further than Derrida’s own writings to see how closely deconstruction is tied to questions of ethics and politics. Derrida asks, “but with the other, is not this disjuncture, this dis-adjustment of the ‘it’s going badly’ necessary for the good, or at least the just to be announced?” (Specters 26). Derrida clearly understands that any articulation of the good as the other of the bad in each society depends on adverbial announcement. An (un)conscious recognition of the fusive nature of signs is a (pre)condition for the eruption of an ethico-political engagement with the other. Spectral Mainstreams: EXTRE(me) Repetition, Return, and Algorithmic Presence If the mainstream was once imagined as a stable centre capable of excluding the fringe, digital media culture increasingly reveals the opposite: the centre itself is constituted by the constant repetition of spectral fragments that it can neither fully absorb nor fully expel. The “extreme” no longer appears merely as a discrete ideological enemy outside the mainstream. Rather, it circulates within contemporary media systems as an algorithmically recurring presence—a ghostly return that destabilis

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
M/C Journal
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3330
Primary Topic
Critical Theory and Philosophy
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Injunctions of (Centrist) Extremes: Derrida, Habermas, and Digital Media in an Age of (Eco)collapse

Carson Stanley
M/C Journal
Critical Theory and Philosophy
article

Injunctions of (Centrist) Extremes: Derrida, Habermas, and Digital Media in an Age of (Eco)collapse

Carson Stanley
article en

Abstract

Many liberal democratic societies are experiencing increasing polarisation. Scholars have increasingly sought to measure this phenomenon through quantitative models of ideological distance and collective behaviour. Yet such approaches risk reproducing the very categories they claim to describe from an objective lens. Polarising rhetoric and narratives ring through digital circuits that structure contemporary culture(s) and, at the same time, weaken the unstable divide between culture and politics. While most of the world’s populations are phenomenologically implicated in the material effects of this instability, the empiricists are busy concocting a “polarization metric” to measure denaturing relationalities stemming from the “physics of collective phenomena” (Thurner, Hofer, and Korbel 1). Metric-based assessments, the brainchildren of liberal austerity, retain a neoliberal affect that rhetorically distances the analyst from a damaged planet and the multiple lives and relations it sustains. This is not to discount the insights of empirical studies of extremism. On the contrary, I want to suggest that these “metrics” are meaningless without a close reading of the theoretical assumptions that their operationalisations and conceptualisations (re)produce. In short, these empirical studies fail to engage with a more fundamental categorical-theoretical conundrum. This puzzle can be stated succinctly: we are told extremism is rising, but what if we have already been living in the extreme? The very category of extremism is hermeneutically suspicious when considering its spatial-temporal construction. This essay argues the distinction between mainstream and extreme functions less as a descriptive category than as a rhetorical mechanism that obscures the structural extremity of contemporary life. In arguing for a postfoundational understanding of the extreme/mainstream binary, I am not positing a single definition of either term. The nature of this argument rests on inherently restless understandings of both terms. To ground this idea, I engage scholars of postphilosophical countertraditions and digital media to trace how algorithmic fantasies of overcoming extremism reproduce the contexts for new understandings of the extreme. This is especially clear when examining the Anthropocene. In an age defined by ecological collapse and systemic instability, the “centre” persists not as a site of moderation but as an ideological formation that masks the radical unsustainability of contemporary life. Framing a perpetually fleeting and deferred concept of “normal” ignores normativity’s rhetorical function. The problem is not simply that extreme ideas are becoming more visible or more acceptable. Rather, the conceptual distinction between “mainstream” and “extreme” may no longer adequately describe the present. Escalating climate catastrophe, intensifying economic precarity, and the erosion of democratic institutions suggest not a stable centre under threat, but a broader condition of systemic instability. To retain this binary may be less an act of analysis than an act of maintenance—one that preserves the fiction of a centre even as the material conditions that once appeared to sustain it continue to unravel. Understanding where we are requires an always incomplete understanding of where we have come from. To begin a deconstructive reading of centrist stability, we need a generalised understanding of the unstable “origins” of the concept of the centre. For this task, we turn to the godfather of conceptual-contextual instability: Jacques Derrida. Derrida and the Metaphysics of the Centre Philosophy has a strong historical lineage grounded in what Derrida identifies as a “metaphysics of presence” (Derrida, Of Grammatology 49). The structural assumption (especially in the Global North) is that the “centre”—like other forms of metonymical normativity—is intrinsically natural, stable, and self-evident. For Derrida, there is no form of presence beneath history, philosophy, rhetoric, or communication that is not mediated. Presence (re)produces the stability, immediacy, coherence, and self-evidence of the organising principle of intelligibility. In this sense, presence is assumed to precede the very structures it organises through its tentacular grasp. Derrida’s insights, arriving slightly before the digital revolution, gained new relevance in the context of digital media and the cultures they materialise. Indeed, the digital mainstream is often presented as the purest and most stable of presences. Digital media collapse the spatial and temporal boundaries that impede communication, ushering in a sense of globalisation. A Derridean perspective resists interpreting digital media as a pure form of presence uninhibited by spatio-temporal concerns (Koulouris 4). In the case of the mainstream, the normative implications associated with the utterance “mainstream” are assumed to exist prior to interpretation. The structural assumptions of the metaphysics of presence extend into digitally mediated political and cultural discourses. This observation is most salient in the digital ecologies of algorithm-based trending and the technocultures surrounding large language models (LLMs). Platforms like TikTok and Facebook promote “trending” topics as a reflection of collective attention. Figures like Elon Musk describe social media, LLMs, and the “Internet” as large cybernetic collectives (Rogers). Musk extends this analysis to describe the contemporary human subject as feeding a machine. In this technocentric worldview, humans feed information to algorithms and models to optimise their supposed use-value for consumers who pay fees to large tech corporations (Zuboff 47). However, this rhetorical obfuscation disguises the exclusions and opacities that determine what gets promoted to the coveted “trending” status. The most visible repetitions of an algorithmically determined presence emerge from a series of probabilistic decisions masquerading as self-evident. Derrida, writing before the advent of specular algorithmic trends, haunts life in the extremist corners of the integrated circuit. But what does it mean to be extreme? Could one ever comprehend extremity outside its relationship with other signifiers? Derrida is reluctant to say, in his typical deference to undecidability. Writing in Specters of Marx, Derrida asks, “can the extremity of the extreme ever be comprehended? After the end of history, the spirit comes by coming back; it figures both a dead man who comes back and a ghost whose expected return repeats itself, again and again” (10). Contemporary media and their supposedly intelligent technologies bear an uncanny resemblance to Derrida’s spirit at the end of history. The collapse between the come and the coming is especially relevant in conceptual discussions on extremism. If the centre (broadly defined as mainstream culture or ideals) comes by coming back, serious ethical and political problems arise within theoretical constructions of the mainstream. There is no transcendental centre or transcendental signifier that directs us toward a centre that is outside the realm of structure. Derrida is urging a recognition of the (other)wise (in)comprehensible nature of the coming required to come. This is not to suggest that our attentiveness to the ethics and political consequences of extremism in media and planetary ecologies is unimportant. Our contemporary lives are plagued by challenges of unforeseen scale and scope. Kathryn Yusoff reminds us of the longue durée of (non)human histories of ecological destruction. Yusoff asserts that the Anthropocene is one of many spatio-temporal abuses carried out in the name of Western domination and colonisation (Yusoff 28). Paradoxically, it is the very technologies and media coded as mainstream or centrist that perpetuate the ecological destruction that new generations are beginning to reckon with. Derrida is often misread as an apolitical figure intent on destroying a shared objective reality. Habermas writes, “despite his transformed gestures, in the end he, too, promotes only a mystification of palpable social pathologies; he, too, disconnects essential (namely, deconstructive) thinking from scientific analysis; and he, too, lands at an empty, formula-like avowal of some indeterminate authority” (Habermas, Philosophical Discourse 161). Amid climate extremes, Derrida’s own writing raises the question: whither Derrida? Derrida’s inquiry rests on a scholarly insistence on the question’s contingency and radical openness. However, we must remember how politics and ethics intertwine with contingency and openness. Derrida’s analysis of language (différance) gave rise to a recognition of the necessity of relationality in (re)constructing meaning. One need look no further than Derrida’s own writings to see how closely deconstruction is tied to questions of ethics and politics. Derrida asks, “but with the other, is not this disjuncture, this dis-adjustment of the ‘it’s going badly’ necessary for the good, or at least the just to be announced?” (Specters 26). Derrida clearly understands that any articulation of the good as the other of the bad in each society depends on adverbial announcement. An (un)conscious recognition of the fusive nature of signs is a (pre)condition for the eruption of an ethico-political engagement with the other. Spectral Mainstreams: EXTRE(me) Repetition, Return, and Algorithmic Presence If the mainstream was once imagined as a stable centre capable of excluding the fringe, digital media culture increasingly reveals the opposite: the centre itself is constituted by the constant repetition of spectral fragments that it can neither fully absorb nor fully expel. The “extreme” no longer appears merely as a discrete ideological enemy outside the mainstream. Rather, it circulates within contemporary media systems as an algorithmically recurring presence—a ghostly return that destabilis

M/C JournalVol. 29(6)
East Carolina University (US)
Critical Theory and Philosophy
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon