Irregularity versus growth rate in disk-stacking phyllotaxis
In the disk-stacking model of phyllotaxis, disks representing young organs are placed on a cylinder, each new disk at the lowest position where it touches two disks and overlaps none; slowly decreasing diameters can produce successive Fibonacci transitions of the parastichy numbers. Golé, Dumais and Douady (Acta Soc. Bot. Pol. 2016) conjectured that independent tolerances on irregularity, notch angle and rate of diameter decrease guarantee N Fibonacci transitions. This preprint proves that for every single-notch hexagonal front D^mU^n with m, n ≥ 2 and n/2 < m < 2n, an explicit open cone of perturbations (both directional deviations and the rate tending to zero, all initial disks obeying the diameter law) makes the first placement a pentagon transition (Theorem A), so there is no independent tolerance box and the conjecture fails in its initial Fibonacci form. From the three-disk fronts F(β, ε) the first transition completes with two triangle transitions and no pentagon (Theorem B). During a rhombic phase of L placements, ratios within either vector family change by O(|c| + c^2 L) (Proposition 5.2). Simulations suggest a crossover controlled by the mismatch-to-rate ratio; delayed breakdown is stated as Conjecture C. Lean 4 verifies the local identities, first-order lemmas and the frozen-shape estimate (standard axioms only); the periodic first-disk argument and uniform remainders are proved by hand, and candidate tables are certified in exact and interval arithmetic. Not peer reviewed; this version predates the author's line-by-line read. Two AI tools were used under the author's direction (Claude, Anthropic, and Codex, OpenAI), as described in the acknowledgements. The archive is identical to the folder phyllotaxis-irregularity of github.com/jvvk/mathematics at tag phyllotaxis-irregularity-v3.
Authors
- Vamshi Jandhyala (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0006-6708-5805)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24421825
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Mathematical Theories and Applications
- Type
- preprint