Never Break the Chain: Revisiting Chains of Equivalence to Understand Coalition Building and New Far-Right Discursive Organisation

Introduction On the morning of 18 March 2023, two crowds occupied the steps of Victoria’s Parliament House on Spring Street. The primary group had gathered for the “Let Women Speak” rally, an event on the Australian tour of the British anti-transgender activist Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull (also known as Posie Parker), and was addressed by then-Liberal MLC Moira Deeming, former federal Liberal candidate Katherine Deves, and other gender-critical feminists. Another group of approximately thirty men in black clothing and balaclavas from the National Socialist Network (NSN) marched along Spring Street chanting “white power”, unfurled a banner which read “destroy paedo freaks”, and performed the Nazi salute – then lawful in the state (Elkin). Moira Deeming is not affiliated with proscribed far-right extremist organisations, and yet, through her involvement in the “Let Women Speak” rally, she was discursively aligned with a neo-Nazi organisation, resulting in then-Opposition Leader John Pesutto moving to expel her from the parliamentary party (Kolovos). In this article, we ask how this affiliation was made legible. Gender-critical and far-right discourses were not strangers to one another before Spring Street. Hines has demonstrated extensive links between gender-critical feminism and the far-right in the United Kingdom. Mayer and Sauer have also shown how “gender ideology” can function as an empty signifier linking anti-abortion, men’s rights, anti-LGBTQ+, and anti-feminist discourses in Austria. Butler has similarly demonstrated the transnational alliances, both implicit and explicit, that have formed in opposition to what they term the “phantasm of gender”. We are not attempting to revisit this overlap, but instead narrow our focus towards an analysis of how groups which offer mutually incompatible accounts of why transgender people constitute a threat became co-present and mutually legible within a single political event, and how that legibility then collapsed. We do so by drawing on Laclau and Mouffe’s notion of chains of equivalence. Chains of equivalence provide an extension on notions of “grievance politics” (Flinders and Hinterleitner) by contextualising far-right groups in broader discourses. What Liberal party members, the NSN, gender-critical feminists, and religious conservatives shared on Spring Street was not an explicit policy platform or ideology but, rather, a shared antagonist: transgender people. We identify three articulations of equivalence formed in this instance: agonistic articulation, imposed articulation, and antagonistic articulation. These were expressed through texts of the protests (such as photographics, videos, and speeches), by the parliamentary rhetoric and media coverage, and through overt affiliations with political parties. In our analysis, chains of equivalence become a means through which scholars of extremism can understand questions and notions of mainstreaming and fringe politics. While conceived of by Laclau and Mouffe as a liberatory tool of left-wing political organising, we argue that chains of equivalence is a powerful explanatory concept for understanding our current political moment and the global resurgence of far-right politics—although, notably, there has also been a recent revival of interest in constructing left-wing chains of equivalence (Jäger). Considering the imprecision and contingency of terms such as “mainstream” and “mainstreaming” (Brown et al.), and the erroneous tendency to position ‘mainstream’ in binary opposition to the ‘extreme’ (Kallis), the chains of equivalence framework enables us to better understand how hegemony is constructed. Within this framework, signifiers such as 'transgender people’ are articulated by heterogenous groups as an antagonistic “other”, thus creating a “frontier” (Laclau) wherein groups with ostensibly contradictory ideologies can form discursive alliances. Thus, we are primarily interested in how perceived linkages between empty signifiers can produce changes in political discourse and give the appearance of solidity across disparate groups. The “Let Women Speak” rally proves an analytically valuable case, as through this we can observe how chains of equivalence can both unify and cohere, as well as tear and rupture. We can trace this rupture through Deeming’s expulsion from the party and the subsequent judgement of Pesutto having defamed Deeming (Asher et al.). In this article, we state our understanding of chains of equivalence, drawing on the work also of other scholars who have applied the concept across a body of work examining far-right politics. We argue that through this analysis, we should not understand the far right as having a clear and coherent ideology that can be succinctly captured and debated. Rather, the dynamics of internal contradictions that scholars have struggled to account for in contemporary analyses of far-right politics are a feature and not a bug. These contradictions between disparate groups are accommodated discursively through chains of equivalence. The disagreement—in some sense—is the point. It reveals how these organisations can accommodate differences so long as the antagonists and grievances remain the focal point of their political activity. Understanding Chains of Equivalence Hegemony and Socialist Strategy begins with the premise that social identities have no essential content in advance of the political practices which assemble them. Articulation, for Laclau and Mouffe, is any such practice which establishes relations between elements such that the identity of those elements is modified by the relation in itself (105). Prior to articulation, a grievance circulates as an element, a floating unit of meaning available to competing political projects. When grievances are articulated within a discourse they can become moments, partially stable elements with positions relative to other moments. Such a stabilisation can only ever be partial, as for Laclau and Mouffe no single discourse can ever entirely exhaust the total field of meaning. Such a surplus of meaning provides a sense of hope for their project, as it entails that every state of hegemony is ultimately reversible. Such contingency means that progressive hegemonies grounded in discourses of social justice are just as available to contestation and reverse (Laclau, Butler, & Žižek). Two logics govern how articulation proceeds. The logic of difference expands a discourse by absorbing demands as distinct particulars, with each processed on their own terms. This, for Laclau and Mouffe, is the characteristic operation of a functioning liberal-democratic order which routes difference through policy channels. Conversely, the logic of equivalence works in the opposite direction. Equivalence establishes that a series of otherwise unrelated demands are indeed equivalent, not through their shared positive content but through a shared obstacle, antagonist, or grievance: as Mouffe states elsewhere, “the creation of an ‘Us’ ... only exists by distinguishing itself from a ‘Them’” (7). During the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, what the anti-vaccination protester, sovereign citizen, and libertarian politician had in common was not their ideology, but shared antagonists in the form of governments and public health officials. Equivalence subverts difference. As the chain of equivalence lengthens, the specific content of each demand is either cancelled, or shifted down in priority, so that what often survives in discourse is a shared negativity in relation to a common antagonist (Laclau and Mouffe 127-34). Because totality or universality is an impossibility, the hegemonic identity becomes “its own particularity embodying an unachievable fullness” (Laclau 71): an “empty signifier”. As such, the empty signifier through which the equivalential chain is expressed—the “us”—can be understood as such because it has been emptied of any particular meaning but has nonetheless come to represent a wide range of heterogenous demands, identities, or struggles. It arises from the simultaneous impossibility and necessity to unify disparate elements through a collective identity. Chains of equivalence, therefore, require an externality, an outside. As Devenney states, “the equivalential link is expressed negatively. It unifies different demands, identities and social groups against something which all oppose. What they have in common is what they reject” (87). Antagonism is therefore not constructed as a conflict between two distinct constituted interests, but is instead conceptualised as the experience of a limit, a discursive force preventing social identities from becoming fully themselves. The antagonist is thus constitutive. They are the enemy of the movement’s coherence, and thus become capacious enough to be blamed for all the grievances contained within the chain. As such, the unifying antagonistic floating signifier undergoes transformations as its role in the chain shifts. Unlike an empty signifier, which has been stripped of specific meaning so that it may represent heterogenous demands, a floating signifier is a site of contestation whose meaning is disputed by opposing political discourses. As an example, we might consider the term “woke” as a floating signifier that, for right-wing coalitions, is used to articulate any number of political grievances but, for Black Americans, functions as a term that signals the need to stay alert to racial prejudice and discrimination. Such terms are never truly required to be particularly defined, operating instead as ambiguous nodal points, fixations which defer and slow down the sliding of meaning long enough for a discourse to hold its shape (112). We should note that while we understand Laclau and Mouffe’s theory of discourse to be a pragmatically useful analytical concept for conceptualising modern far-right politics, it is not without objection. In a long-running debate with Laclau and Mouffe, Ži

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
M/C Journal
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3343
Primary Topic
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Never Break the Chain: Revisiting Chains of Equivalence to Understand Coalition Building and New Far-Right Discursive Organisation

Alex Shermon, Claudia Young
M/C Journal
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
article

Never Break the Chain: Revisiting Chains of Equivalence to Understand Coalition Building and New Far-Right Discursive Organisation

Alex Shermon, Claudia Young
article en

Abstract

Introduction On the morning of 18 March 2023, two crowds occupied the steps of Victoria’s Parliament House on Spring Street. The primary group had gathered for the “Let Women Speak” rally, an event on the Australian tour of the British anti-transgender activist Kellie-Jay Keen-Minshull (also known as Posie Parker), and was addressed by then-Liberal MLC Moira Deeming, former federal Liberal candidate Katherine Deves, and other gender-critical feminists. Another group of approximately thirty men in black clothing and balaclavas from the National Socialist Network (NSN) marched along Spring Street chanting “white power”, unfurled a banner which read “destroy paedo freaks”, and performed the Nazi salute – then lawful in the state (Elkin). Moira Deeming is not affiliated with proscribed far-right extremist organisations, and yet, through her involvement in the “Let Women Speak” rally, she was discursively aligned with a neo-Nazi organisation, resulting in then-Opposition Leader John Pesutto moving to expel her from the parliamentary party (Kolovos). In this article, we ask how this affiliation was made legible. Gender-critical and far-right discourses were not strangers to one another before Spring Street. Hines has demonstrated extensive links between gender-critical feminism and the far-right in the United Kingdom. Mayer and Sauer have also shown how “gender ideology” can function as an empty signifier linking anti-abortion, men’s rights, anti-LGBTQ+, and anti-feminist discourses in Austria. Butler has similarly demonstrated the transnational alliances, both implicit and explicit, that have formed in opposition to what they term the “phantasm of gender”. We are not attempting to revisit this overlap, but instead narrow our focus towards an analysis of how groups which offer mutually incompatible accounts of why transgender people constitute a threat became co-present and mutually legible within a single political event, and how that legibility then collapsed. We do so by drawing on Laclau and Mouffe’s notion of chains of equivalence. Chains of equivalence provide an extension on notions of “grievance politics” (Flinders and Hinterleitner) by contextualising far-right groups in broader discourses. What Liberal party members, the NSN, gender-critical feminists, and religious conservatives shared on Spring Street was not an explicit policy platform or ideology but, rather, a shared antagonist: transgender people. We identify three articulations of equivalence formed in this instance: agonistic articulation, imposed articulation, and antagonistic articulation. These were expressed through texts of the protests (such as photographics, videos, and speeches), by the parliamentary rhetoric and media coverage, and through overt affiliations with political parties. In our analysis, chains of equivalence become a means through which scholars of extremism can understand questions and notions of mainstreaming and fringe politics. While conceived of by Laclau and Mouffe as a liberatory tool of left-wing political organising, we argue that chains of equivalence is a powerful explanatory concept for understanding our current political moment and the global resurgence of far-right politics—although, notably, there has also been a recent revival of interest in constructing left-wing chains of equivalence (Jäger). Considering the imprecision and contingency of terms such as “mainstream” and “mainstreaming” (Brown et al.), and the erroneous tendency to position ‘mainstream’ in binary opposition to the ‘extreme’ (Kallis), the chains of equivalence framework enables us to better understand how hegemony is constructed. Within this framework, signifiers such as 'transgender people’ are articulated by heterogenous groups as an antagonistic “other”, thus creating a “frontier” (Laclau) wherein groups with ostensibly contradictory ideologies can form discursive alliances. Thus, we are primarily interested in how perceived linkages between empty signifiers can produce changes in political discourse and give the appearance of solidity across disparate groups. The “Let Women Speak” rally proves an analytically valuable case, as through this we can observe how chains of equivalence can both unify and cohere, as well as tear and rupture. We can trace this rupture through Deeming’s expulsion from the party and the subsequent judgement of Pesutto having defamed Deeming (Asher et al.). In this article, we state our understanding of chains of equivalence, drawing on the work also of other scholars who have applied the concept across a body of work examining far-right politics. We argue that through this analysis, we should not understand the far right as having a clear and coherent ideology that can be succinctly captured and debated. Rather, the dynamics of internal contradictions that scholars have struggled to account for in contemporary analyses of far-right politics are a feature and not a bug. These contradictions between disparate groups are accommodated discursively through chains of equivalence. The disagreement—in some sense—is the point. It reveals how these organisations can accommodate differences so long as the antagonists and grievances remain the focal point of their political activity. Understanding Chains of Equivalence Hegemony and Socialist Strategy begins with the premise that social identities have no essential content in advance of the political practices which assemble them. Articulation, for Laclau and Mouffe, is any such practice which establishes relations between elements such that the identity of those elements is modified by the relation in itself (105). Prior to articulation, a grievance circulates as an element, a floating unit of meaning available to competing political projects. When grievances are articulated within a discourse they can become moments, partially stable elements with positions relative to other moments. Such a stabilisation can only ever be partial, as for Laclau and Mouffe no single discourse can ever entirely exhaust the total field of meaning. Such a surplus of meaning provides a sense of hope for their project, as it entails that every state of hegemony is ultimately reversible. Such contingency means that progressive hegemonies grounded in discourses of social justice are just as available to contestation and reverse (Laclau, Butler, & Žižek). Two logics govern how articulation proceeds. The logic of difference expands a discourse by absorbing demands as distinct particulars, with each processed on their own terms. This, for Laclau and Mouffe, is the characteristic operation of a functioning liberal-democratic order which routes difference through policy channels. Conversely, the logic of equivalence works in the opposite direction. Equivalence establishes that a series of otherwise unrelated demands are indeed equivalent, not through their shared positive content but through a shared obstacle, antagonist, or grievance: as Mouffe states elsewhere, “the creation of an ‘Us’ ... only exists by distinguishing itself from a ‘Them’” (7). During the COVID-19 pandemic, for example, what the anti-vaccination protester, sovereign citizen, and libertarian politician had in common was not their ideology, but shared antagonists in the form of governments and public health officials. Equivalence subverts difference. As the chain of equivalence lengthens, the specific content of each demand is either cancelled, or shifted down in priority, so that what often survives in discourse is a shared negativity in relation to a common antagonist (Laclau and Mouffe 127-34). Because totality or universality is an impossibility, the hegemonic identity becomes “its own particularity embodying an unachievable fullness” (Laclau 71): an “empty signifier”. As such, the empty signifier through which the equivalential chain is expressed—the “us”—can be understood as such because it has been emptied of any particular meaning but has nonetheless come to represent a wide range of heterogenous demands, identities, or struggles. It arises from the simultaneous impossibility and necessity to unify disparate elements through a collective identity. Chains of equivalence, therefore, require an externality, an outside. As Devenney states, “the equivalential link is expressed negatively. It unifies different demands, identities and social groups against something which all oppose. What they have in common is what they reject” (87). Antagonism is therefore not constructed as a conflict between two distinct constituted interests, but is instead conceptualised as the experience of a limit, a discursive force preventing social identities from becoming fully themselves. The antagonist is thus constitutive. They are the enemy of the movement’s coherence, and thus become capacious enough to be blamed for all the grievances contained within the chain. As such, the unifying antagonistic floating signifier undergoes transformations as its role in the chain shifts. Unlike an empty signifier, which has been stripped of specific meaning so that it may represent heterogenous demands, a floating signifier is a site of contestation whose meaning is disputed by opposing political discourses. As an example, we might consider the term “woke” as a floating signifier that, for right-wing coalitions, is used to articulate any number of political grievances but, for Black Americans, functions as a term that signals the need to stay alert to racial prejudice and discrimination. Such terms are never truly required to be particularly defined, operating instead as ambiguous nodal points, fixations which defer and slow down the sliding of meaning long enough for a discourse to hold its shape (112). We should note that while we understand Laclau and Mouffe’s theory of discourse to be a pragmatically useful analytical concept for conceptualising modern far-right politics, it is not without objection. In a long-running debate with Laclau and Mouffe, Ži

M/C JournalVol. 29(6)
The University of Melbourne (AU)
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon