The Academic Bazaar: Informal Institutions, Social Trust, and Career Strategies among Students and Young People in Afghanistan
This study explores how students and young people in Afghanistan have adapted to the uncertain career environment, unstable administration and political changes that have occurred after the restructuring of the state post 2021. Using a mixed methods approach this paper explores how students use personal informal networks (called wasita) to adapt. This used a quantitative survey of N = 250 respondents from all 34 provinces across the country. The findings were further explored using 15 in-depth qualitative interviews with key informants from public and private universities, recent high school graduates and a refugee student (INT_01 to INT_15). Using Helmke and Levitsky's typology of informal institutions, Noah Coburn's idea of bazaar politics and Barnett Rubin's theory of fragmented states, this paper shows how students use personal informal networks (wasita) rationally as an informal substitute solution to overcome severe administrative issues and institutional collapse. The quantitative results show that 81.2% see personal connections as crucial to their career progression. 38.4% have had disrupted higher education and 82.4% face huge financial barriers. The qualitative results show a Merit Paradox. Interviewees described spending over 10 hours a week improving their technical skills (Coding, AI, English) but recognise that merit does not play a major role when being hired. One interviewee described a 70/30 mental tax, spending up to 70% of their time worrying about the political uncertainty. This paper shows that students networking and creating their own digital solutions are not just examples of nepotism but examples of agency and informal self help.
Authors
- Israr Ahmad Arghandiwal
Institutions
- American University of Afghanistan (AF)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24421026
- Primary Topic
- Education and Labor Relations
- Type
- preprint