Theory of life imprisonment for betrayal against the state
This paper proposes an alternative punishment theory for betrayal against the state, covering corruption, treason, and terrorism. Conventional temporary imprisonment is argued to be disproportionate, because offenders can still enjoy the proceeds of crime and return to public life after serving their sentence. This theory offers life imprisonment not merely as deprivation of liberty, but as permanent and measured restriction of civil rights through four pillars: legal, economic, social, and humanitarian.The legal pillar proposes life imprisonment for cases meeting a loss threshold. The economic pillar proposes measured impoverishment through confiscation of crime proceeds only, while protecting lawful family assets, plus a lifetime ban on state salary, pension, and facilities, and lifetime account supervision based on a court verdict.The social pillar proposes inclusion in the National Blacklist (D-BEN), bi-monthly reporting obligations, and a 10-year media appearance ban with judicial review for good behavior. The humanitarian pillar guarantees basic rights: three meals a day, decent housing, and basic health services. Torture and murder are absolutely prohibited.This theory is secured by a Main Special Clause: D-BEN can only be decided by a court verdict with permanent legal force, never by the executive, under a tripartite model of judiciary, executive, and independent management. It is closed by a Reputation Restoration Clause: if a Judicial Review acquits the convict, the name must be removed from D-BEN within 1 x 24 hours, with public announcement and compensation.Prepared as a de lege ferenda proposal within the 1945 Constitution of Indonesia and human rights, and open to empirical testing and constitutional review under Popper's falsification principle.
Authors
- Muhamad Qodirun (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0003-9135-5869)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24419253
- Primary Topic
- Criminal Law and Policy
- Type
- preprint