An Open Letter to the Quantum-Computing, Thermodynamic-AI, and AI-Evaluation Communities: Thermodynamic, Algebraic, and Psychometric Bounds on Hybrid Quantum–Photonic and Neuro-Symbolic General Intelligence
This document is written as an open letter to researchers in topological quantum computing (including teams atMicrosoft Development Center Copenhagen and NIST), thermodynamic AI hardware, formal verification, and AIevaluation. Across sixteen prior works and a subsequent Majorana–photonic core synthesis [1–17], we proposed subLandauer optomagnetic logic, interferometric Majorana sector-gates, cohomological sheaf guardrails, closed-formcontext-abstraction limits, the AISA-T meta-cognition benchmark, and game-theoretic dissipation models. A rigorousphysical, algebraic, and psychometric audit uncovers critical gaps: an unaccounted thermodynamic cost of dissipativesheaf/radiative guardrails, a ten-to-thirteen-order-of-magnitude drive and Carnot omission in optomagneticswitching, a dropped scale factor in the context boundary reducing tokens to , non-tracepreserving Kraus operators paired with incompatible JVM/n8n latencies, Jacobi-violating neural GENERICbrackets, confabulatory AISA-T self-reports, and misstated 2021 World Championship chess dynamics.Here we establish a self-consistent theoretical and benchmark synthesis. First, we prove the Sagawa–Ueda /Landauer Guardrail Theorem quantifying the exact wall-plug energy bill of cohomological filtering, magic-statedistillation, and cryogenic refrigeration alongside Margolus–Levitin and Sidis open-system bounds. Second, we derivethe exact Lambert- context-abstraction boundary and repair the reduced density, commutator, Chernoff, Kraus,and diffeomorphism-pullback GENERIC equations. Third, we reform AISA-T into a proper-scoring behavioralprotocol (AISA-T v2.0) and formulate a 50-move-clock absorbing Quantal Response Equilibrium chess Markovmodel.
Authors
- peter de ceuster
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24428692
- Primary Topic
- Quantum Computing Algorithms and Architecture
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00