THE CONDITION-AGENCY-SYSTEM COMPATIBILITY THEORY (CASCT)
This paper proposes the Condition-Agency-System Compatibility Theory (CASCT), a conditional and generalizable framework for examining systems whose functioning depends on decisions or actions taken by relatively autonomous agents.The framework addresses situations in which agents' independent choices, actual capabilities, or legitimate objectives become incompatible with requirements attributed to a larger system. It asks where the incompatibility originates, why it arises, whether changes in external conditions and internal states can reduce it, and whether the system itself must be redesigned when voluntary compatibility cannot be achieved.The proposed default mechanism, Condition-Mediated Mutual Compatibility (CMMC), proceeds through detection, causal diagnosis, condition analysis, agency assessment, condition reconfiguration, agency support, system reconfiguration, compatibility assessment, and feedback.A set-based model distinguishes the set of rights-respecting voluntary decision profiles from the set of profiles that satisfy explicitly specified system-viability criteria. Their intersection defines a conditional compatibility set.The paper uses the Reproductive Autonomy-Demographic Continuity Dilemma (RADCD) as its permanent primary case and carries it through an eleven-layer architecture. It also outlines applications to environmental management, organizations, political institutions, shared resources, and human-technology systems.The framework is a theoretical proposal, not an empirically validated universal law.Its contribution, scope, mathematical adequacy, and novelty remain subject to systematic literature review, operationalization, empirical testing, and independent replication.System compatibility; agency; autonomy; systemic functioning; condition analysis; voluntary alignment; adaptive systems; demographic change; reproductive autonomy; feedback
Authors
- Shamiul Hoque Shan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24425666
- Primary Topic
- Complex Systems and Decision Making
- Type
- preprint