A Layered Attribution Framework for Machine Consciousness: Life, Consciousness, Self, Volition, and Self-Awareness as Observer-Relative Judgments
This paper addresses a practical predicament: how to tell whether a machine is conscious. Behavioral tests cannot distinguish genuine consciousness from a good imitation; indicator lists derived from theory depend on theories that are themselves unsettled. The paper proposes no new theory of consciousness and adjudicates no dispute within consciousness science; its contribution is methodological. It offers a five-layer framework, progressive by axiomatic choice: life (endogenous triggering, not biological life), consciousness, self, volition, and self-awareness. Its output maps where disagreements about machine consciousness are located, not whether any system is conscious. Unlike a parallel list of indicators, higher-layer verdicts presuppose the verdict at the life layer. Each layer provides an observable or inferable entry point, the practice the judgment is relative to, and pre-registered failure conditions: what new evidence would withdraw the verdict. Layer dependence is a methodological axiom, not a metaphysical claim that consciousness requires life; every verdict is conditional on that choice. The consciousness layer is judged under a weak, checkable sense, with no claim of phenomenal consciousness. Meeting its criteria is not a consciousness verdict. Observer-relativity concerns the practice of making attribution judgments, not the system judged. Evaluability makes disagreements between practices locatable and discussable rather than empty. The application provides steps for assessing current AI and shows why stable feedback is misread as consciousness while the gaps at the life and volition layers go unnoticed; its verdicts rest on a conditional architectural inference checked under a declared threshold.
Authors
- Wan-Jiu Yang (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-6128-7610)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24411175
- Primary Topic
- Philosophy and Theoretical Science
- Type
- preprint