Teaching Professional Judgement in AI-Enabled Decision Environments: The JUF Research Programme: Framework, Simulation Design and Research Agenda
Working paper (not peer reviewed). Revised version of a paper presented at the 6th CLBS Research and Knowledge Exchange Symposium, University of West London, 6 July 2026. Comments welcome. This paper addresses how business education might systematically develop a capacity that financial regulation increasingly presupposes: trained human oversight of AI outputs. The EU AI Act requires deployers of high-risk AI systems, a category that includes creditworthiness assessment, to assign human oversight to people with the necessary competence, training and authority (for such systems, from 2 December 2027), and UK and US model-risk expectations call for models to be subject to effective challenge. It proposes the Judgement Under Uncertainty Framework (JUF), a preliminary pedagogical framework, not yet empirically validated, that organises professional reasoning in AI-enabled environments into six stages, drawing on research on automation bias, dual-process cognition and model-risk governance. It distinguishes the stages at which machine processing can contribute most from those that currently depend most on human verification and judgement, while accountability runs throughout. The paper then presents The Missing £50,000 Challenge, a 45-minute simulation, followed by a structured debrief, in which teams analyse evidence before receiving a confident but unsupported AI report, so that challenging an AI conclusion is experienced rather than only instructed. The design draws on cognitive forcing functions, experiential learning and professional identity formation. A reflection on the author's first use of the underlying decision-room approach (April 2026) explains how the design developed; it reports no student data. The paper sets out research questions and a pilot evaluation design, subject to ethics approval, which includes a version in which the AI report's conclusion is supported, so that appropriate reliance, not scepticism alone, can be assessed. Its contribution is conceptual and design-based: a teachable synthesis and an instrument specified for empirical testing. This paper is the reference statement of JUF version 1.0 and The Missing £50,000 Challenge.
Authors
- Yianni Doumenis
Institutions
- University of West London (GB)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24425639
- Primary Topic
- Management and Marketing Education
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00