Seven Ways to Assess the Impact of Drones in Conservation: An Evidence-Informed Framework Across Air, Land and Water
This practitioner-led foundation paper proposes an evidence-informed framework for assessing the conservation value of drones across air, land, surface-water and underwater settings. The framework considers six potential contributions: better ecological information; better use of money, time and resources; changes in risk to people; delivery of a usable result when needed; effects on wildlife and habitats; and making previously difficult conservation work possible. A seventh, overarching question asks whether the work improves conservation decisions and ecological outcomes. Assessment begins with the conservation need, the people responsible and feasible alternatives. It considers the complete operation, including data quality, costs, risks, wildlife welfare, local capability, and First Nations and Indigenous authority and knowledge. Four evidence levels distinguish technical achievement, comparative evidence, documented management use and ecological outcomes. Levels apply to individual claims. A comparison may favour a drone, favour an alternative or remain inconclusive. The accompanying technical supplement provides fourteen assessment categories, seven technical measures, a reusable worksheet and evidence guidance. Project ECHIDNA (drones) is a proposed test case; ground and underwater examples are hypothetical. Version 1.0 provides a foundation for practical toolkit development, user testing and further scientific evaluation. An online tool and AI assistance are possible future developments. This conceptual framework has not been independently validated, and the paper has not undergone journal peer review.
Authors
- David Roy Guerin (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0000-7196-1851)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24388127
- Primary Topic
- Wildlife Ecology and Conservation
- Type
- preprint