The Brain Does Not Fill the Skull: A 42-Species Occupancy Audit Finds Ruler Chaos, Not a Constant

Fossil encephalisation quotients rest on an identity: that endocranial volume (ECV) — the volume inside the skull — equals brain volume, an occupancy of 100%. This paper joins the two literatures that measure the two sides of that identity and computes occupancy directly. Under a pre-registered protocol, we joined endocast volumes (Dembitzer et al., 2022; Waugh & Thewissen, 2021; Sakai et al., 2016) to brain volumes (the Patzke et al., 2015 compilation; the same sources' paired values; Brain Catalogue MRI) for 42 mammal species — a far smaller overlap than either literature suggests. Median occupancy is 0.919 (IQR 0.824–0.973), but only 40.5% of species land inside the 90–100% band the identity implies, and 19.0% exceed 100% — physically impossible values that diagnose ruler mismatch rather than biology. The cleanest arm, 26 species with brain and ECV from the same source, gives a median of 0.920 with none above 100%; a bridge arm pairing modern endocasts with the histology-lineage brain compilation gives a median of 1.010, with 60% of species above 100%. Whole orders sit outside the band (Artiodactyla 0.79, Cetacea 0.79, Perissodactyla 0.84), and the largest modern ECV dataset silently back-calculates endocast volume from brain volume for 149 of its species — an assumed ~90% occupancy wearing a lab coat. Credit where it is due: that occupancy varies and is not 100% is Waugh & Thewissen's (2021) established result — a directly measured range of 33–98%, with the bowhead as their outlier — and this audit builds on their paired table. What the audit adds is the cross-compilation picture, and it is the sharper half: the field's rulers disagree by more than the shortfall itself, and the largest modern ECV dataset's back-calculation is a circularity — an assumed occupancy encoded as if it were a measurement. No single occupancy constant survives contact with the joined data. Keywords: endocranial volume; encephalisation quotient; occupancy; comparative neuroanatomy; measurement; pre-registration

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24409378
Primary Topic
Evolution and Paleontology Studies
Type
preprint
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
preprint

The Brain Does Not Fill the Skull: A 42-Species Occupancy Audit Finds Ruler Chaos, Not a Constant

Atharva Chourey
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Evolution and Paleontology Studies
preprint

The Brain Does Not Fill the Skull: A 42-Species Occupancy Audit Finds Ruler Chaos, Not a Constant

Atharva Chourey
preprint en

Abstract

Fossil encephalisation quotients rest on an identity: that endocranial volume (ECV) — the volume inside the skull — equals brain volume, an occupancy of 100%. This paper joins the two literatures that measure the two sides of that identity and computes occupancy directly. Under a pre-registered protocol, we joined endocast volumes (Dembitzer et al., 2022; Waugh & Thewissen, 2021; Sakai et al., 2016) to brain volumes (the Patzke et al., 2015 compilation; the same sources' paired values; Brain Catalogue MRI) for 42 mammal species — a far smaller overlap than either literature suggests. Median occupancy is 0.919 (IQR 0.824–0.973), but only 40.5% of species land inside the 90–100% band the identity implies, and 19.0% exceed 100% — physically impossible values that diagnose ruler mismatch rather than biology. The cleanest arm, 26 species with brain and ECV from the same source, gives a median of 0.920 with none above 100%; a bridge arm pairing modern endocasts with the histology-lineage brain compilation gives a median of 1.010, with 60% of species above 100%. Whole orders sit outside the band (Artiodactyla 0.79, Cetacea 0.79, Perissodactyla 0.84), and the largest modern ECV dataset silently back-calculates endocast volume from brain volume for 149 of its species — an assumed ~90% occupancy wearing a lab coat. Credit where it is due: that occupancy varies and is not 100% is Waugh & Thewissen's (2021) established result — a directly measured range of 33–98%, with the bowhead as their outlier — and this audit builds on their paired table. What the audit adds is the cross-compilation picture, and it is the sharper half: the field's rulers disagree by more than the shortfall itself, and the largest modern ECV dataset's back-calculation is a circularity — an assumed occupancy encoded as if it were a measurement. No single occupancy constant survives contact with the joined data. Keywords: endocranial volume; encephalisation quotient; occupancy; comparative neuroanatomy; measurement; pre-registration

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Evolution and Paleontology Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon
The Brain Does Not Fill the Skull: A 42-Species Occupancy Audit Finds Ruler Chaos, Not a Constant — Atharva Chourey · Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research) (2026) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS