State-Level Two-Child Policies and Progression to a Third Child in India: Evidence from Three Policy Waves How Effective are they, and for Whom?
Over the past few decades, a number of states of India implemented two-child policies as population control measures. Still, two-child policies remain under consideration by states and the nation even as the country's total fertility rate has fallen below replacement with restrictions in some states and recently promises for cash transfers for larger families in others. Whether governments have penalised third births or paid families to have them has depended on political agendas rather than demographic needs.This paper investigates the effectiveness of implemented policies in achieving their intended demographic objectives. Using difference-in-differences analysis with matching techniques on three rounds of National Family Health Survey data (2005-2021), we examine whether these policies reduced progression to a third birth, and whether they did so differently for families without sons and for poor households. Two-child policies produced only a modest additional reduction in third births, concentrated in the 1996 and 2004 waves, and no detectable effect in the most recent 2007 wave. Families without sons were substantially more likely to have a third child than families with at least one son, before the policy and after, in implementation and comparison states alike; the same ordering holds, more weakly, for poor versus non-poor households. Neither differential narrowed after implementation. Triple-difference estimates provide no evidence that the policies operated differently by poverty status in any wave, or by sibling sex composition. This study advances the literature on population policy by showing that son preference and economic constraint structure third-birth behaviour independently of the policy, and that the instruments these policies rely on: disqualification from government employment and from contesting local elections engage in neither. These findings have substantial implications for population policy design in developing countries, suggesting that effective interventions must address underlying socioeconomic determinants and cultural norms rather than relying primarily on incentive structures that conflict with deeply held values and economic realities.
Authors
- Varnitha Kurli (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6028-5253)
- Jane Menken
Publication Details
- Journal
- SocArXiv (OSF Preprints)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.31235/osf.io/xpuqe_v1
- Primary Topic
- Demographic Trends and Gender Preferences
- Type
- preprint