Soil Fertility Constraints and Gross Margin Sensitivity in Maize Production: Evidence from Smallholder Production Systems in Hwedza District, Zimbabwe
Smallholder maize production in Zimbabwe remains central to food security and rural livelihoods, yet profitability is constrained by soil fertility limitations and yield variability. This study examined farm-level differences in productivity and profitability in Hwedza and Harare, focusing on soil nutrient status, input use and economic outcomes. Ten representative farm soil samples were analysed for soil fertility status using laboratory soil tests, yield measurements, gross margin calculations, and return per dollar invested. Results revealed moderate to strong acidity of pH 4.3-6.0, critically low phosphorus, deficient potassium and patchy calcium and magnesium levels. Laboratory prescriptions recommended substantial corrective inputs, including 300-2000kg/ha dolomitic lime (calcium magnesium carbonate), basal fertiliser, 100-500kg/ha compound D (N:7, P:14, K:7), and top dressing 300-650kg/ha ammonium nitrate 34.5% N. However, farmers applied significantly lower rates, with 30% complementing with cattle manure, reflecting affordability constraints and limited access to inputs. Yield outcomes ranged from 0.93-3.10t/ha, with 80% of the households producing below the gross margin-based break-even yield threshold of 2.16t/ha and a return per dollar invested break-even yield of 2.23t/ha. Gross margins varied sharply from -USD 250.4/ha to +USD 147.67/ha, while returns per dollar invested ranged from -USD 45 to +USD 0.25. Regression analysis confirmed yield as the dominant determinant of profitability. Local studies corroborate these findings, showing that profitability is strongly yield-dependent and that integrated nutrient management combining organic and inorganic inputs improves outcomes. Regional evidence from South Africa, Tanzania and Uganda similarly highlights the importance of resource access, balanced fertilisation, and cooperative structures in achieving sustainable intensification. This study demonstrates that yield optimisation above 2.16t/ha and 2.23t/ha is critical for profitability in smallholder maize systems of Hwedza. Addressing systematic barriers in soil acidity, high input costs, insufficient lime use, and limited fertilisation strategies requires a dual strategy combining agronomy and enabling policies. Agronomic interventions are implemented through lime application, balanced organic and inorganic fertiliser amendments, complemented by enabling policies such as input subsidies, credit schemes and market stabilisation. By bridging technical and economic dimensions, smallholder farmers can achieve higher yields, secure positive margins and sustain profitable returns, thereby strengthening resilience in sustainable smallholder maize production systems in Hwedza.
Authors
- Vimbai Samukange
- Trymore Kamunhukamwe
- Blessing Gumindoga
- Liana-Lisa Sakwa (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-1727-8335)
Institutions
- Scientific and Industrial Research and Development Centre (ZW)
Publication Details
- Journal
- International Journal of Research and Innovation in Applied Science
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.51584/ijrias.2026.11100139
- Primary Topic
- Agricultural Science and Fertilization
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00