Satisfied but not recommending: career outlook versus job satisfaction in Korean dentists' recommendation of dentistry to their children, and the student-to-dentist outlook gradient. A preregistered secondary analysis of two 2024 national surveys

This is a preregistration of a secondary-data analysis, deposited before any confirmatory test was run. It follows the Open Science Framework / Center for Open Science template for preregistration of secondary data analysis (Van den Akker et al., 2021). Question. Do Korean dentists' own career outlook and their current job satisfaction differ in how strongly they relate to recommending dentistry to their children, and does the same-wording outlook item fall at the student-to-dentist (graduation) boundary more than at other career stages? Data. A May 2024 online survey of members of the Korean Dental Association (2,033 dentists after cleaning) and a May 2024 online survey of dental students at seven schools (500 students after cleaning). Both are convenience samples. Hypotheses. H1: in an ordinal logit model for recommending dentistry to one's child, the standardised coefficient of own outlook exceeds that of job satisfaction (difference Delta, person-level bootstrap with re-standardisation, B = 5,000). Key secondary (gated by H1): the difference is larger for recommending to a child than for choosing dentistry again. H2: the outlook falls at the graduation boundary (clinical year 4 to career < 5 years) by more than the mean of the other adjacent stage differences in a nine-stage ordinal model (linear contrast, two-stage school-then-student bootstrap). H2 may be called a break only if two mandatory sensitivity checks do not point the other way: a boundary-age contrast and a negative-control analysis of eight vocational-value items. Contents. Data sources and cohort definitions, item wording and placement comparison between the two surveys, a disclosure of the marginal distributions the authors had already seen, variable definitions, analysis models, a rule for switching to a binary split if the proportional-odds assumption fails, Holm correction for two confirmatory tests, prespecified sensitivity analyses, analyses not done, interpretation rules, limitations and a deviation policy. Ethics: Institutional Review Board of Seoul National University School of Dentistry (S-D20240015); joint analysis of the two surveys is covered. Individual-level data cannot be shared publicly under the IRB approval; synthetic-data test code will be added to this record after the DOI is issued and before the first analysis of real data, and the analysis code will be deposited at publication. Funding: Institute of Health Policy, Korean Dental Association; National Research Foundation of Korea (MSIT) grant RS-2026-25593489. Authors (in order): Dong-Hun Han, You-Bin Yim, Ji-Eun Jeon, Yuyi Park, Hye-Sun Shin, Jae-In Ryu, Jae-Hoon Kim, Se-Hwan Jung, Ja-Won Cho (ORCIDs in the PDF).

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Published
2026-11-22
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24429457
Primary Topic
Dental Education, Practice, Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Satisfied but not recommending: career outlook versus job satisfaction in Korean dentists' recommendation of dentistry to their children, and the student-to-dentist outlook gradient. A preregistered secondary analysis of two 2024 national surveys

Se-Hwan Jung, Yuyi Park, Ji-Eun Jeon, Dong‐Hun Han et al.
Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Dental Education, Practice, Research
article

Satisfied but not recommending: career outlook versus job satisfaction in Korean dentists' recommendation of dentistry to their children, and the student-to-dentist outlook gradient. A preregistered secondary analysis of two 2024 national surveys

Se-Hwan Jung, Yuyi Park, Ji-Eun Jeon, Dong‐Hun Han, Ja-Won Cho, Hye‐Sun Shin, You-Bin Yim, Jae‐In Ryu, Jae‐Hoon Kim
article en

Abstract

This is a preregistration of a secondary-data analysis, deposited before any confirmatory test was run. It follows the Open Science Framework / Center for Open Science template for preregistration of secondary data analysis (Van den Akker et al., 2021). Question. Do Korean dentists' own career outlook and their current job satisfaction differ in how strongly they relate to recommending dentistry to their children, and does the same-wording outlook item fall at the student-to-dentist (graduation) boundary more than at other career stages? Data. A May 2024 online survey of members of the Korean Dental Association (2,033 dentists after cleaning) and a May 2024 online survey of dental students at seven schools (500 students after cleaning). Both are convenience samples. Hypotheses. H1: in an ordinal logit model for recommending dentistry to one's child, the standardised coefficient of own outlook exceeds that of job satisfaction (difference Delta, person-level bootstrap with re-standardisation, B = 5,000). Key secondary (gated by H1): the difference is larger for recommending to a child than for choosing dentistry again. H2: the outlook falls at the graduation boundary (clinical year 4 to career < 5 years) by more than the mean of the other adjacent stage differences in a nine-stage ordinal model (linear contrast, two-stage school-then-student bootstrap). H2 may be called a break only if two mandatory sensitivity checks do not point the other way: a boundary-age contrast and a negative-control analysis of eight vocational-value items. Contents. Data sources and cohort definitions, item wording and placement comparison between the two surveys, a disclosure of the marginal distributions the authors had already seen, variable definitions, analysis models, a rule for switching to a binary split if the proportional-odds assumption fails, Holm correction for two confirmatory tests, prespecified sensitivity analyses, analyses not done, interpretation rules, limitations and a deviation policy. Ethics: Institutional Review Board of Seoul National University School of Dentistry (S-D20240015); joint analysis of the two surveys is covered. Individual-level data cannot be shared publicly under the IRB approval; synthetic-data test code will be added to this record after the DOI is issued and before the first analysis of real data, and the analysis code will be deposited at publication. Funding: Institute of Health Policy, Korean Dental Association; National Research Foundation of Korea (MSIT) grant RS-2026-25593489. Authors (in order): Dong-Hun Han, You-Bin Yim, Ji-Eun Jeon, Yuyi Park, Hye-Sun Shin, Jae-In Ryu, Jae-Hoon Kim, Se-Hwan Jung, Ja-Won Cho (ORCIDs in the PDF).

Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
Seoul National University (KR), Kangwon National University (KR), Dongnam Health University (KR), Kyung Hee University (KR), Dankook University Dental Hospital (KR), Pusan National University (KR)
Dental Education, Practice, Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon