From immersion to educational world-making: applying secondary world theory to AI-supported XR design in teacher education
Extended Reality (XR) research in education has focused on immersion, presence, engagement, simulation and experiential learning. These perspectives explain immersive learning but do not fully account for the quality of the worlds learners enter. A virtual environment may be visually compelling while remaining pedagogically shallow, weakly structured or ethically unexamined. This study develops and applies an educational adaptation of Secondary World theory to examine AI-supported XR design in teacher education. The study draws on a theory-driven secondary mixed-methods analysis of an intervention involving 140 pre-service teachers working in 24 teams. Participants designed 48 virtual environments across CoSpaces and Minecraft, using ChatGPT for scenarios, learner personas and critique, and Spline for three-dimensional assets. The analysis examined team-level design artefacts, peer feedback, coded records and reflections across seven dimensions: coherence, depth, actionability, consequence, sub-creation, transfer and reflexivity. Four levels of educational world-making were identified: scenic immersion, task-world construction, pedagogical world construction and reflexive Secondary World-making. Most designs remained scenic or task-oriented, while fewer formed coherent pedagogical worlds integrating learner roles, actions, feedback and transfer. CoSpaces tended to support structured sequencing, while Minecraft supported spatial extension and collaborative construction. These patterns reflected platform affordances and design sequence. Generative AI was most strongly associated with higher-level world-making when used to test assumptions, accessibility, learner agency and pedagogical coherence rather than generate content. The study contributes a framework for evaluating XR learning environments beyond immersion and argues that teacher education should prepare future teachers to design, evaluate and critique the educational worlds technology makes possible.
Authors
- Jason Zagami (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0000-0003-2003-9546)
Institutions
- Griffith University (AU)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Computers & Education X Reality
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.1016/j.cexr.2026.100190
- Primary Topic
- Virtual Reality Applications and Impacts
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00