Worldline-cluster, annealed-spectral, and telescoping obstructions to a phonon-frequency pairing ceiling in the Holstein model
Scope. Whether the pair-correlation decay temperature k_B T_pair of the spinful Holstein model obeys a rigorous phonon-frequency ceiling k_B T_pair <= C(t,U) Omega, uniformly in the volume and the chemical potential, remains open, and this preprint does not close it. Continuing three earlier obstruction papers, it consolidates five independently checked technical components that map out what can be proved on both sides of the remaining gap and where the leading closure strategies break down. Components. (1) Charged-skeleton influence bounds: an exact Parseval identity and disjoint-bump Gram inequality for the Lang-Firsov phonon action in the full unrestricted Fock space, an additive multi-transition barrier lower bound with constant 3/22, improving to 3/19 for half-width transitions, plus two structural obstructions at beta t^2/U >> 1: signless majorization fails on 16 of 160 four-hop neutral plaquette loops, and unexpanded-bath boundary subtraction cannot cancel an O(beta t^2/U) extensive mismatch. (2) Telescoping obstruction: an exact telescoping bound capping bare Lang-Firsov phonon suppression at a single L-independent endpoint factor, Hubbard-Stratonovich determinant positivity for all real mu with exact dimer cancellation, and a refutation of the literal strong-coupling bound via converged grand-canonical and canonical exact diagonalisation. (3) Annealed static-plus-Gaussian package: the static spectral package and a (beta Omega)^2/96 continuum first-variation bound, the coherent-state pressure sandwich and quantum zero-mode variance identity, a dimer counterexample ruling out unrestricted low-temperature transfer of static level counting, and the rejection of direct unweighted second-chaos normalization. (4) Annealed endpoint closure: an unweighted endpoint inequality gives only l^1 summability whereas a spatially weighted exponential-moment estimate implies the ceiling; the universal static Combes-Thomas base bound K_0 = (1 + pi/4)^2, an exact t=0 marginal suppression, an unconditional V=2 operator-norm proof and the exact s=0 derivative bound 1/24 + zeta(3)/(8 pi^3). (5) Neutral-dipole cluster expansion: a volume-, temperature-, frequency-, chemical-potential- and background-uniform Poghosyan-Ueltschi expansion for the neutral-loop gas and its perturbed exterior outside an Omega^-1 collar, with the open interior collar and four-hop virtual pair-return channels delineated. Verification. Every finite-arithmetic, exact-rational, interval-enclosure, exact-diagonalisation and quantum Monte Carlo statement is reproducible from the five standalone replay scripts archived with this preprint, each with a designated mutant battery. The manuscript states that it has not been peer reviewed, and records the use of AI tools for drafting, calculation and checking under the author's direction and review.
Authors
- Davis Rens
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24425676
- Primary Topic
- Quantum many-body systems
- Type
- preprint