Photograph-Based Assessment of Early Aquatic Decomposition and Postmortem Submersion Interval Estimation: A 61-Day Freshwater Pig-Carcass Study in the Netherlands
The interval between death and discovery (submersion) is difficult to estimate using decomposed remains due to the many environmental and encoded carcass-specific factors involved in aquatic decomposition, and the many post-mortem scoring systems that have been generated for direct examination of remains are not designed to be directly applied to the underwater photographic assessment of remains. In this study, the early decomposition of five pigs submersed in a freshwater lake in the Netherlands is described and the behavior of five scoring systems in photos is analyzed. Ten natural deaths piglets (374–2,307 g) were put in different wire cages at a depth of 11.4 m in Het Twiske on 20 July 2018. The carcass recorded were coded and photographed 3 x week over 61 days. For the photographic record, the following methods were used that are commonly associated with Megyesi, Heaton, Reh, van Daalen and Sluis. Throughout the observation period water temp was reported in as 15°C which equates to 15 ADD/d based on 0°C and 915 ADD/d at day 61. Carcasses were observed during the period for signs of bloating, which the detailed photographic records indicate occurred on day 16 (Pig 2), day 21 (Pigs 1 and 5) and day 24 (Pig 3). The smallest and the only stillborn carcass, pig 4, showed no sign of bloating. Progressively, the remains were becoming more and more buried with sediment, leading to only limited observations of surface features. The mean score – log ADD coefficient of determination were reported for Megyesi and Heaton (0.6704), van Daalen (0.6694), and Sluis (0.7938). They are "in-sample fit statistics" and not predictive validity statistics. Original thesis contains PMSI deviation summaries which are not sufficiently uniform and are not in the convention of tentative prediction errors. Moreover, the standard deviation is not a formal 95% confidence or prediction interval, but 4 times the standard deviation is not a formal interval. This study is exploratory and only to the five carcasses studied during one site, depth and season. Sediment cover, narrow range of photographic visibility and sharp scores transition puts restrictions on the applicability of existing photo costing system to PMSI estimation in the first 61 days of the immersion.
Authors
- Elco ten Hertog
- drs. ir. Marco Pot ND
Publication Details
- Journal
- Innovative Research Thoughts
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.36676/irt.v12.i4.1870
- Primary Topic
- Forensic Entomology and Diptera Studies
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00