Structure Versus Symptoms in Kienböck Disease: A Node-by-Node Appraisal of the Evidence Behind Stage-Based Treatment
A unified treatment algorithm for Kienböck disease combines radiographic (Lichtman) stage, lunate viability on magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), and arthroscopic grading of the articular surfaces. This critical narrative review asked which decision points of the algorithm have been tested against an alternative, whether any study has tested if stage modifies the benefit of surgery, and how far the evidence linking lunate structure to symptoms withstands scrutiny for survivor bias and regression to the mean. A structured PubMed search and citation tracking yielded 1,220 records, all screened by a single reviewer. After a record-by-record check of all retrieved randomised trials and systematic reviews, we included 47 studies. Structure-symptom studies were coded for design and bias exposure, and each algorithm node was mapped against its best evidence using an explicit power criterion (80% power for a moderate standardised difference). Advanced structural disease occurred in wrists without symptoms, and in treated cohorts structural findings at follow-up related weakly or not at all to patient-reported outcome; the association was modest in every design. No node rested on evidence above level II. The four randomised treatment trials analysed 16 to 30 patients each and compared techniques within a procedure family or tested an adjunct; none compared surgery with nonoperative care or met the power criterion. No study had tested a stage-by-treatment interaction. The radioscaphoid-angle criterion improved observer agreement at the stage IIIA-IIIB boundary, but agreement did not ensure concordance with cross-sectional imaging. The algorithm builds in a nonoperative trial without defining its failure in measured terms. Stage alone should not be treated as an indication for surgery or as a marker of treatment failure, and choosing between operations by structure remains reasoned but untested. Testing whether stage modifies the effect of surgery will require multicentre comparative studies with patient-reported primary outcomes and a prespecified interaction test.
Authors
- Mohamed Elsayed Abdelhalim Hassan
Publication Details
- Journal
- Cureus
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.7759/cureus.120049
- Primary Topic
- Orthopedic Surgery and Rehabilitation
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00