CAN REGENERATIVE DEVELOPMENT RECONCILE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTIVITY AND ECOLOGICAL CONSERVATION? A PROBLEMATIZING LITERATURE REVIEW OF SMALLHOLDER AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS

Agriculture must produce sufficient food while maintaining the ecological systems on which production depends. However, efforts to increase agricultural productivity can place pressure on soil health, biodiversity and other ecological functions, creating a productivity–conservation tension. This tension is particularly important in smallholder farming systems, where agricultural production, household livelihoods and natural resources are closely connected. This review examines whether, and under what conditions, Regenerative Development can help address this tension. The study adopts a problematising literature review approach, guided by Ecological Economics, Social-Ecological Systems theory and Regenerative Development as complementary analytical perspectives. A Scopus search retrieved 1,093 records. Following deduplication, 1,077 unique records remained. After removing non-English records and non-qualifying items, 1,048 records proceeded to title and abstract screening. Of these, 1,020 were retained in the review corpus and examined through abstract-based thematic analysis. Subsequently, 37 publications were shortlisted for detailed examination, and 33 full texts were obtained. The analysis draws particularly on Bisht (2021), which examines smallholder farming systems in Uttarakhand, India, and Schreefel et al. (2022), which provides a contrasting commercial dairy-farm benchmark from the Netherlands. The findings indicate that the productivity–conservation tension is shaped by economic, ecological and institutional conditions, rather than by farm management alone. The Uttarakhand case highlights the importance of common resources, local ecological knowledge, crop diversity and household livelihoods in sustaining smallholder farming systems. The Dutch case shows that improving some soil functions can reduce farm productivity and income. The farm also needed to purchase more animal feed to compensate for lower grassland production. Together, these findings suggest that improvements in ecological conditions do not necessarily secure wider social and economic benefits. Smallholder transitions also depend on reliable market access, institutional support, collective resource management and fair access to resources and decision-making. The review suggests that agricultural success should be judged in three connected ways: protecting the environment; ensuring that smallholder farmers can maintain a decent livelihood; and providing diverse, nutritious food while protecting local control over food and farming. It concludes that Regenerative Development may provide a useful way to understand how agriculture can support both production and environmental protection. However, this depends on addressing the wider economic, social and institutional conditions that affect smallholder farmers. Further research is needed to understand how these relationships operate across different farming systems and social settings.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
EPRA International Journal of Agriculture and Rural Economic Research
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.36713/epra32194
Primary Topic
Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

CAN REGENERATIVE DEVELOPMENT RECONCILE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTIVITY AND ECOLOGICAL CONSERVATION? A PROBLEMATIZING LITERATURE REVIEW OF SMALLHOLDER AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS

Tharalakshmi Asokakumar Korangode
EPRA International Journal of Agriculture and Rural Economic Research
Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development
article

CAN REGENERATIVE DEVELOPMENT RECONCILE AGRICULTURAL PRODUCTIVITY AND ECOLOGICAL CONSERVATION? A PROBLEMATIZING LITERATURE REVIEW OF SMALLHOLDER AGRICULTURAL SYSTEMS

Tharalakshmi Asokakumar Korangode
article en

Abstract

Agriculture must produce sufficient food while maintaining the ecological systems on which production depends. However, efforts to increase agricultural productivity can place pressure on soil health, biodiversity and other ecological functions, creating a productivity–conservation tension. This tension is particularly important in smallholder farming systems, where agricultural production, household livelihoods and natural resources are closely connected. This review examines whether, and under what conditions, Regenerative Development can help address this tension. The study adopts a problematising literature review approach, guided by Ecological Economics, Social-Ecological Systems theory and Regenerative Development as complementary analytical perspectives. A Scopus search retrieved 1,093 records. Following deduplication, 1,077 unique records remained. After removing non-English records and non-qualifying items, 1,048 records proceeded to title and abstract screening. Of these, 1,020 were retained in the review corpus and examined through abstract-based thematic analysis. Subsequently, 37 publications were shortlisted for detailed examination, and 33 full texts were obtained. The analysis draws particularly on Bisht (2021), which examines smallholder farming systems in Uttarakhand, India, and Schreefel et al. (2022), which provides a contrasting commercial dairy-farm benchmark from the Netherlands. The findings indicate that the productivity–conservation tension is shaped by economic, ecological and institutional conditions, rather than by farm management alone. The Uttarakhand case highlights the importance of common resources, local ecological knowledge, crop diversity and household livelihoods in sustaining smallholder farming systems. The Dutch case shows that improving some soil functions can reduce farm productivity and income. The farm also needed to purchase more animal feed to compensate for lower grassland production. Together, these findings suggest that improvements in ecological conditions do not necessarily secure wider social and economic benefits. Smallholder transitions also depend on reliable market access, institutional support, collective resource management and fair access to resources and decision-making. The review suggests that agricultural success should be judged in three connected ways: protecting the environment; ensuring that smallholder farmers can maintain a decent livelihood; and providing diverse, nutritious food while protecting local control over food and farming. It concludes that Regenerative Development may provide a useful way to understand how agriculture can support both production and environmental protection. However, this depends on addressing the wider economic, social and institutional conditions that affect smallholder farmers. Further research is needed to understand how these relationships operate across different farming systems and social settings.

EPRA International Journal of Agriculture and Rural Economic Research
Agriculture, Land Use, Rural Development
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon