The Normalization M_n = V_n/b for Lucas Sequences: A Critical Re-examination with Corrected Claims and New Results
We examine a recent proposal to normalize the Lucas sequence of the second kind, M_n = V_n/b, where Vn belongs to the characteristic quadratic x^2 - bx - d = 0 (D = b^2 + 4d), together with the novelty claims accompanying it. Our assessment is mixed, and we report both corrections and genuinely new results. (i) The generalized Cassini identity M_(n+1) M_(n-1) - M_n^2 = (D/b2)(-d)^(n-1) is a special case of a general identity valid for every second-order recurrence and arbitrary initial conditions: X_(n+1)X_(n-1) - X_n^2 = (b X_0 X_1 + d X_0^2 - X_1^2)(-d)^(n-1). We give a three-line proof and a unified table of the resulting constants for six derived sequences N_n, M_n, and the triad Sn = N_n + M_n, R_n = _Nn - M_n, P_n = N_n M_n. (ii) The reported higher prime-term density of M-derived sequences is not reproducible for the parameter pairs stated in the source, (b,d) = (2,8) and (3,12), whose terms from N_2 onward are all even (respectively, all divisible by 3); the reported figures reproduce exactly for the classical Jacobsthal pair (1,2), for which M_n = 2^n + (-1)^n combines Mersenne-type and Fermat-type terms. We prove structural rules: Nn prime implies n prime (with a single degenerate exception when b = ±1), while Mn prime requires n prime or a power of two. Numerically we confirm the Lagarias density 2/3 for prime divisors of first-kind sequences. (iii) The binomial representation of M_n, with the factor n/(n-k) and the 1/b normalization, appears to be genuinely new and constitutes the principal surviving claim of the original work. (iv) The Pell-type identity b2 M_n^2 - D N_n^2 = 4(-d)^n is the classical identity V_n^2 - D N_n^2 = 4(-d)^n in rescaled coordinates; the worked example (b,d) = (36,1) reproduces the fundamental unit 18 + 5·√13 of Q(√13). (v) The proposed PRNG based on the linear recurrence is cryptographically insecure: two consecutive outputs suffice to reconstruct the full two-sided output stream, and the Berlekamp–Massey algorithm recovers the minimal recurrence from 2L outputs. The 'controlled periodicity of fractional terms' carries zero entropy. We recommend withdrawing all cryptographic claims. (vi) The triple convergence of the term ratio, the ratio of partial sums, and the geometric mean of ratios to √D/b is a combination of Cesàro's theorem and the Stolz–Cesàro theorem. However, the three modes converge at sharply different rates: exponentially for the first two, and only as O(1/n) for the geometric mean. We derive the explicit second-order asymptotics gmn = (√D/b) · exp(C/(n-1) + O_(n-2)), with an explicitly computable constant C = Σ_k≥2 log((1+r^k)/(1-r^k)), r = |x_2/x_1|, and verify it to four significant digits for six parameter families - a refinement that appears to be new. We conclude with a corrected novelty assessment and concrete recommendations for the underlying article.
Authors
- Юрий Васильев (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0007-8338-7106)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24414938
- Primary Topic
- Advanced Mathematical Theories and Applications
- Type
- preprint