Shifting the Overton Window: The Existential Logic of Enemy Constructions in the New Biopolitics of the Far Right

Introduction The West has witnessed a shift in the Overton window towards more extreme rhetoric in recent years, with the ideological and discursive penetration of the far right in mainstream politics and media coverage. Such a shift, I argue, is driven in large part by an existential logic that underlies the normalisation of extreme ideas and discourses in contemporary far-right biopolitics. Given the far right’s conspiratorial worldview, the discursive strategy of normalisation often involves dual enemy constructions, in which the elite is cast as aligned with “an external foreign enemy” or “an internal ideological enemy” against the national ingroup (Kinnvall). As the construction of enemies often intersects with “exclusionary nationalism” (Carter) and populist appeals, I adopt “far right” as an umbrella term encompassing both the radical and extreme right (Pirro). While they share an exclusionary vision of the nation and an authoritarian attitude towards outgroups, their actual stances towards democracy are not always discernible, as the populist radical right political actors tend to hide their anti-democratic character to gain respectability and legitimacy. In the case of Australia, the COVID-19 pandemic provided an opportunity for the right-leaning news channel, News24 (formerly Sky News Australia), to produce and propagate conspiratorial content by exploiting public anger and fear over restrictive measures. More recently, the Bondi attack created a conducive political environment for far-right leader Pauline Hanson to justify her anti-Islam and anti-immigration agendas. Through a content analysis of Hanson’s Facebook posts following the 2025 Bondi attack and News24’s YouTube coverage of the “Great Reset” conspiracy narratives during the pandemic, I examine how they turn these events into an issue of existential struggle for the continued survival of the national community that is perceived as under threat from constructed enemies. Nazi Biopolitics versus New Far-Right Biopolitics Recalling Foucault, “biopolitics” functions as a politics of population management through the exercise of political biopower “to make live and to let die” in modern society (241). Historically, however, the term Biopolitik was mobilised by Nazi Germany to promote its eugenics program and racial policy (Liesen and Walsh). In this case, biopolitical measures implemented against Jews during the Holocaust represent the state use of extreme biopower for its genocidal agenda. As Foucault argues in Society Must Be Defended, racism is exercised in modern states to divide a population into groups deemed biologically desirable or undesirable, thereby legitimising the killing of the latter (254). While Nazi biopolitics is an extreme manifestation of modern racism, the contemporary far right has adapted this biopolitical logic to new concerns over borders and immigration, demographic change, and national identity. Rather than vanishing along with the Third Reich, the Nazi’s organic, exclusionary concepts of the Volk (people) and the Volkskörper (national body) have persisted in contemporary far-right politics (Rheindorf and Wodak). Under the guise of what French thinker Alain de Benoist calls “ethnopluralism” (Rueda), the far right could continue to draw boundaries around “the people” who constitute a culturally homogenous “national body” without always foregrounding race. In this way, new far-right biopolitics constructs a non-existent “white ethnostate” to normalise its exclusionary practices as necessary to cultural identity preservation, despite its underlying logic of biological racial differentiation. Far-right political actors can thus legitimise their calls for stricter border control and “remigration” as defensive measures against the so-called “Great Replacement” (Hernández Aguilar 81–2). This existential logic, when taken to its extreme by white supremacists such as Anders Breivik, Brenton Tarrant, and Patrick Crusius, served as a pretext for justifying their murderous violence as a form of self-defence for the wellbeing of the white population (Davis, “Violence as Method”). On the other hand, new far-right biopolitics goes beyond the issues of immigration, birth rates, and multiculturalism in its resistance to a perceived globalist biopower to govern public health and life. This form of resistance is particularly visible in the anti-lockdown and anti-vaccination movements during the COVID-19 pandemic. Notably through narratives of digital surveillance, technocratic governance, and globalist conspiracy, these public health measures were framed as a coordinated scheme of global elites for population control (Tuters and Willaert). In this case, far-right biopolitics is also a struggle over who governs life. Such discourse is generally anti-public, defined by its irrationality, antagonism, anti-elitism, anti-statism, anti-cosmopolitanism, and conspiratorial thinking (Davis, “Anti-Public Sphere”). Political Existentiality One important aspect, which lays the foundation for the normalisation of far-right biopolitical discourse, is collective identity construction. Following van de Wall, the concept of “political existentiality”, based on Carl Schmitt’s existentialist account of the political, offers an analytical lens for examining the discursive construction of a common enemy. As a Nazi jurist, Schmitt’s theorising of the distinction between friend and enemy provides a pseudo-legal justification for the regime’s biopolitical practices against Jewish people. Within an existential logic, the enemy is perceived as “the other, the stranger … existentially something different and alien” (Schmitt 27), whose existence is considered an ever-present threat to the survival of one’s own political community. This logic, I argue, is the essence of new far-right biopolitics that also operates on the presupposition of the “friend-enemy” distinction as a source of legitimisation. Rather than recreating the racial hierarchy, the contemporary far right mobilises the concept of political existentiality to transform demographic and cultural changes into an existential “crisis” for the white population. In new far-right biopolitics, group boundaries are often drawn via the conspiratorial “replacement” discourse, which frames immigrants and ethnic minorities as an invading force that constitutes a threat not just to national security but also to national identity (Bracke and Hernández Aguilar). Coupled with invocations of a sense of “white victimhood” (Sengul), constructing enemies through such affectively charged narrations tries to justify the preservation of ethnocultural identity as a matter of national survival. In relation to this, the discursive process of self-victimisation also involves the construction of internal enemies through “the people” versus “the elite” rhetoric. Using this populist frame, the national elite is represented as “internal traitors” who neglect the interests of “the people” while prioritising those of “Others” for their own political and economic gains (Kinnvall). Within far-right biopolitical imaginaries, there has been a coordinated effort between national and global elites to displace white “natives” with immigrants, while also undermining Western civilisation by advancing feminist and LGBTQIA+ agendas (Hernández Aguilar). By interpreting all sorts of social issues such as falling white birthrates, changing gender relations, and crime as a result of an alleged collusion between internal and external enemies, it tends to intensify the affective politics of victimhood whereby antagonistic actions towards “outgroups” may be justified on an existential basis (Sengul). The construction of biopolitical antagonisms between “us” and “them”, however, is not limited to the replacement discourse. In the far-right conspiratorial framing, population governance is also a mechanism through which the global elite can undermine national sovereignty, collective political agency, individual freedom, and bodily autonomy, as claimed in the “Great Reset” and “New World Order” conspiracy theories during the COVID-19 pandemic (Tuters and Willaert). From an anti-statist viewpoint, the existential threat in the context of crisis management is not simply a matter of biological or racial continuity, but more of an “authoritarian” control over public life. Seen in this light, such discursive construction serves to pit “the powerless people” against “the tyrannical state” in a perceived biopolitical struggle for the power to self-government on everyday affairs like hate speech laws, vaccination mandates, and climate policies (Davis, “Anti-Public Sphere”). Methodology Using purposive sampling with Facebook and YouTube’s built-in search functions, I extracted 19 of Pauline Hanson’s posts containing the keyword “Bondi” posted between 14 December 2025 and 31 January 2026 from her Facebook account Pauline Hanson’s Please Explain, along with 24 video titles and descriptions from News24’s YouTube channel, posted in 2020 and 2021, via a keyword search for “Great Reset”. To identify discursive patterns and strategies by which far-right ideas may be normalised and rendered more publicly acceptable, I conducted a content analysis of these two datasets on NVivo. The preliminary screening step involved running word-frequency queries (with stemmed words included) to generate the 50 most frequently used words in each dataset. The results were then visualised as word clouds. Subsequently, words and their lexical variants that refer to the national ingroup, outgroups, elites, threats, and conspiracy theories were chosen for a closer examination in their discursive contexts, using Text Search in NVivo. In the following section, archetypal narratives were extracted for further analysis. These two case studies capture both the political and media dimensions of an Overton window shift in Australia, as Pauline Hanson and News24 represent, respectively, a prom

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
M/C Journal
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.5204/mcj.3340
Primary Topic
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Shifting the Overton Window: The Existential Logic of Enemy Constructions in the New Biopolitics of the Far Right

Xinyi Zhang
M/C Journal
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
article

Shifting the Overton Window: The Existential Logic of Enemy Constructions in the New Biopolitics of the Far Right

Xinyi Zhang
article en

Abstract

Introduction The West has witnessed a shift in the Overton window towards more extreme rhetoric in recent years, with the ideological and discursive penetration of the far right in mainstream politics and media coverage. Such a shift, I argue, is driven in large part by an existential logic that underlies the normalisation of extreme ideas and discourses in contemporary far-right biopolitics. Given the far right’s conspiratorial worldview, the discursive strategy of normalisation often involves dual enemy constructions, in which the elite is cast as aligned with “an external foreign enemy” or “an internal ideological enemy” against the national ingroup (Kinnvall). As the construction of enemies often intersects with “exclusionary nationalism” (Carter) and populist appeals, I adopt “far right” as an umbrella term encompassing both the radical and extreme right (Pirro). While they share an exclusionary vision of the nation and an authoritarian attitude towards outgroups, their actual stances towards democracy are not always discernible, as the populist radical right political actors tend to hide their anti-democratic character to gain respectability and legitimacy. In the case of Australia, the COVID-19 pandemic provided an opportunity for the right-leaning news channel, News24 (formerly Sky News Australia), to produce and propagate conspiratorial content by exploiting public anger and fear over restrictive measures. More recently, the Bondi attack created a conducive political environment for far-right leader Pauline Hanson to justify her anti-Islam and anti-immigration agendas. Through a content analysis of Hanson’s Facebook posts following the 2025 Bondi attack and News24’s YouTube coverage of the “Great Reset” conspiracy narratives during the pandemic, I examine how they turn these events into an issue of existential struggle for the continued survival of the national community that is perceived as under threat from constructed enemies. Nazi Biopolitics versus New Far-Right Biopolitics Recalling Foucault, “biopolitics” functions as a politics of population management through the exercise of political biopower “to make live and to let die” in modern society (241). Historically, however, the term Biopolitik was mobilised by Nazi Germany to promote its eugenics program and racial policy (Liesen and Walsh). In this case, biopolitical measures implemented against Jews during the Holocaust represent the state use of extreme biopower for its genocidal agenda. As Foucault argues in Society Must Be Defended, racism is exercised in modern states to divide a population into groups deemed biologically desirable or undesirable, thereby legitimising the killing of the latter (254). While Nazi biopolitics is an extreme manifestation of modern racism, the contemporary far right has adapted this biopolitical logic to new concerns over borders and immigration, demographic change, and national identity. Rather than vanishing along with the Third Reich, the Nazi’s organic, exclusionary concepts of the Volk (people) and the Volkskörper (national body) have persisted in contemporary far-right politics (Rheindorf and Wodak). Under the guise of what French thinker Alain de Benoist calls “ethnopluralism” (Rueda), the far right could continue to draw boundaries around “the people” who constitute a culturally homogenous “national body” without always foregrounding race. In this way, new far-right biopolitics constructs a non-existent “white ethnostate” to normalise its exclusionary practices as necessary to cultural identity preservation, despite its underlying logic of biological racial differentiation. Far-right political actors can thus legitimise their calls for stricter border control and “remigration” as defensive measures against the so-called “Great Replacement” (Hernández Aguilar 81–2). This existential logic, when taken to its extreme by white supremacists such as Anders Breivik, Brenton Tarrant, and Patrick Crusius, served as a pretext for justifying their murderous violence as a form of self-defence for the wellbeing of the white population (Davis, “Violence as Method”). On the other hand, new far-right biopolitics goes beyond the issues of immigration, birth rates, and multiculturalism in its resistance to a perceived globalist biopower to govern public health and life. This form of resistance is particularly visible in the anti-lockdown and anti-vaccination movements during the COVID-19 pandemic. Notably through narratives of digital surveillance, technocratic governance, and globalist conspiracy, these public health measures were framed as a coordinated scheme of global elites for population control (Tuters and Willaert). In this case, far-right biopolitics is also a struggle over who governs life. Such discourse is generally anti-public, defined by its irrationality, antagonism, anti-elitism, anti-statism, anti-cosmopolitanism, and conspiratorial thinking (Davis, “Anti-Public Sphere”). Political Existentiality One important aspect, which lays the foundation for the normalisation of far-right biopolitical discourse, is collective identity construction. Following van de Wall, the concept of “political existentiality”, based on Carl Schmitt’s existentialist account of the political, offers an analytical lens for examining the discursive construction of a common enemy. As a Nazi jurist, Schmitt’s theorising of the distinction between friend and enemy provides a pseudo-legal justification for the regime’s biopolitical practices against Jewish people. Within an existential logic, the enemy is perceived as “the other, the stranger … existentially something different and alien” (Schmitt 27), whose existence is considered an ever-present threat to the survival of one’s own political community. This logic, I argue, is the essence of new far-right biopolitics that also operates on the presupposition of the “friend-enemy” distinction as a source of legitimisation. Rather than recreating the racial hierarchy, the contemporary far right mobilises the concept of political existentiality to transform demographic and cultural changes into an existential “crisis” for the white population. In new far-right biopolitics, group boundaries are often drawn via the conspiratorial “replacement” discourse, which frames immigrants and ethnic minorities as an invading force that constitutes a threat not just to national security but also to national identity (Bracke and Hernández Aguilar). Coupled with invocations of a sense of “white victimhood” (Sengul), constructing enemies through such affectively charged narrations tries to justify the preservation of ethnocultural identity as a matter of national survival. In relation to this, the discursive process of self-victimisation also involves the construction of internal enemies through “the people” versus “the elite” rhetoric. Using this populist frame, the national elite is represented as “internal traitors” who neglect the interests of “the people” while prioritising those of “Others” for their own political and economic gains (Kinnvall). Within far-right biopolitical imaginaries, there has been a coordinated effort between national and global elites to displace white “natives” with immigrants, while also undermining Western civilisation by advancing feminist and LGBTQIA+ agendas (Hernández Aguilar). By interpreting all sorts of social issues such as falling white birthrates, changing gender relations, and crime as a result of an alleged collusion between internal and external enemies, it tends to intensify the affective politics of victimhood whereby antagonistic actions towards “outgroups” may be justified on an existential basis (Sengul). The construction of biopolitical antagonisms between “us” and “them”, however, is not limited to the replacement discourse. In the far-right conspiratorial framing, population governance is also a mechanism through which the global elite can undermine national sovereignty, collective political agency, individual freedom, and bodily autonomy, as claimed in the “Great Reset” and “New World Order” conspiracy theories during the COVID-19 pandemic (Tuters and Willaert). From an anti-statist viewpoint, the existential threat in the context of crisis management is not simply a matter of biological or racial continuity, but more of an “authoritarian” control over public life. Seen in this light, such discursive construction serves to pit “the powerless people” against “the tyrannical state” in a perceived biopolitical struggle for the power to self-government on everyday affairs like hate speech laws, vaccination mandates, and climate policies (Davis, “Anti-Public Sphere”). Methodology Using purposive sampling with Facebook and YouTube’s built-in search functions, I extracted 19 of Pauline Hanson’s posts containing the keyword “Bondi” posted between 14 December 2025 and 31 January 2026 from her Facebook account Pauline Hanson’s Please Explain, along with 24 video titles and descriptions from News24’s YouTube channel, posted in 2020 and 2021, via a keyword search for “Great Reset”. To identify discursive patterns and strategies by which far-right ideas may be normalised and rendered more publicly acceptable, I conducted a content analysis of these two datasets on NVivo. The preliminary screening step involved running word-frequency queries (with stemmed words included) to generate the 50 most frequently used words in each dataset. The results were then visualised as word clouds. Subsequently, words and their lexical variants that refer to the national ingroup, outgroups, elites, threats, and conspiracy theories were chosen for a closer examination in their discursive contexts, using Text Search in NVivo. In the following section, archetypal narratives were extracted for further analysis. These two case studies capture both the political and media dimensions of an Overton window shift in Australia, as Pauline Hanson and News24 represent, respectively, a prom

M/C JournalVol. 29(6)
Jiangsu University of Science and Technology (CN)
Populism, Right-Wing Movements
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon