Качество экономического роста и условия его устойчивости в регионах Казахстана: сравнительная оценка

The growth rate of gross regional product does not show what drives growth, how widely its benefits are shared or under what conditions it can be maintained when external conditions change. The aim of this article is to assess the structural characteristics of growth quality and the conditions (preconditions) for growth sustainability in 20 territories of Kazakhstan within their current administrative boundaries using 2024 data, and to examine how far their positions depend on income levels and on methodological choices. The methodology is based on a composite index constructed in line with the OECD and European Commission Joint Research Centre handbook: 16 indicators from six blocks, drawn from the Bureau of National Statistics, were normalised by the min-max method and aggregated into a growth quality sub-index and a sub-index of growth sustainability conditions with equal weights; the robustness of the rankings was tested on 10,000 combinations of weights, normalisation and log-transformation choices. The index is cross-sectional: it describes the growth model in place by 2024 but measures neither growth dynamics nor the actual resilience of regional economies to shocks. Index values range from 50.8 points (Ulytau region) to 116.5 points (East Kazakhstan region). The ranking of territories is practically unrelated to income (Spearman coefficient 0.03): the quality sub-index is higher in richer territories and the sustainability-conditions sub-index in less affluent ones; the oil-producing regions with the highest income rank in the lower part of the index, which partly follows from the negative sign of the mining share in the index. Almaty city and East Kazakhstan region are robust leaders. The construction methods are standard; the novelty lies in building, for the 20 territories, an index that deliberately excludes income level and growth so that growth quality and sustainability conditions can be compared with income; in a rule that identifies leaders by two criteria – a weight-independent typology and the share of top-five placements across 10,000 recalculations; and in the empirical finding of a negative association between growth quality and sustainability conditions across Kazakhstan’s regions. The results can support comparative regional diagnostics and the choice of policy priorities for specific groups of territories. Keywords: quality of economic growth, conditions for growth sustainability, composite index, inclusive growth, regions of Kazakhstan.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.26577/be201111426
Primary Topic
Regional Economic Trends and Sectoral Structure
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Качество экономического роста и условия его устойчивости в регионах Казахстана: сравнительная оценка

Aziza Zhuparova, Aknur Yesmurzayeva, Venera Toktorova
The Journal of Economic Research & Business Administration
Regional Economic Trends and Sectoral Structure
article

Качество экономического роста и условия его устойчивости в регионах Казахстана: сравнительная оценка

Aziza Zhuparova, Aknur Yesmurzayeva, Venera Toktorova
article en

Abstract

The growth rate of gross regional product does not show what drives growth, how widely its benefits are shared or under what conditions it can be maintained when external conditions change. The aim of this article is to assess the structural characteristics of growth quality and the conditions (preconditions) for growth sustainability in 20 territories of Kazakhstan within their current administrative boundaries using 2024 data, and to examine how far their positions depend on income levels and on methodological choices. The methodology is based on a composite index constructed in line with the OECD and European Commission Joint Research Centre handbook: 16 indicators from six blocks, drawn from the Bureau of National Statistics, were normalised by the min-max method and aggregated into a growth quality sub-index and a sub-index of growth sustainability conditions with equal weights; the robustness of the rankings was tested on 10,000 combinations of weights, normalisation and log-transformation choices. The index is cross-sectional: it describes the growth model in place by 2024 but measures neither growth dynamics nor the actual resilience of regional economies to shocks. Index values range from 50.8 points (Ulytau region) to 116.5 points (East Kazakhstan region). The ranking of territories is practically unrelated to income (Spearman coefficient 0.03): the quality sub-index is higher in richer territories and the sustainability-conditions sub-index in less affluent ones; the oil-producing regions with the highest income rank in the lower part of the index, which partly follows from the negative sign of the mining share in the index. Almaty city and East Kazakhstan region are robust leaders. The construction methods are standard; the novelty lies in building, for the 20 territories, an index that deliberately excludes income level and growth so that growth quality and sustainability conditions can be compared with income; in a rule that identifies leaders by two criteria – a weight-independent typology and the share of top-five placements across 10,000 recalculations; and in the empirical finding of a negative association between growth quality and sustainability conditions across Kazakhstan’s regions. The results can support comparative regional diagnostics and the choice of policy priorities for specific groups of territories. Keywords: quality of economic growth, conditions for growth sustainability, composite index, inclusive growth, regions of Kazakhstan.

The Journal of Economic Research & Business AdministrationVol. 158(4)
Osh State University (KG), International Information Technologies University (KZ)
Regional Economic Trends and Sectoral Structure
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon