Muslim undergraduate biology students and their patterns of reconciliation, conflict, and negotiation between their religion and evolution in the United States

Background Evolution is a core concept of undergraduate biology education, but students’ perceived conflict with their religious beliefs can prevent them from incorporating evolution into their conceptual framework of biology. In the United States, research on Christian students’ views of evolution and religion has informed effective educational interventions, but limited data has been available to inform instruction for U.S. Muslim students. In this study, we analyzed and compared survey responses from both Muslims and Christians in introductory biology courses across 12 US states (n = 520). Using k-means cluster analysis, we identified common groupings of students based on their acceptance of evolution, perceived conflict with their religion, and views on creationism. Using qualitative content analysis of students’ open-ended responses, we further identified reasons why students perceive conflict or compatibility between religion and evolution. Results Muslims and Christians fell into three groups: (1) the “Reconciliation” group who adopted evolutionary creationist views and scored high on evolution acceptance and low on perceived conflict with their religion, (2) the “Conflicted” group, who adopted special creationist views and scored low on evolution acceptance and high on perceived conflict, and (3) the “Negotiation” group who also adopted special creationist views but scored average on acceptance and conflict. In some groups, Christian students scored higher on acceptance and conflict compared to Muslim students. Muslim students in the Reconciliation Group scored lower on human evolution acceptance, and Muslim students in the Conflicted Group more often chose Humans-only Creationism, a view that excludes humans from evolution. Students with compatibility views often saw religion and evolution as complementary rather than separate domains of knowledge, and students with conflict views tended to prioritize religious knowledge over scientific knowledge. Conclusion In our US sample of undergraduate biology students, Muslims and Christians showed similar patterns in their conceptions of evolution and religion. Further, rather than seeing evolution and religion as non-overlapping, students who perceived compatibility often saw these two domains of knowledge as working together. These results may inform current work on how to increase evolution acceptance and reduce perceived conflict between religion and evolution among Muslim undergraduate biology students in the United States.

Authors

Publication Details

Journal
Developmental Biology Advances
Published
2026-11-21
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1186/s13227-026-00278-6
Primary Topic
Evolution and Science Education
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Muslim undergraduate biology students and their patterns of reconciliation, conflict, and negotiation between their religion and evolution in the United States

Rahmi Qurota Aini, Sara E. Brownell, M. Elizabeth Barnes
Developmental Biology Advances
Evolution and Science Education
article

Muslim undergraduate biology students and their patterns of reconciliation, conflict, and negotiation between their religion and evolution in the United States

Rahmi Qurota Aini, Sara E. Brownell, M. Elizabeth Barnes
article en

Abstract

Background Evolution is a core concept of undergraduate biology education, but students’ perceived conflict with their religious beliefs can prevent them from incorporating evolution into their conceptual framework of biology. In the United States, research on Christian students’ views of evolution and religion has informed effective educational interventions, but limited data has been available to inform instruction for U.S. Muslim students. In this study, we analyzed and compared survey responses from both Muslims and Christians in introductory biology courses across 12 US states (n = 520). Using k-means cluster analysis, we identified common groupings of students based on their acceptance of evolution, perceived conflict with their religion, and views on creationism. Using qualitative content analysis of students’ open-ended responses, we further identified reasons why students perceive conflict or compatibility between religion and evolution. Results Muslims and Christians fell into three groups: (1) the “Reconciliation” group who adopted evolutionary creationist views and scored high on evolution acceptance and low on perceived conflict with their religion, (2) the “Conflicted” group, who adopted special creationist views and scored low on evolution acceptance and high on perceived conflict, and (3) the “Negotiation” group who also adopted special creationist views but scored average on acceptance and conflict. In some groups, Christian students scored higher on acceptance and conflict compared to Muslim students. Muslim students in the Reconciliation Group scored lower on human evolution acceptance, and Muslim students in the Conflicted Group more often chose Humans-only Creationism, a view that excludes humans from evolution. Students with compatibility views often saw religion and evolution as complementary rather than separate domains of knowledge, and students with conflict views tended to prioritize religious knowledge over scientific knowledge. Conclusion In our US sample of undergraduate biology students, Muslims and Christians showed similar patterns in their conceptions of evolution and religion. Further, rather than seeing evolution and religion as non-overlapping, students who perceived compatibility often saw these two domains of knowledge as working together. These results may inform current work on how to increase evolution acceptance and reduce perceived conflict between religion and evolution among Muslim undergraduate biology students in the United States.

Developmental Biology AdvancesVol. 17(1)
Evolution and Science Education
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon