Generativity Propagation and Subject Existence: Where Does the Subject Exist in Human–AI Cooperation?
A human encounter with a contingent question may initiate inquiry, uncertainty, intellectual commitment, and collaboration with artificial intelligence. The resulting knowledge artifact can remain real even when the labor of expression and organization is substantially automated. A further problem emerges when an AI-supported research process continues autonomously after its human participant withdraws: the initial encounter remains part of the process’s historical formation, while subsequent products may cease to reveal that history or require the participant’s continuing action. This philosophical essay investigates that divergence through a provisional generative–relational (GR) account of relational objects, relational subjects, and generativity propagation. It distinguishes historical occurrence, causal dependence, active participation, personal persistence, epistemic recognition, and normative attribution; proposes a constrained complex-based vocabulary for representing event histories; and uses a hypothetical autonomously self-modifying research system as a thought experiment. Relational distance is separated from causal strength, and institutional attribution is examined as a purpose-bound selection from richer histories under evidential and cognitive constraints. The analysis treats withdrawal from participation and loss of attribution as changes distinct from the historical occurrence of an earlier encounter. It also separates genealogical continuation from claims of persistent personal identity. The resulting account interprets “I never disappear” through the conditions of historical persistence and subject identification. It also considers implications for authorship, responsibility, archival practice, and human–AI knowledge production.
Authors
- Wanhong HUANG
Publication Details
- Journal
- Knowledge Commons Works (Michigan State University)
- Published
- 2026-11-21
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.17613/9pkp4-q7737
- Primary Topic
- Cybernetics and Technology in Society
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00