Hybrid Project Management in Heavy Civil Construction: A Layered Framework Integrating Predictive Governance, Lean Production Control, and Adaptive Coordination
Heavy civil construction projects present a structural tension that single approach project management cannot resolve. Their governance is predictive by necessity: fixed price or unit price contracts, regulatory approvals, safety requirements, and public accountability demand baselines, critical path schedules, and earned value control. Their production, however, is variable by nature: weather, subsurface conditions, utility conflicts, material supply, and multi trade interdependence routinely invalidate weekly plans. This conceptual paper addresses the question of how predictive, lean, and adaptive practices should be allocated within the same heavy civil project, rather than whether one approach should replace the others. Drawing on the theory of production in construction, the Last Planner System, and the empirical literature on agile and hybrid project management, the paper proposes a Layered Hybrid Framework composed of three layers: a predictive governance layer, a lean production control layer, and an adaptive coordination layer. For each layer, the framework specifies purpose, core practices, cadence, and metrics, and it provides decision rules for allocating practices according to uncertainty, reversibility, and contractual constraint. Five testable propositions are derived. The paper contributes a construction specific specification of hybrid project management that respects contractual governance while treating plan reliability, measured by Percent Plan Complete and reasons for variance, as a primary control variable. A research design for empirical evaluation is proposed.
Authors
- Jefferson M. Rojas Castro (ORCID: https://orcid.org/0009-0001-5179-6454)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Zenodo (CERN European Organization for Nuclear Research)
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24406364
- Primary Topic
- Construction Project Management and Performance
- Type
- preprint