One-to-One Support Requests for People Living in Care Homes: Why, When, and for Whom?

Context: Care home managers (CHMs) may request additional funding to enable them to provide one-to-one care and support in order adequately to meet an individual’s needs or to keep them, or others, safe. This can present a significant cost for local authorities (LAs) as well as concern about the impact of such surveillance on individuals. Objectives: This study sought to better understand the reasons for one-to-one support requests from CHMs for residents aged 65 and over, and the experiences of LA staff who deal with such requests. Methods: CHMs and LA staff were invited to participate in an interview about their experiences of one-to-one support requests. The qualitative data were analysed using template analysis. Findings: We recruited 22 CHMs and eight LA staff across three LA areas. Seventeen homes supported older people, 5 supported people with learning disabilities, and 4 supported people with mental health issues, autism and/or learning disabilities. Interviews focused only on residents aged 65 and older. Requests for one-to-one care varied from time-limited to longer-term requests. Some requests were limited to a certain number of hours, whilst others sought additional resources for 24-hour care. There was evidence of differing attitudes between CHMs and LA staff as to the appropriateness of requests for one-to-one support. Key reasons for requesting one-to-one support included resident safety, self-harming behaviour and physical and cognitive health needs. It was also requested to support people to settle into a care home, to manage behaviour that challenges, and enable people to go outside of the home. Some respondents saw one-to-one support as a restrictive practice in some circumstances, considering it only appropriate when all other options were exhausted. People living in care homes often have complex needs requiring time-limited support for them to settle in a home. For CHMs, safety is the overarching reason for requests for one-to-one support. Limitations: The self-selection of CHMs into the study may have resulted in a systematic bias in their reasons for participating. Implications: Staffing levels impact on the ability of care homes to provide support for the specific needs of individual residents. Further research to understand the impact of receiving one-to-one support from the perspective of residents would be beneficial.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Long-Term Care
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.31389/jltc.636
Primary Topic
Geriatric Care and Nursing Homes
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00

Funders

Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

One-to-One Support Requests for People Living in Care Homes: Why, When, and for Whom?

Karen Gray, Geraldine M. Macdonald, Lisa Dibsdall, Christie Cabral et al.
Journal of Long-Term Care
Geriatric Care and Nursing Homes
article

One-to-One Support Requests for People Living in Care Homes: Why, When, and for Whom?

Karen Gray, Geraldine M. Macdonald, Lisa Dibsdall, Christie Cabral, Edmund Brooks, Kate Harris, Jill Boreham
article en

Abstract

Context: Care home managers (CHMs) may request additional funding to enable them to provide one-to-one care and support in order adequately to meet an individual’s needs or to keep them, or others, safe. This can present a significant cost for local authorities (LAs) as well as concern about the impact of such surveillance on individuals. Objectives: This study sought to better understand the reasons for one-to-one support requests from CHMs for residents aged 65 and over, and the experiences of LA staff who deal with such requests. Methods: CHMs and LA staff were invited to participate in an interview about their experiences of one-to-one support requests. The qualitative data were analysed using template analysis. Findings: We recruited 22 CHMs and eight LA staff across three LA areas. Seventeen homes supported older people, 5 supported people with learning disabilities, and 4 supported people with mental health issues, autism and/or learning disabilities. Interviews focused only on residents aged 65 and older. Requests for one-to-one care varied from time-limited to longer-term requests. Some requests were limited to a certain number of hours, whilst others sought additional resources for 24-hour care. There was evidence of differing attitudes between CHMs and LA staff as to the appropriateness of requests for one-to-one support. Key reasons for requesting one-to-one support included resident safety, self-harming behaviour and physical and cognitive health needs. It was also requested to support people to settle into a care home, to manage behaviour that challenges, and enable people to go outside of the home. Some respondents saw one-to-one support as a restrictive practice in some circumstances, considering it only appropriate when all other options were exhausted. People living in care homes often have complex needs requiring time-limited support for them to settle in a home. For CHMs, safety is the overarching reason for requests for one-to-one support. Limitations: The self-selection of CHMs into the study may have resulted in a systematic bias in their reasons for participating. Implications: Staffing levels impact on the ability of care homes to provide support for the specific needs of individual residents. Further research to understand the impact of receiving one-to-one support from the perspective of residents would be beneficial.

Journal of Long-Term Care
Wiltshire Council (GB), Bristol City Council (GB), University of Bristol (GB)
National Institute for Health and Care Research, Department of Health and Social Care, Health and Social Care Delivery Research
Good health and well-being
Geriatric Care and Nursing Homes
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon