Ocular imaging changes in astronauts and ground-based analogues: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Background. Spaceflight-associated neuro-ocular syndrome (SANS) affects a substantial proportion of astronauts on long-duration missions, and head-down tilt bed rest (HDTBR) is the principal ground-based analogue used to study and counter it; whether HDTBR faithfully reproduces the ocular phenotype of microgravity, however, remains uncertain. Methods. We systematically searched MEDLINE/PubMed, Embase, Scopus and Web of Science from inception to October 2026, with no language restriction, together with the NASA Technical Reports Server and trial registries, and included longitudinal cohorts of astronauts and of healthy adults in HDTBR or dry immersion with extractable quantitative ocular outcome data. Changes from baseline were pooled separately for spaceflight and analogue cohorts using random-effects models with REML estimation of τ² and Hartung-Knapp adjustment, and stratum-specific estimates were compared with a Wald-type test; a generalised linear mixed model was fitted as a sensitivity analysis for the binary outcome. The review was registered on PROSPERO (CRD420261540269). Results. Across ten pooled ocular and intracranial-imaging outcomes (six with dual-stratum comparison), peripapillary retinal thickness (flight + 29.0 µm vs analogue + 32.3 µm; P = 0.74), retinal nerve fibre layer change (1.7 vs 6.8 µm; P = 0.30) and intraocular pressure (-0.23 vs -0.04 mmHg; P = 0.95) showed no statistically significant between-stratum difference; a formal equivalence test (two one-sided tests) did not establish equivalence for retinal thickness (P = 0.272). The between-stratum comparison for optic disc oedema incidence (43.5% vs 49.9%; P = 0.86) was underpowered (stratum 95% CIs 1.5% to 93.7% and 27.0% to 72.9%) and is reported as exploratory. One outcome diverged: choroidal thickness increased after spaceflight (pooled + 26.6 µm [95% CI 10.9, 42.3]) but decreased during 60 days of strict HDTBR (-13.6 µm [-25.5, -1.7]; between-stratum difference + 40.2 µm, P < 0.001). This contrast - the review’s central novel signal - rests on an analogue estimate from a single cohort (n = 8) without formal certainty rating and is therefore hypothesis-generating rather than confirmatory, but it identifies choroidal thickness as the lead candidate discriminator of analogue fidelity). Optic nerve sheath length (+ 0.69 mm) and ventricular volume (+ 10.3% [95% CI 7.8, 12.8]) increased after flight. Conclusions. This review was designed to detect divergence between actual spaceflight and its terrestrial analogue. Across the fluid-stasis markers of SANS - disc oedema (exploratory comparison), peripapillary retinal thickening and axial shortening - no divergence was detected, although with two to four studies per outcome this cannot establish analogue fidelity. The one outcome whose direction diverged was choroidal thickness (increased after spaceflight, decreased during bed rest; analogue estimate from a single cohort (n = 8) without formal certainty rating), a contrast that is hypothesis-generating rather than confirmatory. We hypothesise, post hoc, that loss of the hydrostatic gradient in microgravity causes passive choroidal venous congestion that headward fluid shift alone cannot replicate, and propose that choroidal thickness, measurable by routine optical coherence tomography, is the lead candidate discriminator of analogue fidelity - hypothesis-generating rather than confirmatory, pending confirmation in larger analogue cohorts.
Authors
- Junhui Zhao
- Zishu Zhao
Institutions
- Huazhong University of Science and Technology (CN)
- Zhejiang University (CN)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Research Square
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.21203/rs.3.rs-11511140/v1
- Primary Topic
- Spaceflight effects on biology
- Type
- preprint