Engineering validation of analytical predictions for strength of equal and unequal legged reinforced concrete L-columns

Structural engineering frameworks frequently demand reinforced concrete (RC) columns capable of resisting complex coupled axial compression and uniaxial flexure. While standard design aids (such as IS 456 and SP 16) provide ultimate load-moment interaction diagrams for symmetric cross-sections, a distinct research gap exists regarding asymmetric, special-shaped L-columns. This study addresses this research gap by developing a simplified, strain-compatibility-based analytical framework to generate non-dimensional design interaction charts for short RC L-columns. These charts are strictly bounded to the specific geometric leg-length ratios, thickness ratios, and reinforcement topologies investigated herein, featuring both equal (450 mm × 450 mm × 210 mm with 12 bars) and unequal (450 mm × 330 mm × 210 mm with 10 bars) leg geometries under varying cross-sectional orientations. The analytical model was evaluated experimentally by subjecting full-scale structural specimens (1.36 m in height) cast with M20 grade concrete (mean 28-day compressive strength of 27.85 MPa) and longitudinal Fe-500 rebar arrays (12 bars of 12 mm diameter for equal-legged; 10 bars of 12 mm diameter for unequal-legged profiles) to eccentric loading within a 200-t loading frame. Investigational results revealed that orienting equal-legged columns with the flange as the highly compressed edge (ELP-1) achieved a balanced moment capacity (Mu) of 117.04 kN-m at an axial load (Pu) of 524.49 kN (neutral axis depth xu = 0.37D), compared to Mu = 102.62 kN-m at Pu = 203.40 kN (xu = 0.50D) for the web-compressed orientation (ELP-2). For unequal legs, orientation UELP-4 yielded a balanced moment capacity of 102.36 kN-m (Pu = 527.62 kN), approximately 92% higher than the corresponding balanced moment capacity of UELP-1 (Mu = 53.35 kN-m, Pu = 414.93 kN), with the comparison made at their respective axial loads; this difference may partly reflect the greater geometric depth along the bending axis. ​ The proposed limit-state analytical framework was compared with empirical results, showing positive experimental-to-analytical differences of approximately 5% to 27% in four of the eight reported L-column comparisons, while the remaining four showed negative differences, discussed with reference to possible local bearing failure. These non-dimensional charts provide a computationally efficient, limit-state-based design aid for optimizing specific asymmetric vertical structural elements in building infrastructure.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Scientific Reports
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-026-80173-1
Primary Topic
Structural Behavior of Reinforced Concrete
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Engineering validation of analytical predictions for strength of equal and unequal legged reinforced concrete L-columns

Shanmukha Shetty, Thushar S. Shetty, Shriram Marathe, Subrahmanya R. M
Scientific Reports
Structural Behavior of Reinforced Concrete
article

Engineering validation of analytical predictions for strength of equal and unequal legged reinforced concrete L-columns

Shanmukha Shetty, Thushar S. Shetty, Shriram Marathe, Subrahmanya R. M
article en

Abstract

Structural engineering frameworks frequently demand reinforced concrete (RC) columns capable of resisting complex coupled axial compression and uniaxial flexure. While standard design aids (such as IS 456 and SP 16) provide ultimate load-moment interaction diagrams for symmetric cross-sections, a distinct research gap exists regarding asymmetric, special-shaped L-columns. This study addresses this research gap by developing a simplified, strain-compatibility-based analytical framework to generate non-dimensional design interaction charts for short RC L-columns. These charts are strictly bounded to the specific geometric leg-length ratios, thickness ratios, and reinforcement topologies investigated herein, featuring both equal (450 mm × 450 mm × 210 mm with 12 bars) and unequal (450 mm × 330 mm × 210 mm with 10 bars) leg geometries under varying cross-sectional orientations. The analytical model was evaluated experimentally by subjecting full-scale structural specimens (1.36 m in height) cast with M20 grade concrete (mean 28-day compressive strength of 27.85 MPa) and longitudinal Fe-500 rebar arrays (12 bars of 12 mm diameter for equal-legged; 10 bars of 12 mm diameter for unequal-legged profiles) to eccentric loading within a 200-t loading frame. Investigational results revealed that orienting equal-legged columns with the flange as the highly compressed edge (ELP-1) achieved a balanced moment capacity (Mu) of 117.04 kN-m at an axial load (Pu) of 524.49 kN (neutral axis depth xu = 0.37D), compared to Mu = 102.62 kN-m at Pu = 203.40 kN (xu = 0.50D) for the web-compressed orientation (ELP-2). For unequal legs, orientation UELP-4 yielded a balanced moment capacity of 102.36 kN-m (Pu = 527.62 kN), approximately 92% higher than the corresponding balanced moment capacity of UELP-1 (Mu = 53.35 kN-m, Pu = 414.93 kN), with the comparison made at their respective axial loads; this difference may partly reflect the greater geometric depth along the bending axis. ​ The proposed limit-state analytical framework was compared with empirical results, showing positive experimental-to-analytical differences of approximately 5% to 27% in four of the eight reported L-column comparisons, while the remaining four showed negative differences, discussed with reference to possible local bearing failure. These non-dimensional charts provide a computationally efficient, limit-state-based design aid for optimizing specific asymmetric vertical structural elements in building infrastructure.

Scientific Reports
Nitte University (IN)
Structural Behavior of Reinforced Concrete
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon