Reconstructing Public Participation Mechanisms for Sustainable Grassroots Governance: A Q-Methodological Analysis from Formal Participation to Substantive Co-Governance

Public participation is the core of grassroots governance modernisation and a key vehicle of whole-process people’s democracy. Yet participation in Chinese urban and rural communities remains trapped in a formalisation dilemma, characterised by passive mobilisation, symbolic voting, fragmented voice and weak feedback. Prior research has explained this dilemma mainly through objective deficits in institutions, channels and technology, while neglecting the subjective cognitive differentiation among stakeholders. Methods: Drawing on whole-process people’s democracy and collaborative governance theory, this study applies Q methodology. Thirty-eight purposively sampled stakeholders across five groups (street-level cadres, community workers, residents, social organisation representatives and volunteers) completed a forced-normal Q sort of 45 statements, followed by 75–100 min semi-structured interviews. Principal component analysis with Varimax rotation extracted five factors. Results: Five distinct cognitive paradigms emerged—institution-dependent, interest-driven, public welfare volunteer, ability-constrained and critical reflective—explaining 76.5% of total variance. The five factors represent shared patterns of subjective perspectives rather than mutually exclusive citizen types; they are interpreted through factor score arrays and distinguishing statements rather than through direct causal testing. Respondents reached strong consensus on the necessity, channel diversification, effectiveness and government responsibility of participation, but diverged sharply on the role split between government and residents, the core driver of participation, the validity of existing institutions, the value of digital channels and the responsibility for building participation capacity. Conclusions: Cognitive divergence is associated with, and helps explain, the persistence of formalisation alongside institutional supply. We propose a four-dimensional reconstruction framework of classified adaptation, benefit linkage, capacity enablement and institutional safeguard, delivered through an empowerment–capacity building–evaluation three-ring mechanism in three time phases, supporting SDG 16 (accountable and inclusive institutions) and SDG 11 (inclusive, safe and resilient human settlements). The study identifies subjective viewpoint patterns among a purposive sample; it does not observe actual participation behaviour or measure governance outcomes, and the proposed participation mechanisms have not been assessed through implementation or evaluation data.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Sustainability
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.3390/su182211830
Primary Topic
Public Policy and Administration Research
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Reconstructing Public Participation Mechanisms for Sustainable Grassroots Governance: A Q-Methodological Analysis from Formal Participation to Substantive Co-Governance

Bangfan Liu, 杨龙波, Hui Wang, Rong Zhang et al.
2 links
Sustainability
Public Policy and Administration Research
article

Reconstructing Public Participation Mechanisms for Sustainable Grassroots Governance: A Q-Methodological Analysis from Formal Participation to Substantive Co-Governance

Bangfan Liu, 杨龙波, Hui Wang, Rong Zhang, Yifan Jiang, Zhiyong Wu, Lichen Zhang, Yingyihao Shao, Yunling Gao
article en

Abstract

Public participation is the core of grassroots governance modernisation and a key vehicle of whole-process people’s democracy. Yet participation in Chinese urban and rural communities remains trapped in a formalisation dilemma, characterised by passive mobilisation, symbolic voting, fragmented voice and weak feedback. Prior research has explained this dilemma mainly through objective deficits in institutions, channels and technology, while neglecting the subjective cognitive differentiation among stakeholders. Methods: Drawing on whole-process people’s democracy and collaborative governance theory, this study applies Q methodology. Thirty-eight purposively sampled stakeholders across five groups (street-level cadres, community workers, residents, social organisation representatives and volunteers) completed a forced-normal Q sort of 45 statements, followed by 75–100 min semi-structured interviews. Principal component analysis with Varimax rotation extracted five factors. Results: Five distinct cognitive paradigms emerged—institution-dependent, interest-driven, public welfare volunteer, ability-constrained and critical reflective—explaining 76.5% of total variance. The five factors represent shared patterns of subjective perspectives rather than mutually exclusive citizen types; they are interpreted through factor score arrays and distinguishing statements rather than through direct causal testing. Respondents reached strong consensus on the necessity, channel diversification, effectiveness and government responsibility of participation, but diverged sharply on the role split between government and residents, the core driver of participation, the validity of existing institutions, the value of digital channels and the responsibility for building participation capacity. Conclusions: Cognitive divergence is associated with, and helps explain, the persistence of formalisation alongside institutional supply. We propose a four-dimensional reconstruction framework of classified adaptation, benefit linkage, capacity enablement and institutional safeguard, delivered through an empowerment–capacity building–evaluation three-ring mechanism in three time phases, supporting SDG 16 (accountable and inclusive institutions) and SDG 11 (inclusive, safe and resilient human settlements). The study identifies subjective viewpoint patterns among a purposive sample; it does not observe actual participation behaviour or measure governance outcomes, and the proposed participation mechanisms have not been assessed through implementation or evaluation data.

SustainabilityVol. 18(22)
Yanshan University (CN)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Sustainable cities and communities
Public Policy and Administration Research
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon