Instructional equivalence and differential affordances of peer tutoring and AI-assisted learning in IUPAC nomenclature: an explanatory sequential mixed-methods study
IUPAC nomenclature in Organic Chemistry remains a challenging procedural domain requiring precision and rule-based reasoning. While peer tutoring and artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted tools have been introduced to support learning, empirical evidence with the comparison of learning functions with traditional instruction remains limited. This study examined both the instructional equivalence and functional roles of a blended intervention integrating peer tutoring, ChatGPT, and OrgoSolver. An explanatory sequential mixed-methods design was employed involving 27 undergraduate students assigned to control ( n = 14) and experimental ( n = 13) groups. A 30-item validated test was administered as pretest and posttest. Quantitative results showed that both groups improved significantly ( p < .001), with the experimental group demonstrating a larger numerical gain ( d = 1.38) than the control group ( d = 1.17). Although the experimental group obtained higher posttest scores, ANCOVA indicated no statistically significant difference. Given the small sample size, the quantitative findings should be interpreted as preliminary and exploratory. Qualitative findings revealed four complementary affordances of the blended intervention: (1) cognitive affordances through conceptual understanding and cognitive triangulation, (2) social affordances fostered by peer tutoring, (3) technological affordances through the complementary roles of ChatGPT for conceptual explanations and OrgoSolver for procedural verification, and (4) the development of critical AI literacy as students learned to verify and evaluate AI-generated responses rather than rely on them uncritically. The findings suggest that the educational value of the intervention lies in the complementary interaction of human and AI-supported learning resources, highlighting the importance of verification, collaborative reasoning, and responsible AI use in chemistry education. Implications highlight the importance of structured integration and critical evaluation when incorporating AI tools in chemistry education.
Authors
- Jessa Banzon-Manulat
Institutions
- Cebu Technological University (PH)
Publication Details
- Journal
- Frontiers in Education
- Published
- 2026-11-20
- DOI
- https://doi.org/10.3389/feduc.2026.1873775
- Primary Topic
- Intelligent Tutoring Systems and Adaptive Learning
- Type
- article
- Field-Weighted Citation Impact
- 0.00