Peer Instruction in Hybrid Computing Courses: The Relationships Between Student Modality, Discussion, and Learning

Background: Peer instruction is an active learning pedagogy that emphasizes collaboration and learning from one’s peers. Prior research in computing education has shown that using peer instruction can improve students’ learning, reduce dropout and failure rates, and result in larger increases in students’ self-efficacy relative to standard lecture-based instruction. However, it has not investigated the use of peer instruction in hybrid courses, which have become increasingly popular in higher education due to their flexibility and ability to manage increases in enrollment. Objectives: We evaluated the effectiveness of peer instruction at facilitating students’ learning of computing concepts in in-person and online modalities of a hybrid course. Additionally, we examined how students’ discussions between rounds of peer instruction relate to their learning of computing concepts and whether these relationships vary when courses follow different attendance policies. Context and Methods: We analyzed students’ normalized learning gains from peer instruction in two offerings of a hybrid undergraduate data science course where students could choose to attend class meetings in person or synchronously online. In the first (open-policy) offering, students could self-select their modality for each class meeting and alternate modalities at will. In the second (closed-policy) offering, students needed to obtain instructor permission each time they wanted to attend class online, which drastically reduced the proportion of students who did so. Findings: Students who attended class online in the open-policy offering experienced smaller normalized learning gains than students who attended class in person in either offering. Additionally, in the open-policy offering, students who discussed the peer instruction questions in person experienced higher normalized learning gains than students who engaged in discussion online. Lastly, students who engaged in in-person discussion in the open-policy offering experienced higher normalized learning gains than students who did so in the closed-policy offering. Implications: Our results suggest that peer instruction may be more effective in person as opposed to online, particularly if there are differences in discussion environments across modalities. Additionally, they provide insight into how students’ discussion behaviors are related to their modalities. We encourage other instructors to take them into consideration when designing and implementing peer instruction in a hybrid computing course.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
ACM Transactions on Computing Education
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1145/3864438
Primary Topic
Innovative Teaching Methods
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Peer Instruction in Hybrid Computing Courses: The Relationships Between Student Modality, Discussion, and Learning

Shao-Heng Ko, Janet Jiang, K Stephens
ACM Transactions on Computing Education
Innovative Teaching Methods
article

Peer Instruction in Hybrid Computing Courses: The Relationships Between Student Modality, Discussion, and Learning

Shao-Heng Ko, Janet Jiang, K Stephens
article en

Abstract

Background: Peer instruction is an active learning pedagogy that emphasizes collaboration and learning from one’s peers. Prior research in computing education has shown that using peer instruction can improve students’ learning, reduce dropout and failure rates, and result in larger increases in students’ self-efficacy relative to standard lecture-based instruction. However, it has not investigated the use of peer instruction in hybrid courses, which have become increasingly popular in higher education due to their flexibility and ability to manage increases in enrollment. Objectives: We evaluated the effectiveness of peer instruction at facilitating students’ learning of computing concepts in in-person and online modalities of a hybrid course. Additionally, we examined how students’ discussions between rounds of peer instruction relate to their learning of computing concepts and whether these relationships vary when courses follow different attendance policies. Context and Methods: We analyzed students’ normalized learning gains from peer instruction in two offerings of a hybrid undergraduate data science course where students could choose to attend class meetings in person or synchronously online. In the first (open-policy) offering, students could self-select their modality for each class meeting and alternate modalities at will. In the second (closed-policy) offering, students needed to obtain instructor permission each time they wanted to attend class online, which drastically reduced the proportion of students who did so. Findings: Students who attended class online in the open-policy offering experienced smaller normalized learning gains than students who attended class in person in either offering. Additionally, in the open-policy offering, students who discussed the peer instruction questions in person experienced higher normalized learning gains than students who engaged in discussion online. Lastly, students who engaged in in-person discussion in the open-policy offering experienced higher normalized learning gains than students who did so in the closed-policy offering. Implications: Our results suggest that peer instruction may be more effective in person as opposed to online, particularly if there are differences in discussion environments across modalities. Additionally, they provide insight into how students’ discussion behaviors are related to their modalities. We encourage other instructors to take them into consideration when designing and implementing peer instruction in a hybrid computing course.

ACM Transactions on Computing Education
Duke University (US), Vanderbilt University (US), University of Washington (US)
Quality education
Innovative Teaching Methods
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon