Review of Manon Garcia’s Living with Men: Reflections on the Pelicot Trial

In 2024, one of the most widely publicized trials centering on sexual violence was held in France. 1 The widespread media attention that it received was made possible by the decision of Gisèle Pelicot to waive her right, as a victim of sexual assault, to anonymity, and to allow the trial to be public.Although Dominique Pelicot, Gisèle's husband, had confessed to the crimes he was charged with during the investigation and the trial, including drugging his wife over a 10-year period so that he could invite dozens of other men to rape her while she was unconscious and then rape her himself, the other defendants claimed various degrees of innocence or mitigated responsibility.The twoweek trial detailed the horrific details of the committed crimes: the videos of the rapes, the meticulous records that Dominique kept of the abuse, and the pathetic attempts of the accused to claim that they had assumed Gisèle's consent.Manon Garcia showed up at the courthouse daily, occasionally gaining access to the actual courtroom, but more often being relegated to the overflow rooms (sometimes to ones predominantly occupied by defendants and/or their families), where she watched the proceedings on a video screen.Loosely chronologically ordered, the themed, often quite brief essays making up this volume chronicle Garcia's thoughts on different facets of the trial-the use of video, the daily presence of a trio of impeccably attired retired women, the persistent subtext of incest, the oft-described ordinariness of the defendants, and many others-in an appropriately unwieldy attempt to excavate the trial's meanings for contemporary heterosexuality, and particularly, for contemporary heterosexual women.I emphasize the centrality of heterosexuality here, for it is clear that Garcia knowingly positions dominant forms of heterosexuality as the site of her most pressing philosophical questions, but not because she takes heterosexuality to be the default form of sexual identity.For Garcia, the challenge that heterosexual women face-how to live with men-is a political problem generated by contingent social factors, and her focus on

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Hypatia
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1017/hyp.2026.10119
Primary Topic
Gender and Feminist Studies
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Review of Manon Garcia’s Living with Men: Reflections on the Pelicot Trial

Ann J. Cahill
3 links
Hypatia
Gender and Feminist Studies
article

Review of Manon Garcia’s Living with Men: Reflections on the Pelicot Trial

Ann J. Cahill
article en

Abstract

In 2024, one of the most widely publicized trials centering on sexual violence was held in France. 1 The widespread media attention that it received was made possible by the decision of Gisèle Pelicot to waive her right, as a victim of sexual assault, to anonymity, and to allow the trial to be public.Although Dominique Pelicot, Gisèle's husband, had confessed to the crimes he was charged with during the investigation and the trial, including drugging his wife over a 10-year period so that he could invite dozens of other men to rape her while she was unconscious and then rape her himself, the other defendants claimed various degrees of innocence or mitigated responsibility.The twoweek trial detailed the horrific details of the committed crimes: the videos of the rapes, the meticulous records that Dominique kept of the abuse, and the pathetic attempts of the accused to claim that they had assumed Gisèle's consent.Manon Garcia showed up at the courthouse daily, occasionally gaining access to the actual courtroom, but more often being relegated to the overflow rooms (sometimes to ones predominantly occupied by defendants and/or their families), where she watched the proceedings on a video screen.Loosely chronologically ordered, the themed, often quite brief essays making up this volume chronicle Garcia's thoughts on different facets of the trial-the use of video, the daily presence of a trio of impeccably attired retired women, the persistent subtext of incest, the oft-described ordinariness of the defendants, and many others-in an appropriately unwieldy attempt to excavate the trial's meanings for contemporary heterosexuality, and particularly, for contemporary heterosexual women.I emphasize the centrality of heterosexuality here, for it is clear that Garcia knowingly positions dominant forms of heterosexuality as the site of her most pressing philosophical questions, but not because she takes heterosexuality to be the default form of sexual identity.For Garcia, the challenge that heterosexual women face-how to live with men-is a political problem generated by contingent social factors, and her focus on

Hypatia
Elon University (US)
Peace, justice, and strong institutions, Gender equality
Gender and Feminist Studies
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon
Review of Manon Garcia’s Living with Men: Reflections on the Pelicot Trial — Ann J. Cahill · Hypatia (2026) | TGRS Research Map | TGRS