Climate Dependence of the Cooling Energy, Circadian Lighting Trade-off in Dynamically Controlled Hospital Glazing and Shading: A Three-Climate Study

Dynamic control of window visible transmittance (VT) and shading can simultaneously manage cooling energy demand and circadian effective daylight (Equivalent Melanopic Lux, EML), but whether the resulting trade-off is climate invariant remains untested. This study applies an hourly, EnergyPlus and MATLAB weighted multi-objective control framework to minimize a performance index over visible transmittance and shading projection depth, identically for three climatically distinct hospital sites: Jeddah (hot arid, cooling dominated), Athens (Mediterranean, mixed load), and Seattle (marine, heating leaning). Varying the cooling energy weight WCE throughout its full range (0 to 1) reveals a strongly non-linear trade-off in all three climates, in which circadian performance remains near its limit while nearly all achievable cooling energy savings are obtained, collapsing only when illuminance is given zero weight. The magnitude of achievable cooling energy reduction before this collapse scales inversely with cooling dominance, 5% in Jeddah, 17% in Athens, and 55% in Seattle in relative terms, and only Jeddah shows interior curvature, indicating that a continuously tunable trade-off exists only where cooling load is substantial, while Athens and Seattle behave in a near binary manner. Measured against a static reference, none of the 40 fixed VT and shading configurations reaches the combination of cooling energy and EML delivered by the dynamic control in any of the three climates. Annual control deployment mirrors the same gradient, with an annual mean shading projection of 0.67 m in Jeddah, 0.56 m in Athens, and 0.25 m in Seattle, and in every climate the controller withdraws shading during daylit hours and deploys it when daylight is unavailable. A glare weighted variant of the objective produces the most climate independent result, since prioritizing glare control above a weight of approximately 0.5 to 0.6 collapses mean EML below the WELL Building Standard threshold of 200 EML in all three climates. These findings indicate that the energy circadian trade-off previously identified in hot arid climates is not a general property of dynamic envelope control but is itself climate dependent in both magnitude and shape, with direct implications for how such control strategies should be tuned and implemented in different locations.

Authors

Institutions

Publication Details

Journal
Journal of Daylighting
Published
2026-11-20
DOI
https://doi.org/10.15627/jd.2026.42
Primary Topic
Building Energy and Comfort Optimization
Type
article
Field-Weighted Citation Impact
0.00
Controls
|||
ALL TIME
JAN
FEB
MAR
APR
MAY
JUN
JUL
AUG
SEP
OCT
NOV
article

Climate Dependence of the Cooling Energy, Circadian Lighting Trade-off in Dynamically Controlled Hospital Glazing and Shading: A Three-Climate Study

Alaa Alaidroos, Diana Mardenli
Journal of Daylighting
Building Energy and Comfort Optimization
article

Climate Dependence of the Cooling Energy, Circadian Lighting Trade-off in Dynamically Controlled Hospital Glazing and Shading: A Three-Climate Study

Alaa Alaidroos, Diana Mardenli
article en

Abstract

Dynamic control of window visible transmittance (VT) and shading can simultaneously manage cooling energy demand and circadian effective daylight (Equivalent Melanopic Lux, EML), but whether the resulting trade-off is climate invariant remains untested. This study applies an hourly, EnergyPlus and MATLAB weighted multi-objective control framework to minimize a performance index over visible transmittance and shading projection depth, identically for three climatically distinct hospital sites: Jeddah (hot arid, cooling dominated), Athens (Mediterranean, mixed load), and Seattle (marine, heating leaning). Varying the cooling energy weight WCE throughout its full range (0 to 1) reveals a strongly non-linear trade-off in all three climates, in which circadian performance remains near its limit while nearly all achievable cooling energy savings are obtained, collapsing only when illuminance is given zero weight. The magnitude of achievable cooling energy reduction before this collapse scales inversely with cooling dominance, 5% in Jeddah, 17% in Athens, and 55% in Seattle in relative terms, and only Jeddah shows interior curvature, indicating that a continuously tunable trade-off exists only where cooling load is substantial, while Athens and Seattle behave in a near binary manner. Measured against a static reference, none of the 40 fixed VT and shading configurations reaches the combination of cooling energy and EML delivered by the dynamic control in any of the three climates. Annual control deployment mirrors the same gradient, with an annual mean shading projection of 0.67 m in Jeddah, 0.56 m in Athens, and 0.25 m in Seattle, and in every climate the controller withdraws shading during daylit hours and deploys it when daylight is unavailable. A glare weighted variant of the objective produces the most climate independent result, since prioritizing glare control above a weight of approximately 0.5 to 0.6 collapses mean EML below the WELL Building Standard threshold of 200 EML in all three climates. These findings indicate that the energy circadian trade-off previously identified in hot arid climates is not a general property of dynamic envelope control but is itself climate dependent in both magnitude and shape, with direct implications for how such control strategies should be tuned and implemented in different locations.

Journal of DaylightingVol. 13(2)
King Abdulaziz University (SA), Dar Al-Hekma University (SA)
Affordable and clean energy, Climate action
Building Energy and Comfort Optimization
AI Navigator

Ask Laika to Summarize, Analyze, and Connect papers live on the map.

Summarize Papers & Methodologies

Extract key findings, datasets, and comparative methods across publications.

Benchmark Rankings & Visual Analytics

Rank top research institutions, authors, funders, topics, and journals by Field-Weighted Citation Impact (FWCI) and paper volume with instant charts.

Connect Distant Disciplines

Bridge topological clusters on the map to find hidden collaborative intersections.

Laika access coming soon